Team Mgmt. 2017 rucks – who’s number 1?

[eth-dog]

Think the general rule is you have 4, incl one project ruckman (Gach this year).

Can't see us flicking Smack unless we bring in another mature ruck

We'll flick Smack and I reckon we're one of the teams that likes Oscar McInerney from Casey. I've only seen him a few times but he's certainly impressive. What are your thoughts on the big O-Mac Yoda_?

 

[mick4]

Luey for mine will be the number one man.
As for if it's Belly, Hooker, Smack, Francis, Patton or Julian Kirzner plays the second KF, as long as they can make there opponent accountable and help Joey to be one out, I'm not to fused who plays there. Brown struggles in that role. I actually quiet like the set up when the Russian parked himself in the goal square. Belly has been in the past decent overhead and mechanically a good kick, might be able to fill that role.

 

[Rack Watts]

Can we add Cooney to the poll?
We all know he can ruck.

 

[Yoda_]

We'll flick Smack and I reckon we're one of the teams that likes Oscar McInerney from Casey. I've only seen him a few times but he's certainly impressive. What are your thoughts on the big O-Mac Yoda_?

Sorry bout the late reply. Spoke with a friend at the Scorpions and said they have huge wraps for the 203cm, 22 year old from Montrose.

Said he moves exceptionally well for a big man and is likened to an Andrew Phillips from Carlton. Won't be a star but can do a servicable job. As all big men take time, he could well worth be an option. Three clubs interested but not us as one of them apparently.

 

[eth-dog]

Sorry bout the late reply. Spoke with a friend at the Scorpions and said they have huge wraps for the 203cm, 22 year old from Montrose.

Said he moves exceptionally well for a big man and is likened to an Andrew Phillips from Carlton. Won't be a star but can do a servicable job. As all big men take time, he could well worth be an option. Three clubs interested but not us as one of them apparently.

If he's like Phillips I'll put him firmly in the do not want basket.

 

[dnbassador]

Bellchambers for a mile, Luey is terrible and Smack wont be on the list at the end of the season

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Bellchambers for a mile, Luey is terrible and Smack wont be on the list at the end of the season

Lung butter is far from terrible. I would have him ahead of Bell.

 

[Darealrath]

Leuenberger is the best at actual ruck work, and he works his ass off around the ground, but I almost cringe when we give him the footy now.

His inability to play forward also makes it really hard to find an ideal partner. A Jenkins or a younger Petrie would be ideal. A healthy Bellchambers isn't as mobile as these guys but I think he could make a decent fist of it, and I suspect Worsfold will play both, so we'll just have to wear the shortcomings.