2017 trade hypothetical thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Brander is a quality kid why not just draft him can play at both ends of the ground
We don't need someone with the versatility of playing either ends of the ground, we need a key forward who's good at what key forwards are paid to do, that is kicking goals. Brander is not that player.
 
We don't need someone with the versatility of playing either ends of the ground, we need a key forward who's good at what key forwards are paid to do, that is kicking goals. Brander is not that player.

You need a lot more than that. Including a linker like Brander.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Pick 6 > Richmond
Picks 15 + 16 > Collingwood
we probably would do that depending on draft targets. though id prefer you to add a later pick as well to help with points for naish
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

You are mad if you would not do that deal. That is a steal. Go and watch Schache's u/18 champs highlights. He is gonna be a gun, and one of the best key fwd's in the comp. I have no doubt about that.
I watched him. There's no evidence right now that he's going to be the best forward in the comp. I'm not big on paying for potential because we have been burnt before.

I do entertain the thought of trading Sidey but the club would never do it.
 
Trade 1a:
Dees receive - Jake Lever (from Crows)
Crows receive - Bryce Gibbs (from Blues), 2018 2nd rounder (From Dees)
Blues receive - Dom Tyson (From Dees), pick 45 (from Dees)

Trade 1b:
Dees receive - Jake Lever (from Crows) Pick 35 (from Crows)
Crows receive - Dom Tyson (from Dees), 2018 1st round pick (from Dees), pick 27 (from Dees)

Trade 2:
Dees receive - Andrew Gaff (from Eagles)
Eagles receive - Pick 10, 2017/2018 2nd round pick (from Dees)

Trade 3: (0.5% chance, massive curve ball)
Dees receive- Lachie Whitfield
Giants receive - Jack Watts, Pick 10


Thoughts?
I know Tyson isn't rumoured to be on the move but we are way too inside mid heavy. Tyson has good trade value and we would need to move a player like him to make a big splash in the trade period
 
Trade 1a:
Dees receive - Jake Lever (from Crows)
Crows receive - Bryce Gibbs (from Blues), 2018 2nd rounder (From Dees)
Blues receive - Dom Tyson (From Dees), pick 45 (from Dees)

Trade 1b:
Dees receive - Jake Lever (from Crows) Pick 35 (from Crows)
Crows receive - Dom Tyson (from Dees), 2018 1st round pick (from Dees), pick 27 (from Dees)

Trade 2:
Dees receive - Andrew Gaff (from Eagles)
Eagles receive - Pick 10, 2017/2018 2nd round pick (from Dees)

Trade 3: (0.5% chance, massive curve ball)
Dees receive- Lachie Whitfield
Giants receive - Jack Watts, Pick 10


Thoughts?
I know Tyson isn't rumoured to be on the move but we are way too inside mid heavy. Tyson has good trade value and we would need to move a player like him to make a big splash in the trade period
Tyson has little trade value, maybe a pick in the 20s at most. Apart from the gaff trade the other 2 favour dees way too much.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2017 trade hypothetical thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top