2018 - Best 22

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

AFL
B: Langdon Dunn Crisp
HB: Maynard Moore Howe
C: Wells Adams Sidebottom
HF: Varcoe Reid Hoskin-Elliott
F: Fasolo Cox Elliott
FOLL: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
INTER: Aish Greenwood Phillips Stephenson

VFL
B: Smith McLarty Oxley
HB: Murray Mihocek Scharenberg
C: Broomhead De Goey C.Brown
HF: Murphy Magden Blair
F: Kirby Mayne Crocker
FOLL: Lynch Thomas Wills
INTER: Daicos, T.Brown, Sier, Appleby

INJ: Goldsack

 

[Robroy22]

AFL
B: Langdon Dunn Crisp
HB: Maynard Goldsack Howe
C: Wells Adams Sidebottom
HF: DeGoey Moore Hoskin-Elliott
F: Fasolo Reid Elliott
FOLL: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
INTER: Varcoe Greenwood Phillips Stephenson

VFL
B: Smith McLarty Oxley
HB: Murray Scharenberg Murphy
C: C.Brown Sier Aish
HF: Blair Cox Broomhead
F: Kirby Mayne Crocker
FOLL: Lynch Thomas Wills
INTER: Daicos, T.Brown

I couldn't get Scharenberg in best 22. I think Bucks would prefer Goldsack but I expect Scharenberg to eventually take Goldies role. He may need to bulk up to play key position going forward in his career. He probably too slow to be a flanker in today's AFL.

Josh Daicos can't even make the VFL first string? Really?

 

[DraftBalta]

Langdon Dunn Scharenberg
Phillips Moore Pendlebury

Grundy Maynard Treloar
Hoskin De Goey Adams

Sidebottom Howe Elliott
Stephenson Reid Fasolo

Int
Wells Crisp Murray Cox

 

[Baird]

?-?-?
?-?-?
?-?-?
Murphy-?-?
?-?-?
?-Stephenson-Brown
?-?-?-?

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Langdon Dunn Scharenberg
Phillips Moore Pendlebury

Grundy Maynard Treloar
Hoskin De Goey Adams

Sidebottom Howe Elliott
Stephenson Reid Fasolo

Int
Wells Crisp Murray Cox

Wells on the I/C?

jackcass

 

[donnie5]

FB: Maynard - Dunn - Crisp
HB: Murray - Reid - Howe
C: Wells - Treloar - Varcoe
HF: De Goey - Moore - Sidebottom
FF: Elliot - Cox - Fasolo
FOLL: Grundy - Adams - Pendlebury

INT: Stephenson - WHE - Goldsack - Greenwood

EMERGENCIES: Phillips, Murphy, Scharenberg

Positives:

- We finally look like we’ve got some serious pace now with Stephenson, Wells, Murray and Treloar.

- Midfield is very strong.

- We have some X-Factor with this team with players like Elliot, Fasolo, Sidebottom, Varcoe, Wells and Stephenson.

- Great intercept markers across half back.


Negatives:

- Seriously lacking key position depth, we’re an injury to Reid or Moore away from complete disaster.

- Does that midfield run both ways?

- Can Cox, Grundy and Moore co-exist?


I feel like we made a mistake in drafting Murphy over a KKP. I really hope he proves me wrong, let’s hope he’s as good as most on this board believe him to be. We must have our eyes set on next seasons draft in terms of KKP’s because it is very interesting that we didn’t draft one right now considering how light we were this season in those positions and next season we’ll be even lighter with delistings + the retirement of White.

 

[DraftBalta]

Wells on the I/C?

jackcass

Just for him

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Josh Daicos can't even make the VFL first string? Really?

The small VFL forwards I have in the team has more runs on the board. Once Blair is delisted, Daics will take his place.

 

[mike123]

The small VFL forwards I have in the team has more runs on the board. Once Blair is delisted, Daics will take his place.

Lel

 

[THATSGOLD]

How is Stephenson automatic best 22?

 

[MightyRoar]

How is Stephenson automatic best 22?

Not sure he's an "automatic" walk up start but with what he offers and what we need he's certainly in mine and many others best 22 ol mate

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Be really interesting if the new or newish players who can break in to best 22 ongoing.

do we see the emergence of Sier or Murray or Stephenson or Murphy...

Or Kirby?

Or the breakout year we've waited for from Aish or Broomhead.

Then Daicos?

Does Cox burst out as ongoing best 22 troubling defences and rucking types?

Be fascinating

 

[Men of Steele]

FB: Maynard - Dunn - Crisp
HB: Murray - Reid - Howe
C: Wells - Treloar - Varcoe
HF: De Goey - Moore - Sidebottom
FF: Elliot - Cox - Fasolo
FOLL: Grundy - Adams - Pendlebury

INT: Stephenson - WHE - Goldsack - Greenwood

EMERGENCIES: Phillips, Murphy, Scharenberg

Positives:

- We finally look like we’ve got some serious pace now with Stephenson, Wells, Murray and Treloar.

- Midfield is very strong.

- We have some X-Factor with this team with players like Elliot, Fasolo, Sidebottom, Varcoe, Wells and Stephenson.

- Great intercept markers across half back.


Negatives:

- Seriously lacking key position depth, we’re an injury to Reid or Moore away from complete disaster.

- Does that midfield run both ways?

- Can Cox, Grundy and Moore co-exist?


I feel like we made a mistake in drafting Murphy over a KKP. I really hope he proves me wrong, let’s hope he’s as good as most on this board believe him to be. We must have our eyes set on next seasons draft in terms of KKP’s because it is very interesting that we didn’t draft one right now considering how light we were this season in those positions and next season we’ll be even lighter with delistings + the retirement of White.

What's a KKP and who would you have taken that is one that was still on the board?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Matt_352]

FB: Maynard - Dunn - Crisp
HB: Murray - Reid - Howe
C: Wells - Treloar - Varcoe
HF: De Goey - Moore - Sidebottom
FF: Elliot - Cox - Fasolo
FOLL: Grundy - Adams - Pendlebury

INT: Stephenson - WHE - Goldsack - Greenwood

EMERGENCIES: Phillips, Murphy, Scharenberg

Positives:

- We finally look like we’ve got some serious pace now with Stephenson, Wells, Murray and Treloar.

- Midfield is very strong.

- We have some X-Factor with this team with players like Elliot, Fasolo, Sidebottom, Varcoe, Wells and Stephenson.

- Great intercept markers across half back.


Negatives:

- Seriously lacking key position depth, we’re an injury to Reid or Moore away from complete disaster.

- Does that midfield run both ways?

- Can Cox, Grundy and Moore co-exist?


I feel like we made a mistake in drafting Murphy over a KKP. I really hope he proves me wrong, let’s hope he’s as good as most on this board believe him to be. We must have our eyes set on next seasons draft in terms of KKP’s because it is very interesting that we didn’t draft one right now considering how light we were this season in those positions and next season we’ll be even lighter with delistings + the retirement of White.

Pick up Butts and Collins in rookie drsft would sort kpp depth

 

[Darkyprotector]

FB: Maynard - Dunn - Crisp
HB: Murray - Reid - Howe
C: Wells - Treloar - Varcoe
HF: De Goey - Moore - Sidebottom
FF: Elliot - Cox - Fasolo
FOLL: Grundy - Adams - Pendlebury

INT: Stephenson - WHE - Goldsack - Greenwood

EMERGENCIES: Phillips, Murphy, Scharenberg

Positives:

- We finally look like we’ve got some serious pace now with Stephenson, Wells, Murray and Treloar.

- Midfield is very strong.

- We have some X-Factor with this team with players like Elliot, Fasolo, Sidebottom, Varcoe, Wells and Stephenson.

- Great intercept markers across half back.


Negatives:

- Seriously lacking key position depth, we’re an injury to Reid or Moore away from complete disaster.

- Does that midfield run both ways?

- Can Cox, Grundy and Moore co-exist?


I feel like we made a mistake in drafting Murphy over a KKP. I really hope he proves me wrong, let’s hope he’s as good as most on this board believe him to be. We must have our eyes set on next seasons draft in terms of KKP’s because it is very interesting that we didn’t draft one right now considering how light we were this season in those positions and next season we’ll be even lighter with delistings + the retirement of White.

Yeah I like it
Pace is the key in transition and footy smarts
Cameron and Lynch from Adelaide showed that
As we plan 5 years ahead we know ;
Young Kelly is a key back and has been with us for years as a daicos academy member , gonna be very very good
ISSAC q will be excellent
Nick daicos enough said
Also big pick up nt zone
Tom lynch free agent
Tom McDonald is howes and lyndons and rivers mate free agent
We e picked up Murray and Stephenson they both play
IMO
2018
Adams Dunn Howe
Murray Moore crisp
Wells Maynard WHE
De goey Reid Sidey
Elliot cox daicos
Grundy pendles AT
Stephenson varcoe fasolo sack

 

[Darkyprotector]

Be really interesting if the new or newish players who can break in to best 22 ongoing.

do we see the emergence of Sier or Murray or Stephenson or Murphy...

Or Kirby?

Or the breakout year we've waited for from Aish or Broomhead.

Then Daicos?

Does Cox burst out as ongoing best 22 troubling defences and rucking types?

Be fascinating

The great thing today is renewed hope
Great point and illustrates where on the cusp of something better
I think we now have an established core of 14/ 17 capable of beating anyone
Cox goes half as well as I and others think finals are a cert ( injuries permitting )
Core group
Dunn, Howe, Moore , de goey , Grundy, crisp, pendels , Sidey, wells , treloer, Adams, WHE , Maynard , Reid , varcoe,Elliot , sack
Need as you pointed out 5 of the slow starters to get going
I want wills, cox, Murray ,Stephenson and Kirby to be that 5
Lots of others to pick from too

 

[DraftBalta]

How is Stephenson automatic best 22?

I like to call it... the Daisy factor


will walk in

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I like to call it... the Daisy factor


will walk in

What are we going to do about your Richmond name ?

 

[DraftBalta]

What are we going to do about your Richmond name ?

negotiations ongoing

 

[magpies42]

AFL
B: Langdon Dunn Crisp
HB: Maynard Goldsack Howe
C: Wells Adams Sidebottom
HF: DeGoey Moore Hoskin-Elliott
F: Fasolo Reid Elliott
FOLL: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
INTER: Varcoe Greenwood Phillips Stephenson

VFL
B: Smith McLarty Oxley
HB: Murray Scharenberg Murphy
C: C.Brown Sier Aish
HF: Blair Cox Broomhead
F: Kirby Mayne Crocker
FOLL: Lynch Thomas Wills
INTER: Daicos, T.Brown

I couldn't get Scharenberg in best 22. I think Bucks would prefer Goldsack but I expect Scharenberg to eventually take Goldies role. He may need to bulk up to play key position going forward in his career. He probably too slow to be a flanker in today's AFL.

Surely Shaz gets a gig ahead of Langdon, and Phillips isn’t best 22 for mine. He’s too panicked, one paced and weak...maybe in a couple of years. I’d prefer to try out Murray, Aish, Cox, Broomhead, Mclarty, Thomas or wills. Basically anybody because I don’t think he’ll make the grade and also because the others have more upside

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Surely Shaz gets a gig ahead of Langdon, and Phillips isn’t best 22 for mine. He’s too panicked, one paced and weak...maybe in a couple of years. I’d prefer to try out Murray, Aish, Cox, Broomhead, Mclarty, Thomas or wills. Basically anybody because I don’t think he’ll make the grade and also because the others have more upside

Langdon has been better than Scharanberg to date. I am rewarding performance over potential.
Likewise Phillips over the likes of Aish, Broomhead, but I acknowledge Phillips (along with Stephenson) are probably the 21st and 22nd player. Therefore you can remove one of them and go with an extra tall (Cox) or go with more inside midfield grunt (Thomas) or another small forward who will press and tackle (Blair/Mayne/Broomhead).
Murray NEAFL form wasn’t that outstanding in that he automatically becomes best 22. He’s behind Maynard, Crisp, Varcoe for a small running defender role. Maybe Aish too.

 

[Good Degoe]

What are we going to do about your Richmond name ?

There we goey

 

[Horaceg]

B: Sharenberg Dunn Crisp
HB: Maynard Reid Howe
C: Wells Adams Sidebottom
HF: DeGoey Moore Hoskin-Elliott
F: Fasolo Cox Elliott
FOLL: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
INTER: Varcoe Aish Phillips Daicos

 

[well left]

I think if Moore goes back then Goldsack goes forward.

Backs: Dunn and Moore with Langdon/Scharenberg/Howe capable of playing tall. McLarty developing.

Forwards: Reid and Cox with Goldsack as 3rd tall and pressure forward. Stephenson/WHE and possibly Wills or Sier all capable of playing as a 3rd tall and Elliott/Fasolo/De Goey dangerous out of the square.

I think we need more KPs developing at VFL but we do have flexibility in our bigs which may save us.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ottoman]

Be really interesting if the new or newish players who can break in to best 22 ongoing.

do we see the emergence of Sier or Murray or Stephenson or Murphy...

Or Kirby?

Or the breakout year we've waited for from Aish or Broomhead.

Then Daicos?

Does Cox burst out as ongoing best 22 troubling defences and rucking types?

Be fascinating

You can lock Cox in Mr Viewed.
He is going to bedazzle next year.
Mark my words.