2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[GT619]

Are you really taking a photo of your ipad?

Yeah unfortunately. Laptop not working

 

[Dark Sharks]

Don't be mirin, none of you even lift.

 

[Leftyitis]

Going with the traditional 4-5-4 with 2 set and forget rucks,rookies can change based on JLT..

Looks like a league win team and not the 50K winning team. What are you targeting? Good luck. A little off track, but does Gibson come straight into the 22. Cheers.

 

[jack powell]

Thoughts? Rookies will change, christensen most likely to go, thoughts on tuohy and curnow?

 

[Metapod]

Became the new unaccountable, 3rd man up, loose in defence - aka josh Gibson mk2 - halfway through last year. Will do same this year apparently.

Interesting... however that blues game sticks out where he copped a hard tag, needs to mature a bit more before scoring consistently

 

[Marlowe]

Became the new unaccountable, 3rd man up, loose in defence - aka josh Gibson mk2 - halfway through last year. Will do same this year apparently.

And averaged 91.4 from there too (hence the buzz).

 

[Gringo Star]

Progress..

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Thoughts? Rookies will change, christensen most likely to go, thoughts on tuohy and curnow?

Nice POD team.
No Danger, no worries as your bating 6 deep in the MIDS.
Gotta keep an eye on NicNat
Touhy and Smith are reasonably safe picks.
Only breakout risk is C.Curnow but the forward line is the place to take risks this year IMO.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Progress..

Not a fan of the Mitch Robinson or Rich picks but great rucks and Mids.
Some nice ballsy picks too.

You reckon Shuey breaks out a bit with Priddis gone and NicNat back?

 

[Dark Sharks]

You reckon Shuey breaks out a bit with Priddis gone and NicNat back?

That thought has definitely crossed my mind, i'd lock Shuey in if Nicnat was 100% fit and was rucking properly.

 

[atlas1]

Really not understanding the hype around this guy:

View attachment 461618

Am I missing something? 8 scores below 60, including 4 below 40... Averaged less than 75 last season, which is FAR from keeper status. Why all the hype?

This is why

 

[King_Steele]

View attachment 461658

This is why

Loves himself more than Danger & that’s saying something. Also can’t handle a tag which will happen if he kills it.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Don't be mirin, none of you even lift.


View attachment 461630

Interesting, you went Neale over Fyfe .......rationale ?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

View attachment 461545

Too deep in the midfield and too weak up forward I reckon. If Sicily scores a few of those 40s its like playing 4 rookies in you forward line but only 1 in your mids where they are usually better scorers.
Id consider downgrading one of JOM or Coniglio and upgrading Sicily
OR move Sicily down back for Yeo and getting two decent forwards.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

That thought has definitely crossed my mind, i'd lock Shuey in if Nicnat was 100% fit and was rucking properly.

I still dont see it. 105 average. 110 would be a Brownlow year for Shuedog

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Loves himself more than Danger & that’s saying something. Also can’t handle a tag which will happen if he kills it.

No previous scoring history, no guaranteed role, plays for a non SC friendly team, is an awkward price and a flog. No thanks.

 

[King_Steele]

Post AFLX. Yeah baby.

7k left over

Thoughts Here2tellyouwhy

 

[Gringo Star]

You reckon Shuey breaks out a bit with Priddis gone and NicNat back?

Absoulutly, I'l throw it out there and say he just about broke out this year. Can hardly fault his last year.
Rich and Mitch were just thrown in there on AFLX, they'll be out soon, no doubt.
Appreciate the feedback

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Post AFLX. Yeah baby.

7k left over

Thoughts Here2tellyouwhy

View attachment 461663
View attachment 461664
View attachment 461666

Richards at D4 or any Rookie at D4 would make me nervous ......but the rest of the side is great

 

[King_Steele]

Richards at D4 or any Rookie at D4 would make me nervous ......but the rest of the side is great

Absolutely.

Sort of the price for getting more “sure things” as premos

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Absolutely.

Sort of the price for getting more “sure things” as premos

Just cannot find sure fire DEF Rookies ......having 3 on field .....

 

[bomberland33]

Pretty content on this team until JLT starts

 

[King_Steele]

Just cannot find sure fire DEF Rookies ......having 3 on field .....

Cumming - apparently the one for Williams role
Gardner - No Henderson until round 4 at the latest
Murray - Pies traded for him
Doedee- lock, Lever replacement
Morgan-needs to prove himself, Roos should play him to see what he can offer
Richards - Dogs can’t speak highly enough of him & Bevo doesn’t mind playing the kids
O’Brien - You’d think Blues would play him as they need elite talent in the side

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Cumming - apparently the one for Williams role
Gardner - No Henderson until round 4 at the latest
Murray - Pies traded for him
Doedee- lock, Lever replacement
Morgan-needs to prove himself, Roos should play him to see what he can offer
Richards - Dogs can’t speak highly enough of him & Bevo doesn’t mind playing the kids
O’Brien - You’d think Blues would play him as they need elite talent in the side

ATM the only player you'd have confidence of continuous games, would be Doedee ......the others, 3-4 games stints averaging 50's ....

Maybe Murray ......but haven't seen him play ?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Interesting, you went Neale over Fyfe .......rationale ?

Well i've got both... BUT i prefer Neale because he's quality and POD.

Fyfes ownership is currently at 41% Might jump off him before lockout, if he implodes everyone is going to look like a dickhead whilst i really won't lose much if he comes out firing, can always jump on later.