2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[CatFan79]

Apart from those minor dilemmas i'm all but set!

I'd be a bit worried about copping a donut in F6.

 

[KardiniaPark]

View attachment 469419Hey guys,

Please give me your feedback, only got $9k left over..

Much appreciated

Sicily to Cyril. Brayshaw to anyone that’s not Brayshaw.

 

[KardiniaPark]

I'd look at making a downgrade or 2 to get some cash so you can upgrade Lycett to a proper ruck.

Wash your mouth out.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Ryan and Fogerty are the one two rookies that might change, but the rest is set.

Bring on Rd 1

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

I'd be a bit worried about copping a donut in F6.

I’d prefer to save the $100k odd instead of opting for the only real option in Christensen, who is hardly worth forking out the extra cash for. Also, there aren’t a plethora of rookies to choose from, and those guys are the best of a bad bunch IMO.

Confident one of Ryan, Langdon or Garlett will be playing at any one time. Not ideal, but it’ll be one of the first spots I’ll try and upgrade once cashcows start generating some cash.

 

[pincrusher]

Minor changes, you heartless bastards.View attachment 469328

My head hurts just looking at that team.

 

[BillingsMagic]

Minor changes, you heartless bastards.View attachment 469328

 

[Judd_Magic]

Ryan and Fogerty are the one two rookies that might change, but the rest is set.

Bring on Rd 1

View attachment 469468

I don't mind that team at all mate.

Has a few different selections to separate it from the cookie cutter teams.

 

[JRyan23]

So the plan is to avg 100 until when? Then upgrade?

Might upgrade before the bye but if scoring very well and looking like a top 25 mid, then ill hold him for the main 3 bye rounds

 

[pincrusher]

Nank or Sandi I reckon.

They should both score well till at least when Ryder comes off his bye.

That way if Sandi is injured by then or if Nank has run out of petrol it wll be a great swap that wont cost you much coin.

I'm backing Nank to be close to the number 1 ruck by season's end. Perfect age profile for a big man. 21 disposals and 7 tackles in 2nd JLT suggests to me that he has considerably built his tank over the off season.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'm backing Nank to be close to the number 1 ruck by season's end. Perfect age profile for a big man. 21 disposals and 7 tackles in 2nd JLT suggests to me that he has considerably built his tank over the off season.

Man I just went from Nank to Sandilands. LOL!

Now you have me second guessing again! Hah!

 

[pincrusher]

Man I just went from Nank to Sandilands. LOL!

Now you have me second guessing again! Hah!

I originally had Kreuzer, but with the lack of R3 and FWD swing options I was worried about a donut given he can cop the odd injury. Nank I think is good value at his price. At the end of the day, I reckon Nank could be a keeper. No way I could say the same about Sandi, so barring injury there is already a trade saved.

 

[buttox]

Minor changes, you heartless bastards.View attachment 469328

Worst team I've seen this year.
You need to go to too serious look up who's a good scorer.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I originally had Kreuzer, but with the lack of R3 and FWD swing options I was worried about a donut given he can cop the odd injury. Nank I think is good value at his price. At the end of the day, I reckon Nank could be a keeper. No way I could say the same about Sandi, so barring injury there is already a trade saved.

You raise some good points mate.

Food for thought.

I need to ponder on all this now....

 

[pincrusher]

You raise some good points mate.

Food for thought.

I need to ponder on all this now....

Just don't come looking for me if Nank does his knee in the first game.

Seriously though, I just have a feeling that Nank will be one of the top rucks this year. I know there's only so much you can take out of JLT but 21 disposals and 7 tackles was significant IMO.

 

[Papa Caz]

my current team, not 100% happy with it since danger went down and now have more money to spend then i know what to do with it.

keep changing my mind with my defence, had mcgrath/sicily/mills but got coffield in at d3 the rest is basically locked in.

mids my first 5 are locked, my rookies are locked just unsure about cogs at the moment i have him just so i can upgrade to danger when he is right but i dont know if thats to much money to spend on a bloke who will be an upgrade after a few rounds.

rucks will depend on how kreuz pulls up, its either stef for kreuz for r1 and gawn is locked r2

fwd, not 100% sure on heeney he will be top 10 fwd but not sure if i trust him after his pre season. billings mclean and smith all but locked in had walters but not sure if i trust ross lyon (i hate him) rookies will change apart from fritsch he is locked and bell is iffy he will play round 1 but is fighting for his spot and not sure what role he has at brisbane, have him at the moment just cause i had left over money.

thoughts guys? kinda confused if i should have a deeper defence and lighter mid.

 

[Brick Loosener]

I originally had Kreuzer, but with the lack of R3 and FWD swing options I was worried about a donut given he can cop the odd injury. Nank I think is good value at his price. At the end of the day, I reckon Nank could be a keeper. No way I could say the same about Sandi, so barring injury there is already a trade saved.

Avoid Nank. Griggs will steal his points.

 

[JRyan23]

Anyone rate Travis Boak as a FWD/MID option, only 460k
Not sure what he scored over JLT or last year but felt like he could be a smart pick. Thoughts?

 

[stevebbb]

Anyone rate Travis Boak as a FWD/MID option, only 460k
Not sure what he scored over JLT or last year but felt like he could be a smart pick. Thoughts?

Was super keen on him before I saw this

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/2018-03-09/boak-out-of-jlt-clash

The skipper will sit out the game as a precaution after reporting some hamstring tightness.

I know it's only precaution, but since he's been hampered by injuries the last couple years and hasn't been able to run properly, this is not what I want to see

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I don't mind that team at all mate.

Has a few different selections to separate it from the cookie cutter teams.

Hoping for not too many changes. Just would like to nail a few rookies

 

[buttox]

Figure Cameron is probably going to play more games than Keeffe and make more $$ at the same price, so downgraded Keeffe to a rolling donut in Mihocek, who I think could be some chance of games later on off the back of Goldy's injury. Tossing between him and Murphy from the Crows, so will wait and see upon round one selections.

Also changed Sandi to Nank, as I just can't trust Lurch's body (even though I think he'll outscore Nank in the short term). But I also think Nank can improve on last year's effort of shouldering the #1 ruck role for the first time in his career.

Am also chopping and changing between Bont and Selwood; the latter of whom could take a greater share of the points in Danger's absence. Still 50/50 right up until the first bounce.

Apart from those minor dilemmas i'm all but set!

View attachment 469435

Cameron plays Sunday r1.
Use him first round as loop IMO.
Pretty sure you will have someone dropped/injured r2. We all will.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Man I just went from Nank to Sandilands. LOL!

Now you have me second guessing again! Hah!

I have been flipping between Nank v Sandi... You just know Sandi will get injured at some point, question is...when.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Ok...some more tweaks but I'm feeling like I am getting there....Any feedback??

 

[buttox]

I’d prefer to save the $100k odd instead of opting for the only real option in Christensen, who is hardly worth forking out the extra cash for. Also, there aren’t a plethora of rookies to choose from, and those guys are the best of a bad bunch IMO.

Confident one of Ryan, Langdon or Garlett will be playing at any one time. Not ideal, but it’ll be one of the first spots I’ll try and upgrade once cashcows start generating some cash.

Rayner.
Number 1 pick with dpp and got 70 odd this week in jlt. Plays for what most peeps consider to be the 2nd worst team in the comp so should play every week.
Realise he is expensive. So was macgrath last year.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Anyone rate Travis Boak as a FWD/MID option, only 460k
Not sure what he scored over JLT or last year but felt like he could be a smart pick. Thoughts?

getting old
SC average declining since 2014
lots of new players at Port. uncertainty over role
round 10 bye
hamstring tightness

pass