List Mgmt. 2018 St Kilda Trade Thread Part 1

[VDS66]

We should offer McGovern $1m per year over 6...

 

[JG22]

We should offer De Goey $1m per year over 6...

true

 

[Gangnam Saint]

If the filth are genuinely going to let De Goey leave then you can bet the problems are even deeper than we know.
DO NOT WANT.

 

[triggering bro]

If the filth are genuinely going to let De Goey leave then you can bet the problems are even deeper than we know.
DO NOT WANT.

They were trying to offload him last year but no one wanted him. Makes me want him more tbh. Just the wildcard we need imo

 

[STK2020]

We should offer McGovern $1m per year over 6...

Seems to be the standard offer we are throwing about , i think we have a real reluctance to pay more when countered.

 

[plugger66]

We should offer McGovern $1m per year over 6...

Or we could offer Degoey less and use him even better. No idea if we or him are interested but he would ideal. Don’t care what he has done outside the game previously


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[ScrappyDo]

Careful, we are looking for a forum whipping boy. Those that have seen through our thin veneer of civility will be the first in line for persecution.

Anywhere, Anytime, mofos.

 

[triggering bro]

Or we could offer Degoey less and use him even better. No idea if we or him are interested but he would ideal. Don’t care what he has done outside the game previously


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In terms of getting a talented player like JDG, we just need to make it happen. He’ll probably get 500k max at the Pies, we’d probably need to throw an extra 200 on top of that. It seems a bit extreme & it would make him close to the highest paid player on our list however that’s what it would take to get him imo. Give him 5yrs on 700k a year. I reckon it’ll pay off in 2 years time.

 

[Gangnam Saint]

They were trying to offload him last year but no one wanted him. Makes me want him more tbh. Just the wildcard we need imo

Maybe I'm just jaded but I know this would end badly for us.

 

[JG22]

In terms of getting a talented player like JDG, we just need to make it happen. He’ll probably get 500k max at the Pies, we’d probably need to throw an extra 200 on top of that. It seems a bit extreme & it would make him close to the highest paid player on our list however that’s what it would take to get him imo. Give him 5yrs on 700k a year. I reckon it’ll pay off in 2 years time.

Great point raised, do our list management team have the balls to do that?

Such a seemingly happy list with no one leaving over the last few years, would that potentially piss guys off that a bloke walks in on more than them without playing any really good consistent footy.

Guess they wouldn't mind if he turns out the gun.

 

[St Kilda Death]

If the filth are genuinely going to let De Goey leave then you can bet the problems are even deeper than we know.
DO NOT WANT.

Because no one has ever been a ratbag in their early 20s and turned out ok.

 

[triggering bro]

Great point raised, do our list management team have the balls to do that?

Such a seemingly happy list with no one leaving over the last few years, would that potentially piss guys off that a bloke walks in on more than them without playing any really good consistent footy.

Guess they wouldn't mind if he turns out the gun.

Let’s face it, with a standard salary cap across the league, our players have been riding the gravy train by getting massive overs. Blokes like Newnes are likely getting paid as much as Sloane. I’m sure they’ll understand if we bring in a couple of new blokes on salaries that are above market value. I hope we have the balls to make it happen.

 

[triggering bro]

Maybe I'm just jaded but I know this would end badly for us.

It’s a risk but looking at the teams that have recently won flags, they’ve all taken risks at the trade table & invested heavily in trades. Building primarily from the draft with good blokes hasn’t ended well for teams.

Most laughed at the Tigers for spending two first round picks on Prestia & getting the ‘bust’ Caddy.

Most laughed at the Dogs for trading in Boyd, he was close to BOG in a flag.

The Hawks & Swans have built their teams by trading in established & somewhat risky players.

The Cats, & a bit earlier, the Eagles, are the last teams to win flags without a significant amount of players traded in.

 

[ScrappyDo]

I agree with all that .
But what if .......
We could get Root Rat and retain our 1st pick this years draft ?

Spot on point.
Simple risk v reward sceario. If we can get him cheap enough, then we do it coz horse trading is the business we're in.

 

[gringo2011]

Because no one has ever been a ratbag in their early 20s and turned out ok.

No but if we drafted them they end up borderline sociopaths with tendencies toward a range of criminal activities.

 

[VDS66]

Or we could offer Degoey less and use him even better. No idea if we or him are interested but he would ideal. Don’t care what he has done outside the game previously


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Not really. Just messing with you and trying to cheer you up.

 

[VDS66]

They were trying to offload him last year but no one wanted him. Makes me want him more tbh. Just the wildcard we need imo

No one wanted Dusty either...

 

[VDS66]

Great point raised, do our list management team have the balls to do that?

Such a seemingly happy list with no one leaving over the last few years, would that potentially piss guys off that a bloke walks in on more than them without playing any really good consistent footy.

Guess they wouldn't mind if he turns out the gun.

Beat me to the punch... No pun intended.

Yes we have the balls if we rate him.

If our younger players improve, they will get paid more so don't see a problem.

 

[ScrappyDo]

Great point raised, do our list management team have the balls to do that?

Such a seemingly happy list with no one leaving over the last few years, would that potentially piss guys off that a bloke walks in on more than them without playing any really good consistent footy.

Guess they wouldn't mind if he turns out the gun.

Salary space should be a non issue and I see no need to pay him overs first up. It's all down to what the Cwood demand as trade. Historically Bucks does not do well with bad boys, and if JDG wants out then he can simply not sign a new contract and the club will have to take what they can get. Same as the Stringer scenario sort of.

 

[VDS66]

No but if we drafted them they end up borderline sociopaths with tendencies toward a range of criminal activities.

Just like Michael Gardner did...

 

[Joffaboy]

In terms of getting a talented player like JDG, we just need to make it happen. He’ll probably get 500k max at the Pies, we’d probably need to throw an extra 200 on top of that. It seems a bit extreme & it would make him close to the highest paid player on our list however that’s what it would take to get him imo. Give him 5yrs on 700k a year. I reckon it’ll pay off in 2 years time.

Considering there are some overpaid campaigners on our list @ 2018 ( we are paying 100% of the cap) I dont mind ovetpaying the little headcase.

He might calm down and become a good citizen like Jake the Snake.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sab22]

JDG Want.

 

[Hayes4PM]

Imagine if De Goey wasn’t a dickhead

 

[Saint_Matt]

1. Dayne Beams goes okay
2. They haven't had many good players they drafted to be poached
3. A future second for a guy taken with pick 10 two years earlier is a great deal

Fair call on Beams. We need to get Freezer on the park before it's a good deal though. Would love De Goey and he is turning it on today. However, it will be a first rounder unless he acts up again.

 

[SainterOf92]

De goey Please