Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread

[Turbocat]

No from Adelaide. Take Crouch and Cunningham out of the deal and the Crows might say yes.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Edit:

So.. trade P8 out for P1,P23 in... ? I can see how you would want that deal

What would you really give to get the deal done for P1 Kristof

 

[Drewie11]

So.. trade P8 out for P1,P23 and Cuningham in... ? I can see how you would want that deal

What would you really give to get the deal done for P1 Kristof

It says Cunningham out of the deal.

 

[Turbocat]

It says Cunningham out of the deal.

Oh OK that much better P8 for P1 and P23

 

[Drewie11]

Oh OK that much better P8 for P1 and P23

It’s actually pick 8 and McGovern so Carlton get Cerra but cool story.

Personally still not enough for pick 1 though

 

[Shaz2012]

Oh OK that much better P8 for P1 and P23

No. We also lose Gov in that deal. It’s a no from me. It might be a acceptable if Gov was uncontracted. We need huge overs to let go a highly valued and highly paid player 1 year after signing a 3 year extension.

 

[Turbocat]

It’s actually pick 8 and McGovern so Carlton get Cerra but cool story.

Personally still not enough for pick 1 though

Id think three way deal are notoriously hard to work out... all good fun on here...

 

[M Malice]

Sam Weideman can't get much of a go at the Demons with Tom McDonald and Jesse Hogan in front of him, not OOC till 2019, what would it take to get him out of the Demons?

 

[Shaz2012]

Sam Weideman can't get much of a go at the Demons with Tom McDonald and Jesse Hogan in front of him, not OOC till 2019, what would it take to get him out of the Demons?

Huge overs this year. A bargain when he is OOC if he still hasn’t broken in or shown a lot more than he has so far.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Harry Dear, what’s your thoughts Adelaide supporters?

 

[Drewie11]

Pick 14 or where Melbourne finish and McGovern to the Dogs for pick 5

Pick 8, 19 and 2019 first and second to Carlton for Pick 1.

Are these close to fair deals?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

You are soooooooo dreaming

 

[Crow till I die]

Pick 14 or where Melbourne finish and McGovern to the Dogs for pick 5

Pick 8, 19 and 2019 first and second to Carlton for Pick 1.

Are these close to fair deals?

I had to double take on reading that. To summarise..the crows are dealing themselves out of this years AND next years 1st and 2nd round and losing one of their main young forwards for 2 draft picks - 1 will get Lukosius and the other MAY get rankine....I would be down at the club with a gibbet for the recruitment manager if they signed off on that

 

[Hammer time 2018]

Pick 14 or where Melbourne finish and McGovern to the Dogs for pick 5

Pick 8, 19 and 2019 first and second to Carlton for Pick 1.

Are these close to fair deals?

Don't think Carlton would be after more pucks

Oh OK that much better P8 for P1 and P23

Wouldn't have thought so. With some of the academy/ father son selections pick 8 could become pick 10. By then the top teir mids will most likely be gone.

Carlton would be looking for atleast one established player if they want to trade pick one I recon.

 

[Drewie11]

I had to double take on reading that. To summarise..the crows are dealing themselves out of this years AND next years 1st and 2nd round and losing one of their main young forwards for 2 draft picks - 1 will get Lukosius and the other MAY get rankine....I would be down at the club with a gibbet for the recruitment manager if they signed off on that

I would rather use the picks on Lukosius and Rankine. These guys could be absolute Guns of the future. Sometimes you got to risk it.

What do you suggest then?

 

[Drewie11]

Don't think Carlton would be after more pucks



Wouldn't have thought so. With some of the academy/ father son selections pick 8 could become pick 10. By then the top teir mids will most likely be gone.

Carlton would be looking for atleast one established player if they want to trade pick one I recon.

Adelaide keep 19 then and you get Atkins or Ellis Yoelman?

It is extremely hard to come up with trades that suit both teams and they both feel like they’ve won

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Y

Pick 14 or where Melbourne finish and McGovern to the Dogs for pick 5

Pick 8, 19 and 2019 first and second to Carlton for Pick 1.

Are these close to fair deals?

Yes

 

[Crow till I die]

I would rather use the picks on Lukosius and Rankine. These guys could be absolute Guns of the future. Sometimes you got to risk it.

What do you suggest then?

By all means look to get Lukosius and Rankine - but that is way too much to give up to do so. IMO Rankine will slip to our 1st pick as long as it is inside top 10 - ie 8. Then it becomes what will satisfy the bottom club to secure pick 1. If sloane leaves as seems likely, then it will be for band 1 compo so that and the melbourne pick and the carlton 2nd rounder might be enough in this draft as that would allow carlton to get someone in inside top 10 and use the other picks to get in a gaff or other player

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

By all means look to get Lukosius and Rankine - but that is way too much to give up to do so. IMO Rankine will slip to our 1st pick as long as it is inside top 10 - ie 8. Then it becomes what will satisfy the bottom club to secure pick 1. If sloane leaves as seems likely, then it will be for band 1 compo so that and the melbourne pick and the carlton 2nd rounder might be enough in this draft as that would allow carlton to get someone in inside top 10 and use the other picks to get in a gaff or other player

Rankine will not slide to Crows first pick.

 

[Drewie11]

By all means look to get Lukosius and Rankine - but that is way too much to give up to do so. IMO Rankine will slip to our 1st pick as long as it is inside top 10 - ie 8. Then it becomes what will satisfy the bottom club to secure pick 1. If sloane leaves as seems likely, then it will be for band 1 compo so that and the melbourne pick and the carlton 2nd rounder might be enough in this draft as that would allow carlton to get someone in inside top 10 and use the other picks to get in a gaff or other player

If Lukosius is as good as they say then get rid of McGovern because Lukosius is going to take his spot anyway.

Rankine looks like a jet, these guys look 100% like they will be great players and they’re south Australian.

This way Sloane still stays.

I don’t think pick 9 for Sloane, pick 14 and pick 19 would satisfy Carlton for puck 1

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Pick 14 or where Melbourne finish and McGovern to the Dogs for pick 5

Pick 8, 19 and 2019 first and second to Carlton for Pick 1.

Are these close to fair deals?

That seems fair to me with the exception that pick 19 this year might need to be the Sloane compo.

 

[Crow till I die]

Rankine will not slide to Crows first pick.

we will see on draft night but I think you might be in for a surprise

 

[Crow till I die]

s

That seems fair to me with the exception that pick 19 this year might need to be the Sloane compo.

o 2 x 2018 top 10 picks, a 2019 1st rounder and a 2019 2nd rounder for pick 1..not thanks. I am sure most people would want 2 very highly rated players and 2 top 20 players rather than 1 exceptional player

 

[Drewie11]

That seems fair to me with the exception that pick 19 this year might need to be the Sloane compo.

If that’s what Adelaide would get for Sloane then I hope he decides to stay

 

[Drewie11]

s

o 2 x 2018 top 10 picks, a 2019 1st rounder and a 2019 2nd rounder for pick 1..not thanks. I am sure most people would want 2 very highly rated players and 2 top 20 players rather than 1 exceptional player

Where are the 2 x 2018 top 10 picks?

 

[Crow till I die]

Where are the 2 x 2018 top 10 picks?

the band 1 sloane compo was suggested in lieu of pick 19 from your original post