Prediction 2019 "Hypothetical Trade, FA, random player you wish we could get" thread..

[List Manager]

Potential GWS trades for Pittonet:

Pittonet and pick 50 for Patton and pick 40 (Tomlinson compo) = GWS get Patton salary dump and add Pittonet for 10 pick downgrade.

Or

Pittonet and pick 11 for Patton, pick 12 and pick 60 = extra points for GWS Greene draft bid plus Pittonet plus Patton salary dump more or less trading Pittonet pick pick 60. Still take picks 18 and 40 to the draft (or use on other trades) as well as getting Tom Greene at pick 11.
Hawks maintain access to same kid in the draft they would have with pick 11 knowing Giants take Greene at 11 but gain pick 60 adding points for Finn draft bid.

Pick 50 goes to Dees for Frost.

Hawks (excluding any additional trades) walk away with picks 12, 30 (Finn), 60 (Finn match with points left over = additional late pick back), Frost and Patton

 

[Zack]

I'd still like Luke Hodge but he's old now.

 

[matsta1975]

I know him personally through a friend, average player doesn’t work hard enough and bit of a flog bloke at times.

Each club has 10 blokes on a list that are flogs some of the time in regards to being an average player I don't know him but on an AFL list mid first round pick and a few clubs enquiring so must have some attributes that can be utilized

 

[Mojo]

Make em pay up. 2nd rounder. We need him on our list.

Absolutely!

Spent 5 years developing this bloke. Improved year-on-year. I'm not sure we've seen his ceiling just yet, and I'm definitely curious how much improvement he's got left.

 

[kazzooka]

Mitch Cleary reporting on Trade Radio the deal is done to Geelong in principle and will go through as soon as tomorrow. Pick 14, 24 and 2020 first. No mention of us being included sorry

Jeez that is a hefty price. While Geelong would be disappointed to lose him can't complain about turning 24 into 14,24 (in a significantly stronger draft) and another pick in the teens for 2020.
Could get a few good players with those picks.

My guess is more than Tim Kelly has to go west coasts way right? You can't trade 1 player for 3 top 25 picks.

 

[Squirk]

Potential GWS trades for Pittonet:

Pittonet and pick 50 for Patton and pick 40 (Tomlinson compo) = GWS get Patton salary dump and add Pittonet for 10 pick downgrade.

Or

Pittonet and pick 11 for Patton, pick 12 and pick 60 = extra points for GWS Greene draft bid plus Pittonet plus Patton salary dump more or less trading Pittonet pick pick 60. Still take picks 18 and 40 to the draft (or use on other trades) as well as getting Tom Greene at pick 11.
Hawks maintain access to same kid in the draft they would have with pick 11 knowing Giants take Greene at 11 but gain pick 60 adding points for Finn draft bid.

Pick 50 goes to Dees for Frost.

Hawks (excluding any additional trades) walk away with picks 12, 30 (Finn), 60 (Finn match with points left over = additional late pick back), Frost and Patton

I think a major risk of the second option is if GWS package up our old pick (11) to try and get in before a Greene bid. If that happens then we just let another team get access to a player that we might rate highly. If they keep it, however, and choose to match then the pick 12 would return to being a pick 11. It would be risky just hoping that they dont bundle the first rounders up.

 

[WWSD]

Pittonet does not have high market value. I’d be surprised if any club offered more than a 3rd round pick.

 

[tige19]

Pitt has zero value

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Carlton have picks 43 and 48.

I’d be pretty happy with us sending Pitto and Pick 50 for Carlton’s two picks.

 

[List Manager]

Carlton have picks 41 and 46.

I’d be pretty happy with us sending Pitto and Pick 47 for Carlton’s two picks.

I think they have 43 and 48 now. We have 50

 

[Hawk the Talk]

Carlton have picks 41 and 46.

I’d be pretty happy with us sending Pitto and Pick 47 for Carlton’s two picks.

That would actually be a very good result.
One pick for Frost and the other for Finn points.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

 

[Geelongsuck]

Petch from WCE potentially going to explore his options in Victoria, hawks norf dogs interested. Eagles tight on cap with Kelly coming in. Would love to have petch so electric perfect pop replacment

 

[tige19]

Carlton have picks 43 and 48.

I’d be pretty happy with us sending Pitto and Pick 50 for Carlton’s two picks.

100%.. well need all the picks we can get

 

[tige19]

Petch from WCE potentially going to explore his options in Victoria, hawks saints norf dogs interested. Eagles tight on cap with Kelly coming in. Would love to have petch so electric perfect pop replacment

Bloody hell, now that would be a pick up..

 

[Geelongsuck]

Bloody hell, now that would be a pick up..

Eagles really keen on keeping him tho, as they’ve lot Rioli but **** he would be a ripper pickup if we could do it

 

[MrPremiership]

Petch from WCE potentially going to explore his options in Victoria, hawks saints norf dogs interested. Eagles tight on cap with Kelly coming in. Would love to have petch so electric perfect pop replacment

Where has that been reported?

what would he cost?

 

[tige19]

Where has that been reported?

what would he cost?

A goal a game forward with elite speed, he isn’t a brilliant pressure forward but we can train that into him.. I’d say he is worth a pick in the late 20s, but not 1st round.

 

[Geelongsuck]

Gaff to a big Victorian club talk just won’t go away... when there is smoke there is fire. I hope he is the “interstate “ mid we are after. Pick 11 would do it

 

[pipcoo]

Frost still in the game any News ?

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Petch from WCE potentially going to explore his options in Victoria, hawks saints norf dogs interested. Eagles tight on cap with Kelly coming in. Would love to have petch so electric perfect pop replacment

Are you just lifting that from the AFL Insider TRADE News facebook page?

I reckon anything that starts with "Hawks and Saints" as one of 12 interested clubs is just BS.

 

[Mitchell54]

Petch from WCE potentially going to explore his options in Victoria, hawks saints norf dogs interested. Eagles tight on cap with Kelly coming in. Would love to have petch so electric perfect pop replacment

I'm not a big fan of Petch tbh but if Clarko likes him then I'll go along for the ride.

 

[The Kipster]

Petch and Frost plenty of pace but both are pressure packs and spray there kicks.

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

What's the source for Petch leaving? His manager was on trade radio today and said he was very happy at WCE and wasn't going anywhere.

 

[Geelongsuck]

What's the source for Petch leaving? His manager was on trade radio today and said he was very happy at WCE and wasn't going anywhere.

This person I know has a connection with the petch family, he is keen to get back to vic at some stage this year if possible.