2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Red Syrah]

Hmmmm agreed Gresh_Magic. Don’t like Worpel at F3, but can Gus and Piggy coexist? Maybe I should go Beams and Walters

The question is if there is room for gus to improve and so far it seems there is. If he can increase his avg by 10 pts then he is good value. Lots of teams have had multiple premo mids at the same time.

 

[Jiska]

I hate my defence but my mids are sex on a stick

My mids are better

 

[Red Syrah]

Laird, Whitfield & Neale
V
Hurn, Crisp & Macrae

Option 2. Hurn and crisp look solid and macrae at least 10 pts above neale

 

[Old Stuckup]

Neale and B Smith vs Crisp and Rockliff/Sheed

 

[Girthquake]

Laird, Whitfield & Neale
V
Hurn, Crisp & Macrae

#2!!

 

[Jiska]

Neale and B Smith vs Crisp and Rockliff/Sheed

Neale and Smith although Neale’s love affair with the handball is concerning and not sure he can improve much.

 

[Girthquake]

Neale and B Smith vs Crisp and Rockliff/Sheed

Crisp & Sheed, think sheed may have more upside than Bsmith so that gets option 2 over the line for me

 

[cherrypie]

Moore + Williams
vs
Balta + Whitfield

 

[JRyan23]

Sheed and BSmith
or
Neale/Coniglio and Scrim


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[stevebbb]

Moore + Gus Brayshaw + Walters + $43.6k for rookie corrections/savings
vs
Scrimshaw + Macrae + Billings + $9.6k

 

[stevebbb]

Moore + Williams
vs
Balta + Whitfield

Moore and Williams
I'm not sold on Moore, but Williams is a must-have imo

 

[stevebbb]

Sheed and BSmith
or
Neale/Coniglio and Scrim


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Sheed and Smith. Mid-price madness baby!

 

[JRyan23]

Moore + Gus Brayshaw + Walters + $43.6k for rookie corrections/savings
vs
Scrimshaw + Macrae + Billings + $9.6k

Second


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Judd_Magic]

Need some advice on last 2 spots in my team.

Oliver vs Brayshaw

T.Kelly vs Gray vs Darling

 

[stevebbb]

Need some advice on last 2 spots in my team.

Oliver vs Brayshaw

T.Kelly vs Gray vs Darling

What's the $$$ being used for? If money is not a problem, go Oliver for sure, that pig can average 120-130

Kelly out of that lot, but I prefer Boak and Walters

 

[blackshadow]

Pick two

Sheed, B Crouch, Libba

Needs more Rocky

One suave ****

 

[SavDog23]

Neale and B Smith vs Crisp and Rockliff/Sheed

Neale and Smith.

Moore + Williams
vs
Balta + Whitfield

Gotta have Williams in your team. Don't like Moore IMO though.

Sheed and BSmith
or
Neale/Coniglio and Scrim


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Cogs and Scrimshaw.

Moore + Gus Brayshaw + Walters + $43.6k for rookie corrections/savings
vs
Scrimshaw + Macrae + Billings + $9.6k

Option 2.

Need some advice on last 2 spots in my team.

Oliver vs Brayshaw

T.Kelly vs Gray vs Darling

Oliver and Telly.

 

[SavDog23]

Neale and Gibbons ($7k left over)

OR

Treloar + <$117k Rookie

OR

MCrouch + <$165k Rookie

 

[toxic]

Neale and Gibbons ($7k left over)

OR

Treloar + <$117k Rookie

OR

MCrouch + <$165k Rookie

Depends on Gibbons being selected

 

[Yoda_]

McGrath v N.Newman?

 

[GT619]

Macrae v cogs v Neale

 

[Yoda_]

Macrae v cogs v Neale

In that order

Macrae a SC pig
Coniglio ready to break into that top tier
Neale similar output to recent years

 

[06Premiers]

1) ! Brayshaw has $$ to make while oliver is priced at his max, can see oliver average more but not by much. can pick him up after the byes also, collins will be a flop and coniglio is sexy.

Good one.

How about Oliver, Brouch and Scrimshaw and bank the change?

Ended up going with Cogs, Brouch, Scrimshaw as this fits with my 2 Dee max policy.
Also allowed me to drop Gibbons for Walsh. Gibbons' role is too Pickett/Garlett-y.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I would have prefered to keep both, but if I can only keep one, which one?
Grundy (not ideal pre-season) vs Gawn (Pruess issue)

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Needs more Rocky

One suave ****

Throw Ahern in the mix

One suave ****