2019 Player X v Y v Z

[JRyan23]

Walters and Butters
Moore and Sheed?

 

[Kadog]

Choose 3 of Scott, Hind, Constable, Atkins

 

[JRyan23]

Hmm ok. Might have to do some digging...

would have Wilkie above him currently but one will be squeezed out for Brown when he is back so flip a coin

 

[PoopingHindi]

Walters and Butters
Moore and Sheed?

first one for me.
i dont like the Sheed pick. SC version of a list clogger.

 

[JRyan23]

first one for me.
i dont like the Sheed pick. SC version of a list clogger.

or
Moore and Neale
v
Walters and BCrouch

 

[True Blue Saint]

Have my team pretty set with Guns/Rooks - only Mid priced (If you call them that) are Zac Williams and Darcy Moore. I currently have Tim Kelly at F4.

Other option is to Go with Constable instead of Butters (I already have Atkins and Clarck from Geel and didnt want to go all 3 rooks).
Then I can move T.Kelly to Mundy who will be diff Bye week and POD.

So Tim Kelly and Butters VS Constable and Mundy

Thoughts?

Telly & Butters for mine.

Neale v Sloane + $$?

I've had Neale since day dot but I'm convinced Adelaide are going to have a strong season and I think Rory is in for a rather large season. Thoughts?

 

[PoopingHindi]

or
Moore and Neale
v
Walters and BCrouch

i honestly dont know with that one.
probably the first one again but i wouldn't be all that happy about missing out on BCrouch.


side note: i have both Walters and BCrouch in my side

 

[Criticism]

Lloyd + Brouch vs Hurn/Crisp + Brayshaw/Sloane

 

[PoopingHindi]

Lloyd + Brouch vs Hurn/Crisp + Brayshaw/Sloane

Hurn and Sloane.
Lloyd is an upgrade target IMO

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Lloyd + Collins + Hind + 165K vs Crisp + Wilkie + Rockliff

 

[CrozaN]

Lloyd + Collins + Hind + 165K vs Crisp + Wilkie + Rockliff

2nd easily if that 165k isn't needed elsewhere

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Got 2 decisions to make

Brouch vs Rockliff

Feel like Brouch is the more popular choice but has never gone 100+ or played a full season. Rockliff is a recent burnman but at least has past premium scoring and is looking fit for the first time in a while. DEspite their good value, need one of them to go 105+ to be worth it.

Steele vs Brayshaw (edit: add V Sloane)

Again feel like Brayshaw 'looks better' as the more popular choice and he did ave 108 post bye and smash the pre-season. But Steele averaged 112 post bye, also smashed the pre-season and has a better bye? Sloane is a former premium who has been susceptible to the tag recently in a similar price bracket.

 

[shotgun_blues]

Scrimshaw or Clark (D6)
- points & JS

Drew or Petrucelle or Parker or Schultz (F8)
- JS main requirement

Only taking one of each.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Scrimshaw or Clark (D6)
- points & JS

Drew or Petrucelle or Parker or Schultz (F8)
- JS main requirement

Only taking one of each.

Clark.

Probably Parker for JS (not for scoring)

 

[Imoster]

Grundy & Steele vs Macrae + Goldstein

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Treloar vs yeo vs m crouch vs pendles vs Selwood

Pick 1

Fyfe coniglio macrae brayshaw the other mids

 

[Andrew Birch]

Treloar vs yeo vs m crouch vs pendles vs Selwood

Pick 1

Fyfe coniglio macrae brayshaw the other mids

M Crouch
---


For M5
Taranto & 2k
v
Rocky & 77k (for corrective trades)

 

[Wellsy35]

Menegola v Darling v Telly v Walters

 

[Hai_Newman]

M Crouch
---


For M5
Taranto & 2k
v
Rocky & 77k (for corrective trades)

2nd one

 

[Raveneyes]

M Crouch
---


For M5
Taranto & 2k
v
Rocky & 77k (for corrective trades)

Rocky looks the goods this year, but it's a huge risk. But the $77k will be handier than you think!


Here's my latest dilemna.

Brouch & Libba & $90k
vs
Oliver & Hately & $40k

 

[Raveneyes]

Menegola v Darling v Telly v Walters

Hard to go past Menegola. Quietly knocks out consistent 100 averages, even with the team mates he has.

Darling may not have a purple patch again.

Speaking of purple, Walters injury & suspension prone? PLus might play FWD some games.

Telly is too inconsistent for mine.


Menegola is my tip!

 

[Raveneyes]

Got 2 decisions to make

Brouch vs Rockliff

Feel like Brouch is the more popular choice but has never gone 100+ or played a full season. Rockliff is a recent burnman but at least has past premium scoring and is looking fit for the first time in a while. DEspite their good value, need one of them to go 105+ to be worth it.

Steele vs Brayshaw (edit: add V Sloane)

Again feel like Brayshaw 'looks better' as the more popular choice and he did ave 108 post bye and smash the pre-season. But Steele averaged 112 post bye, also smashed the pre-season and has a better bye? Sloane is a former premium who has been susceptible to the tag recently in a similar price bracket.

Brouch

Gus

Just gut feels.

 

[M_I_G]

Walters and Butters
Moore and Sheed?

Sheesh tricky
If it’s me I’m going option 2

 

[M_I_G]

Menegola v Darling v Telly v Walters

Hard to go past Menegola. Quietly knocks out consistent 100 averages, even with the team mates he has.

Darling may not have a purple patch again.

Speaking of purple, Walters injury & suspension prone? PLus might play FWD some games.

Telly is too inconsistent for mine.


Menegola is my tip!

I’m really liking Tkelly for some reason.


Lads:
TKelly (when I have danger and selwood..err..)
VS
Mundy

 

[Guardian Hawk]

I’m really liking Tkelly for some reason.


Lads:
TKelly (when I have danger and selwood..err..)
VS
Mundy

I have a slight preference for Telly due to age and the odd Ross Lyon positional shenanigan but with the other 2 Cats in there I would go for Mundy cos if Geelong have a dirty day your team will be hit hard