2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Andrew Birch]

Rocky looks the goods this year, but it's a huge risk. But the $77k will be handier than you think!


Here's my latest dilemna.

Brouch & Libba & $90k
vs
Oliver & Hately & $40k

Hately's not playing

I'd still go the MPM option even if he was though

 

[ForeverHardcore]

M Crouch
---


For M5
Taranto & 2k
v
Rocky & 77k (for corrective trades)

Rocky and cash forsure

Rocky more potential to be a to pick 10-15 mid

Taranto will score well til Kelly and Ward are back though.

 

[DT_35]

Which to choose...

A) Parker at F8
B) Swing Burgess to F8 and Hore D8
C) Swing Burgess to F8 and Scrim D8

Thoughts?

 

[DT_35]

Sheed or Burn man Rocky?

 

[Raveneyes]

Sheed or Burn man Rocky?

Rock Lobster!

 

[CrozaN]

Sheed or Burn man Rocky?

I am srsly tempted by Rocky tbh!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Rock Lobster!

My whole season relies on my selection of Rocky and B.Crouch ....in preference to spending $$$$ on my DEF

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I am srsly tempted by Rocky tbh!

It's all based on his fitness .....you see from his scoring history, when he's fit .......but as soon as he cops an injury, his output drops like a rock

I'm not planning on making $$$ ......just short term scoring & maximizing points

 

[ROOINYOU]

Collins or Moore
I have no idea...

 

[CrozaN]

It's all based on his fitness .....you see from his scoring history, when he's fit .......but as soon as he cops an injury, his output drops like a rock

I'm not planning on making $$$ ......just short term scoring & maximizing points

Literally can be said for almost every player hahaha.

 

[Raveneyes]

My whole season relies on my selection of Rocky and B.Crouch ....in preference to spending $$$$ on my DEF

Good luck m8.

Could pay off big time!

I have Brouch and Rocky both for a while, but decided to keep only one.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Literally can be said for almost every player hahaha.

Yes it can ....but in Rocky's case he goes from a high scoring SC Premo .....to a Billings

 

[Raveneyes]

Collins vs Scrimshaw and $

Think I'll take the Scrimcash.

 

[nan_11]

Duursma V Scrimshaw
Shultz v Parker
Joyce v Burgess

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Collins or Moore
I have no idea...

At what position ? .....If Collins at D5 .....if at D4

Prefer Moore over Ridley

 

[Benno_900]

Whitfield, Collins and Butters

versus

Ridley, Hore and Matt Crouch

 

[pulpdriver]

Whitfield, Collins and Butters

versus

Ridley, Hore and Matt Crouch

First one looks better to me.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Darling - Goldstein - Llooooyd

VS

Billings - Gawn - Hurn/Crisp

 

[ROOINYOU]

At what position ? .....If Collins at D5 .....if at D4

Prefer Moore over Ridley

D4 mate...I've lost the plot this year with all the mid price buys.

 

[pulpdriver]

Darling - Goldstein - Llooooyd

VS

Billings - Gawn - Hurn/Crisp

Both look really good. I'd probably lean slightly towards the second one because Gawn >>> Goldy.

 

[Benno_900]

First one looks better to me.

Thanks - I had a crazy idea to get rid of my only back premium to fit in Matt Crouch at M6.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Collins or Moore
I have no idea...

Moore. Easily for mine.

Whitfield or Crisp?

 

[Tulendeena]

Wilkie vs Wagner (via duursma swing)

 

[pulpdriver]

Thanks - I had a crazy idea to get rid of my only back premium to fit in Matt Crouch at M6.

Hey, 6 premo mids might be the way to go. I had Brayshaw as my M6 and a really pov defence for God knows how long but pussied out in the end and went for a bit more balance. Might end up being the first thing I post in the Vents thread though.

 

[Benno_900]

Hey, 6 premo mids might be the way to go. I had Brayshaw as my M6 and a really pov defence for God knows how long but pussied out in the end and went for a bit more balance. Might end up being the first thing I post in the Vents thread though.

It will leave my defence as Williams, Smith, Ridley and 3 rookies. But I am playing 3 rookies as is.

If Ridley has good JS, I would do it. But it seems not.