2019 Player X v Y v Z

[stevebbb]

WCE have a strong forward line and Sheed is a running machine, why would he spend more time forward when he can get to multiple contests and still kick goals from the midfield?

 

[Andrew Birch]

So basically the Dusty 2017 role, sweet.

 

[DraftPunk]

Boak v T Kelly

 

[JuddgementDay]

the first one if you're playing it safe (boring)
the second one if you're glory hunting (ballsy)

Bont and McCarthy for me but if you could see my team you wouldn't be taking my advice.

Gresh_Magic I share the same sentiments here
Except, I've had the Bont last year and found it frustrating, he played too much forward. This year he is getting more of the ball, but when they are low on forwards, guess where he is going?

 

[saintbatty]

2020 fwd premo

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Who we thinking to start?

Drew named on the ball again back home against our pox midfield?
Or Parker to bounce back against the hawks?

Could play Parker and drew but would have to put butters on the pine?

Going away this weekend and need a pick tonight

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Who we thinking to start?

Drew named on the ball again back home against our pox midfield?
Or Parker to bounce back against the hawks?

Could play Parker and drew but would have to put butters on the pine?

Going away this weekend and need a pick tonight

I asked a similar question in another thread. I have to field 2 of Setterfield, Parker & Drew. Left to my own devices, I think I'd bench Parker, but it's with no confidence.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

I asked a similar question in another thread. I have to field 2 of Setterfield, Parker & Drew. Left to my own devices, I think I'd bench Parker, but it's with no confidence.

Think I’m going drew and butters
We give up a heap of fantasy points

Think Parker will get 70+ though
Can’t trust setterfield

 

[JohnChainz]

Bontempelli vs Coniglio

Please please help. Will be much appreciated

 

[JuddgementDay]

Bontempelli vs Coniglio

Please please help. Will be much appreciated

Cognilio - GWS will win more games
The Bont may be thrown forward and spud up again

 

[Gene Simmons]

Boak v Gray v D.Smith v Sheed

Pick 1

 

[PoopingHindi]

Boak v Gray v D.Smith v Sheed

Pick 1

D.Smith v Sheed
Pick 1

i'd take Smith for that extra bit of PODdy goodness.

 

[toxic]

Boak v Gray v D.Smith v Sheed

Pick 1

Gray

 

[Gene Simmons]

Gray

Is it crazy to go Fyfe -> Gray ?

 

[toxic]

Is it crazy to go Fyfe -> Gray ?

Yes

 

[juddola]

Dunkley > Marshall
Williams > Stewart

Or

Dunkley > Heeney (bringing him back)
Second trade TBC.

 

[Test Tickle]

Which one is better to trade in this week?
Mundy v Walters?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Gibbons v Lockhart v Wagner

How does one end up with these 3 potatoes?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Dunkley > Marshall
Williams > Stewart

Or

Dunkley > Heeney (bringing him back)
Second trade TBC.

Heeney via Roughy manoeuvre

 

[ROOINYOU]

Bontempelli vs Coniglio

Please please help. Will be much appreciated

Cogs for me mate..he's a straight midfielder.
Bont always a chance to play fwd.

edit- a week late, sorry dude.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Which one is better to trade in this week?
Mundy v Walters?

Mundy

 

[stevebbb]

Which one is better to trade in this week?
Mundy v Walters?

Probably neither, but I'd say Walters. Mundy will go back to being a spud when Fyfe and Blakely come back. There's also a few rookie mids that will get a game soon. Walters will kick goals and often gets some KOTD action

 

[JohnChainz]

Cogs for me mate..he's a straight midfielder.
Bont always a chance to play fwd.

edit- a week late, sorry dude.

Went the Bont in the end, so far so good

 

[shaunfern]

Hore, ROB, Stack

Can only have 2, who best to bring in.

Setterfield OR faulta? to be sacrificed for Hore (via Kiera’s dpp) as I want to swing him forward to sure up a shaky forward line.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hore, ROB, Stack

Can only have 2, who best to bring in.

Setterfield OR faulta? to be sacrificed for Hore (via Kiera’s dpp) as I want to swing him forward to sure up a shaky forward line.

Post team in Trades Rd5 thread .