2019 Player X v Y v Z

[SC fish]

Parker vs burgess
Who to trade out for Hinge?

I don't have Burgess but I'm trading OUT Parker despite his now low BE. I need to trade out a FWD so I can shift Danger back FWD for team balance.

 

[ohh_v]

Who's got better JS?

Hinge v O.Baker?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Who's got better JS?

Hinge v O.Baker?

Hinge.

Dees have a lot of players to come back in.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hinge.

Dees have a lot of players to come back in.

I like Osska would of got him if he had DPP.

**** seems to give his young players a good crack at it. Look at answorth been in for afew weeks now.

On DPP there are fuuuuu all rookies with mid/fwd status WTF ?

 

[gutsroy]

Wayne Milera at 405-410k vs not Wayne Milera at 405-410k

 

[JuddgementDay]

Wayne Milera at 405-410k vs not Wayne Milera at 405-410k

I'm prepared to pay more & watch his form

 

[stevebbb]

Wayne Milera at 405-410k vs not Wayne Milera at 405-410k

Started with him, was looking great until he got injured. Still think he'll average similar to BSmith, so not much of an upgrade. The fact that he gets thrown around a lot means he'll throw in some 70s and 80s and average 90-95

On the watchlist, but it'll only be if I need to strengthen my defence after the byes

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Clark or Answerth on field?

Can't loop via Zilliams this week.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Clark or Answerth on field?

Can't loop via Zilliams this week.

Take a crap in the corner and pick which fly lands on said player first.

 

[Suma Magic]

If you could only pick one:

Cripps v J. Kelly

Cripps. But only due to Jelly’s injury risk. And price I suppose. I’d back jelly to average more.

 

[Suma Magic]

Get rid of:

Rocky

or

MCrouch?

 

[revo333]

Houli or Luke Ryan?

 

[Kenyan]

Houli or Luke Ryan?

Luke Ryan - Houli lots of injuries

 

[SC fish]

Houli or Luke Ryan?

I'm going Ryan due to his R12 bye

 

[gutsroy]

Started with him, was looking great until he got injured. Still think he'll average similar to BSmith, so not much of an upgrade. The fact that he gets thrown around a lot means he'll throw in some 70s and 80s and average 90-95

On the watchlist, but it'll only be if I need to strengthen my defence after the byes

You had a bit of bad luck with injuries to some of your starters,but the good thing is that they have performed to expectations and otherwise looked the goods
Like Milera, the rd 14 bye is slightly tricky but also reckon he’s good for that 90-95 range.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Faz 2000]

Do we reckon either Daniel or Walters makes an OK F5/6?

Rolling at the mo: Danger-Kelly-Heeney-Dunkley-Marshall-<awful rookie>

 

[Gene Simmons]

JDunkley v JCameron.......

 

[BeamsLocke]

JDunkley v JCameron.......

Dunkley probably going to be more consistent but Jezza could pump out some massive scores. Personally I’d go Dunkley

 

[Faz 2000]

Dunkley's MPP might prove handy along the way, too.

I'm not as into Cameron as many seem to be... he's really got no history of averaging 99+, and I think there's reasons for that.

 

[BeamsLocke]

Do we reckon either Daniel or Walters makes an OK F5/6?

Rolling at the mo: Danger-Kelly-Heeney-Dunkley-Marshall-<awful rookie>

Can definitely see both being Top 10 forwards. Personally think Daniel will be a bit better

 

[Gene Simmons]

Dunkley's MPP might prove handy along the way, too.

I'm not as into Cameron as many seem to be... he's really got no history of averaging 99+, and I think there's reasons for that.

I think Cameron can post some massive scores with big bags of goals but he can also post dismal scores like against Hawks 3 weeks ago..

 

[toxic]

JDunkley v JCameron.......

Dunk based on average

 

[freddy mercury]

Cameron vs Daniel?

 

[boulders]

Best defender option under $530K? Already have Whitfield, Seagull, B Smith, Hore.

Ryan / Houli / Stewart / Sicily / Rich / Laird

 

[freddy mercury]

Best defender option under $530K? Already have Whitfield, Seagull, B Smith, Hore.

Ryan / Houli / Stewart / Sicily / Rich / Laird

Ryan