Opinion 2020 Draft picks 1/9/22/23/40/56/66/80 (2021 + Melb 2nd, 4th, Haw 4th)

which mythological creature you think would win in a fight, Bigfoot or Santa?

  • Total voters
    32

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Deaneus!

Deaneus!

We Await Silent Tristero's Empire
Veteran 10k Posts RIP Sensible Type Mount Buller Demons - Sweet F.A. Chess Club Member A Star Wars Fan
Nov 24, 2007
25,849
54,736
DTC Frat House
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Team Lambda Variant

Crows Draft Hand Tweet



KEY DATES

Oct 30 – Nov 6: AFL Free Agency Period
November 4 – 12: AFL Trade Period
November 20: List Lodgment 1
November 27: List Lodgment 2
November 30: AFL Draft Nominations close
w/c December 7: NAB AFL Draft and Rookie Draft (exact date to be confirmed in due course)
Mid-December: Final List Lodgment & TPP estimates​


As God is my witness, finding anything useful on the AFL.com.au site is practically impossible, may whoever designed it burn in hell.
 
Last edited:
B is for Bad Ass, which he surely is
I is for Inigo Montoya, his spirit animal
N is for Ninja, which he does in his spare time
U is for Unrelenting, because he cannot be stopped
K is for Killing Machine, which we cannot prove in a court of law because all the witnesses are dead

What Keyser Soze/The Joker madness will he pull off this morning?
 
WeedsMullet84 said:
Hey mate, they could match a bid at Pick 2 if the Crows gave them Pick 22 & 40

They could certainly match a bid if we gave them 22&23, but I think that's paying way overs for us if we're also agreeing not to select JUH with Pick 1
Click to expand...
If we pay 22/23 for 14 , Kelly and Reid should resign immediately. They are not good negotiators.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

So we have a few hours until the trades can be announced, so some thoughts that have me confused at this point;

  • If Port trade pick 29 for Orazio, how do they match for BOTH Jones and Schofield? Especially if both come in a bit earlier than they hoped? Surely a future second makes more sense.
  • The Dunkley trade is an odd one. WB don't want picks in this years draft, knowing they are going to either be wiped out or reduced significantly. Only way I can see this getting done is if they get a pick from this year (that they immediately trade out for for Treloar) and a pick in next years draft.
  • Collingwood want out of next years first round. What opportunities might lie there?
  • I'm confident J Cameron will get to Geelong. It looks like it will involve at least 2 or maybe all 3 of their picks. Will happen though.
For ours:
  • I'm not quite sure what next years second from Melbourne was about.
  • If we want WB pick 14 as suggested, why have did we trade out pick 33? We have offered 40 to GWS for Hately. So what are we offering to WB for pick 14? It better not include more than one pick in the 20's.
I think we end up going;

  • Hately for the Melbourne future 2nd round pick
  • WB pick 14 for 23 and 40 and maybe a late round pick swap as well
  • Take 1, 9, 14 and 22 to the draft
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I for one still really like Thilthorpe. Skilful on both sides. Athletic and quick for his size. Good hands. Can ruck as well. He's got a lot of tools.

Hollands would have been nice if we had pick 2. I still wouldn't care if we took him with 1 but it's a big risk unfortunately. Would have been an ideal and easy number 1 choice if not for the knee.
 
Adelaide Football Club picks between 11-19:

16 2018 Ned McHenry
12 2017 Darcy Fogarty
15 2016 Jordan Gallucci
17 2015 Tom Doedee
11 2015 Wayne Milera
14 2014 Jake Lever
14 2010 Brodie Smith
13 2009 Daniel Talia
14 2006 James Sellar
17 2005 Darren Pfieffer
16 2005 Richard Douglas
14 2003 Fergus Watts
12 2001 Brent Reilly
16 1998 Brett Burton
17 1997 Lance Picioane
13 1996 Tom Gilligan
18 1995 Brent Williams
 
Crows I Am said:
Great job with all the draft pick summaries, we have done quite well over the years with the draft picks we have had.

Any chance of a summary of our picks in the teens? :)
Click to expand...
done
 
dogs105 said:
Adelaide Football Club picks between 11-19:

16 2018 Ned McHenry
12 2017 Darcy Fogarty
15 2016 Jordan Gallucci
17 2015 Tom Doedee
11 2015 Wayne Milera
14 2014 Jake Lever
14 2010 Brodie Smith
13 2009 Daniel Talia
14 2006 James Sellar
17 2005 Darren Pfieffer
16 2005 Richard Douglas
14 2003 Fergus Watts
12 2001 Brent Reilly
16 1998 Brett Burton
17 1997 Lance Picioane
13 1996 Tom Gilligan
18 1995 Brent Williams
Click to expand...

That's depressing reading.
 
CONSOLIDATED LIST

Players taken by the Adelaide Crows with a top 10 pick:

7 2000 Laurence Angwin
8 2004 John Meesen
10 2007 Patrick Dangerfield
10 2008 Phil Davis
9 2018 Chayce Jones
6 2019 Fischer McAsey

Adelaide Football Club picks between 11-19:

16 2018 Ned McHenry
12 2017 Darcy Fogarty
15 2016 Jordan Gallucci
17 2015 Tom Doedee
11 2015 Wayne Milera
14 2014 Jake Lever
14 2010 Brodie Smith
13 2009 Daniel Talia
14 2006 James Sellar
17 2005 Darren Pfieffer
16 2005 Richard Douglas
14 2003 Fergus Watts
12 2001 Brent Reilly
16 1998 Brett Burton
17 1997 Lance Picioane
13 1996 Tom Gilligan
18 1995 Brent Williams


Players taken between 20-25 by the Adelaide Crows:

24 2019 Harry Schoenberg
23 2013 Matt Crouch
24 2004 Nathan van Berlo


between 26-30

29 2019 Josh Worrell
30 2018 Will Hamill
27 2011 Sam Kerridge
29 2009 Jack Gunston
28 2008 Shaun McKernan
27 2007 Andy Otten
28 2004 Chad Gibson
29 1998 Tyson Stenglein
27 1995 Kane Johnson
27 1994 Toby Kennett
26 1992 Marty McKinnon

Players taken between 40-49 By the Adelaide Crows:

48 2019 Lachlan Gollant
42 2019 Ronin O'Çonnor
40 2017 Andrew McPherson
44 2016 Myles Poholke
43 2014 Mitch McGovern
46 2013 Riley Knight
46 2011 Nick Joyce
41 2011 Mitch Grigg
45 2009 Sam Shaw
44 2008 Rory Sloane
48 2006 David Mackay
48 2005 Alan Obst
40 2004 Ivan Maric
44 2001 Ben Finnin
48 2000 Matthew Smith
48 1998 Lucas Herbert
49 1997 Ian Perrie
44 1995 Scott Hodges
44 1993 Eugene Warrior
41 1992 Brook Fogden

Players taken between

50-54

51 2016 Elliot Himmelberg
53 2000 Hayden Skipworth
51 1999 Ricky O'Loughlin
52 1995 Adam Ugrinic
50 1994 Brett Higgins

55-59

58 2014 Harry Dear
58 2007 Tony Armstrong
56 2004 Chris Knights
58 2003 Ben Hudson
56 2002 Robert Shirley
59 2001 Jacob Schuback
56 1992 Matthew Powell


Players taken in the 60s:

64 2018 Lachlan Sholl
62 2016 Matthew Signorello
62 2012 Sam Siggins
64 2011 Cam Ellis-Yolmen
61 2010 Jarryd Lyons
61 2009 James Craig
60 2008 Tom Lee
64 2006 Nick Gill
68 2002 James Begley
67 2000 Graham Johncock
67 1997 Robert Shirley
65 1997 Justin Cicolella
63 1998 Clint Kirey
65 1997 Linden Stevens
69 1996 Chad Rintoul
60 1996 Andrew Eccles
69 1995 Ashley Fernee

Taken in 70s:

75 2016 Ben Davis
72 2008 Will Young
71 2007 Aaron Kite
78 2006 Bryce Campbell
79 1999 Balraj Singh
75 1998 Ken McGregor
76 1996 Greg Dempsey

Players taken at 80 or later (not including rookie elevations):

81 2012 Rory Atkins
83 1999 Matthew Shir
80 1998 Brodie Atkinson
86 1996 Ben Parker
116 1992 Michael Godden
86 1992 Sam Smart


PSD (and games played):

2012 Nick Joyce
2005 Jason Porplyzia (130)
2001 Trent Hentschel (71)
2000 Adam Richardson (2)
2000 Chris Ladhams (54)
1999 Andrew Crowell (44)
1999 James Byrne (24)
1998 Darryl Wintle (3)
1995 Brendan Logan
1995 Simon Goodwin (275)
1995 Shane Ellen (54)
1994 Tyson Edwards (321)
1994 Peter Vardy (96)
1993 Matthew Kluzek (24)
1993 Shane Tongerie (4)
1992 Simon Pedler
1992 Nick Pesch (31)
1992 Josh Mail (4)
1992 Darryl Wakelin (261)


first picks at the the rookie draft each year: (Numbers in brackets are games played after we drafted them).

2019 Ben Keays (16)
2018 Kieran Strachan (1)
2017 Patrick Wilson (2)
2016 Sam Shaw
2015 Paul Hunter
2014 Reilly O'Brien (37)
2013 Charlie Cameron (73)
2012 Kyle Hartigan (113)
2011 Rory Laird (160)
2010 Timothy Milera
2009 Luke Thompson (20)
2008 Ricky Henderson (90)
2007 James Moss
2006 Andrew McIntyre
2005 Brad Sugars
2004 Ryan Nye
2003 Tim Hazell
2002 Hayden Skipworth (39)
2001 Paul Thomas
2000 Kane McLean
1999 Michael Doughty (231)
1998 Stuart Bown (4)
1997 Ben Marsh (48)
1996 Ben Marsh (48)
 
Last edited:
DJ75 said:
So we have a few hours until the trades can be announced, so some thoughts that have me confused at this point;

  • If Port trade pick 29 for Orazio, how do they match for BOTH Jones and Schofield? Especially if both come in a bit earlier than they hoped? Surely a future second makes more sense.
  • The Dunkley trade is an odd one. WB don't want picks in this years draft, knowing they are going to either be wiped out or reduced significantly. Only way I can see this getting done is if they get a pick from this year (that they immediately trade out for for Treloar) and a pick in next years draft.
  • Collingwood want out of next years first round. What opportunities might lie there?
  • I'm confident J Cameron will get to Geelong. It looks like it will involve at least 2 or maybe all 3 of their picks. Will happen though.
For ours:
  • I'm not quite sure what next years second from Melbourne was about.
  • If we want WB pick 14 as suggested, why have did we trade out pick 33? We have offered 40 to GWS for Hately. So what are we offering to WB for pick 14? It better not include more than one pick in the 20's.
I think we end up going;

  • Hately for the Melbourne future 2nd round pick
  • WB pick 14 for 23 and 40 and maybe a late round pick swap as well
  • Take 1, 9, 14 and 22 to the draft
Click to expand...

I think Hately for the future 2nd round from Melbourne is far too much.
 
StonesThrow said:
I for one still really like Thilthorpe. Skilful on both sides. Athletic and quick for his size. Good hands. Can ruck as well. He's got a lot of tools.

Hollands would have been nice if we had pick 2. I still wouldn't care if we took him with 1 but it's a big risk, unfortunately. Would have been an ideal and easy number 1 choice if not for the knee.
Click to expand...

Im really torn on this.

Tilthorpe has some great qualities. He just doesn't scream number 1.

McDonald is a better KPF choice. The pressure that will come on both club and player will be immense once JUH and McDonald start to kill it. And if we don't bid on JUH because of a deal with the WBD, the media will undoubtedly ignore the context of the deal and still give it to us.

'ADL didn't even bid on him'.

I can hear it now, and I hate the idea of it (for both player and club).

I'm emotionally invested in Hollands. I've been on the bandwagon for a while now and I really hope we take him. You said it yourself, if it wasn't for the knee, he would be the easy #1 choice.
 
Spartacus_Aurelius said:
Im really torn on this.

Tilthorpe has some great qualities. He just doesn't scream number 1.

McDonald is a better KPF choice. The pressure that will come on both club and player will be immense once JUH and McDonald start to kill it. And if we don't bid on JUH because of a deal with the WBD, the media will undoubtedly ignore the context of the deal and still give it to us.

'ADL didn't even bid on him'.

I can hear it now, and I hate the idea of it (for both player and club).

I'm emotionally invested in Hollands. I've been on the bandwagon for a while now and I really hope we take him. You said it yourself, if it wasn't for the knee, he would be the easy #1 choice.
Click to expand...
That last sentence is the clincher.

Now players are pretty good at the recovery side of things and medical science has come a long way, but it's still a huge risk. It's why a player of Max King's calibre slipped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

119others
  • Poll
Predict the Crows first draft pick 2024
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
176
Views
6K
Cromulant
C
Scorpus
Competitions AFC Board Draft Game 2023/24 Main Competition Thread - Starts Dec 4th
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
1K
Views
38K
1990crow
1990crow
jackster83
Prediction Pick the Scapegoat
Replies
12
Views
557
Cap
Cap
John Who
Showdowns since our rebuild 2020-2024
Replies
1
Views
261
cmndstab
cmndstab
Scorpus
Game Day Adelaide vs Western, Round 22
34 35 36 37 38
Replies
948
Views
16K
jenny61_99
jenny61_99
1990crow
Opinion 2025 Best 22 + playstation offseason
Replies
0
Views
334
1990crow
1990crow
Thylacinus
Game Day Round 22, Crows v Brisbane at the Gabba, 12/8/23
65 66 67 68 69
Replies
2K
Views
28K
DJ75
DJ75
Back
Top