Game Day 2021 AFL Draft & AFL Rookie Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

As much as I like van Rooyen, I'm not bothered he's off the board. I just didn't see what he offers to us that Brennan Cox doesn't already, and I do think he's also best suited to defence. I'd find it very hard to go past Johnson as best available, but I think Goater fits what we'd want better so it wouldn't surprise me if we went that way.
Daring to bet against Jason Taylor. Since joining Melbourne in 2013 every first pick he has had except one (Hannan, who was traded to WB and played in the GF this year) has a premiership medal.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Johnson could have slipped for lots of reasons. One might be that he isn't super quick, one might be that he doesn't win a lot of the ball, one might be that he potentially indicated that he would not sign an extension with an interstate side and wanted to come home with Colin Young as his manager.
 
I can only assume the mail on the Hawks being keen on Johnson was wrong because if they had him as a top 8 talent then there is no way they dont find a way to trade with Brisbane for that pick.

Likewise, if we were tossing up on Johnson/Erasmus per the mail then we rate Johnson top 10 and some club is going to have to pay a mint for us to risk losing him
 
Not sure why Johnson has slid out of the first? As tempting as he is, if we could swap picks with the Hawks for a little something extra and still get Goater it'd be an awesome haul...

I think you've hit the nail on the head.

The more I think about it now, the more I think we'll trade with Hawthorn for 23 and a future 2nd rounder and grab Goater. Hawthorn will want Johnson, so we'll be able to extract maximum value from them as a result.

Goater also adds a POD to our midfield.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Can someone post a link or a list showing the order of the remaining picks please..
 
I can only assume the mail on the Hawks being keen on Johnson was wrong because if they had him as a top 8 talent then there is no way they dont find a way to trade with Brisbane for that pick.

Likewise, if we were tossing up on Johnson/Erasmus per the mail then we rate Johnson top 10 and some club is going to have to pay a mint for us to risk losing him

I don't think we did really consider Johnson over Erasmus. We may've considered him at 10 if Erasmus was gone along with a host of others but I suspect the rumblings of our interest in Hobbs and Gibcus would've seen them selected in from of him if that was the case.
 
Johnson could have slipped for lots of reasons. One might be that he isn't super quick, one might be that he doesn't win a lot of the ball, one might be that he potentially indicated that he would not sign an extension with an interstate side and wanted to come home with Colin Young as his manager.

Didn't he test really well for speed?
 
He is agile and can run, but I don't think he is quick

Sub 3 second 20m. That’s quick.

Anyway, Johnson projects as that type that just knows how to football. No flair. No fanfare. Just a footballer.

We’d need a significant offer to not grab him OR we never rated him in which case we just go for best offer for our needs.

If we take a deal, we can never have rated Johnson.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day 2021 AFL Draft & AFL Rookie Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top