GotTheGoodes
Bloods
- Moderator
- #2,126
Definition of a legend.Yes I am going to see Melb vs Cats today
Yes I am wearing my Swans hoodie
No I don't care
No Oppo Supporters 2021 General AFL Discussion
- Thread starter Kennedy Parker
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Sep 24, 2014
- 3,837
- 19,387
- AFL Club
- Sydney
This bump by Cunnington was assessed as Careless Conduct, Medium Impact and High Contact.
One match suspension.
This Caleb Daniel tackle was also deemed worthy of an one week suspension
Identically assessed as careless conduct with medium impact and high contact.
www.westernbulldogs.com.au
I know the AFL is worried about the head, concussion etc, but the Caleb Daniel tackle could have had far more serious ramifications.
Assessing the two incidents identically resulting in the same sanction is, IMO, baffling.
And sets a dangerous precedent (if of course the AFL were ever to follow precedent).
One match suspension.
This Caleb Daniel tackle was also deemed worthy of an one week suspension
Identically assessed as careless conduct with medium impact and high contact.
Bulldogs Media | Western Bulldogs
Watch the latest videos from the Western Bulldogs
I know the AFL is worried about the head, concussion etc, but the Caleb Daniel tackle could have had far more serious ramifications.
Assessing the two incidents identically resulting in the same sanction is, IMO, baffling.
And sets a dangerous precedent (if of course the AFL were ever to follow precedent).
Grand Uncle Horace
Shake down the thunder
This bump by Cunnington was assessed as Careless Conduct, Medium Impact and High Contact.
One match suspension.
This Caleb Daniel tackle was also deemed worthy of an one week suspension
Identically assessed as careless conduct with medium impact and high contact.
Bulldogs Media | Western Bulldogs
Watch the latest videos from the Western Bulldogs
I know the AFL is worried about the head, concussion etc, but the Caleb Daniel Tackle could have had far more serious ramifications.
IMO adjudicating the two incidents identically with the same sanction is baffling.
and then a fine for Langford's dangerous tackle on Warner... should have gone for tunnelling McInerney as well.
This bump by Cunnington was assessed as Careless Conduct, Medium Impact and High Contact.
One match suspension.
This Caleb Daniel tackle was also deemed worthy of an one week suspension
Identically assessed as careless conduct with medium impact and high contact.
Bulldogs Media | Western Bulldogs
Watch the latest videos from the Western Bulldogs
I know the AFL is worried about the head, concussion etc, but the Caleb Daniel tackle could have had far more serious ramifications.
IMO adjudicating the two incidents identically with the same sanction is baffling.
Daniel should have got 4
Fair call. Had a good game by all accounts. Thursday game a bugger though. They've forgotten by Monday so neither JMac nor Cox stood much of a chance!Still hope for McInerney, Stephens, McDonald
ADELAIDE young gun Lachie Sholl has become the 12th player to be nominated for the NAB AFL Rising Star twice after his dominant performance against North Melbourne on Sunday.
Young Crow picks up second Rising Star nomination
Adelaide's Lachie Sholl is the round four NAB AFL Rising Starwww.afl.com.au
This bump by Cunnington was assessed as Careless Conduct, Medium Impact and High Contact.
One match suspension.
This Caleb Daniel tackle was also deemed worthy of an one week suspension
Identically assessed as careless conduct with medium impact and high contact.
Bulldogs Media | Western Bulldogs
Watch the latest videos from the Western Bulldogs
I know the AFL is worried about the head, concussion etc, but the Caleb Daniel tackle could have had far more serious ramifications.
Assessing the two incidents identically resulting in the same sanction is, IMO, baffling.
And sets a dangerous precedent (if of course the AFL were ever to follow precedent).
How is that bump 1 week?? Are we sure there is even Hugh contact??
Grand Uncle Horace
Shake down the thunder
Deserved. In slow motion you can see the coward lined him up and the victim's head rocks back.
Jewelsbon
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 30, 2016
- 5,890
- 17,955
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Mind boggling, particularly when compared to Daniels.
Grand Uncle Horace
Shake down the thunder
He did on the vision I saw. Besides the perp is a career grub who has got away with a lot.
SwansProudly
Moderator
- Sep 5, 2016
- 9,453
- 26,554
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sydney Swans AFLW
- Moderator
- #2,136
Cunnington free to play
- Mar 11, 2012
- 5,237
- 8,187
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Patriots & UConn
- Oct 24, 2012
- 6,924
- 14,774
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Northern Districts Tigers
The Toby Greene I know: a competitor with a contagious will to win
Just who is the GWS Giants star, so loved internally and so often criticised by those outside the club?
GWS Giants urged to strip Coniglio of captaincy
'Admit you got it wrong and move on'
wwos.nine.com.au
Toby Greene is an undeniable talent but I find it strange that he's seen as a grub by outsiders but is revered as a great guy and natural leader within GWS. There's entire teams who don't have as lengthy and costly a tribunal history as Greene yet GWS have stated they don't want him to change his natural aggression. Now Matthew Lloyd thinks he should replace Coniglio permanently as captain.
- Sep 24, 2014
- 3,837
- 19,387
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I thought the paragraph in the Wayne Campbell article, regarding Greene in the 2019 Finals, summed up the issue with GWS and Greene.
Elimination final, Greene prepared to get himself suspended to get retribution on Bontempelli.
Greene was fined at the tribunal for pulling the Bont's hair.
Not tough. Stupid.
Next week Greene did get suspended when he made contact with Lachie Neale's face when Neale was defenceless on the ground.
Not tough. Stupid.
Two acts in do or die finals, Greene fronts the tribunal twice and gets suspended once and yet Campbell somehow thinks those actions are either praiseworthy or just Toby being Toby.
No one doubts Greene's football ability and because of that ability we are likely to see GWS continued indulgence of his indiscipline.
He’s been suspended for a total of 7 games over a 10 year career. Hardly makes him Hannibal Lecter. Barry Hall got 7 for the Staker punch alone.
The Toby Greene I know: a competitor with a contagious will to win
Just who is the GWS Giants star, so loved internally and so often criticised by those outside the club?www.theage.com.au
GWS Giants urged to strip Coniglio of captaincy
'Admit you got it wrong and move on'
Toby Greene is an undeniable talent but I find it strange that he's seen as a grub by outsiders but is revered as a great guy and natural leader within GWS. There's entire teams who don't have as lengthy and costly a tribunal history as Greene yet GWS have stated they don't want him to change his natural aggression. Now Matthew Lloyd thinks he should replace Coniglio permanently as captain.
Granted he’s coughed up a small deposit for a granny flat in fines but not sure what all the hysteria is about.
Worth remembering he won best first year player in the Giants first year and finished runner up in there best and fairest that year. Probably why the club rank him.
Why is it an issue as all clubs have players who push the limits? Barry Hall 05 prelim final punches Matt Macguire clear as day. Swans indulged in Halls actions for years.
- Sep 24, 2014
- 3,837
- 19,387
- AFL Club
- Sydney
And I thought Hall's actions were equally dumb.
Knockout finals and Greene pulls a guy's hair and makes contact with another guys face. One fine, one suspension, why do it?
Similarly Hall's punch on Maguire, could have cost himself a GF spot and given his importance to the team, the Swans a premiership.
I dislike undisciplined, selfish players and too often those blokes are faux tough.
Although at least the last accusation could not be made against Hall.
We eventually dumped Hall, whereas there is a push to elevate Greene to the GWS captaincy.
And yes to see Hall lift the 2005 cup instead of Brett Kirk still sticks in my craw.
Heading down the North path - rewarding cheap shots.The Toby Greene I know: a competitor with a contagious will to win
Just who is the GWS Giants star, so loved internally and so often criticised by those outside the club?
GWS Giants urged to strip Coniglio of captaincy
'Admit you got it wrong and move on'
Toby Greene is an undeniable talent but I find it strange that he's seen as a grub by outsiders but is revered as a great guy and natural leader within GWS. There's entire teams who don't have as lengthy and costly a tribunal history as Greene yet GWS have stated they don't want him to change his natural aggression. Now Matthew Lloyd thinks he should replace Coniglio permanently as captain.
It should have been LRT, lifting the cup and looking resplendent in the Norm Smith.
- Sep 25, 2011
- 1,811
- 1,824
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Bump was as soft as butter.
- Sep 24, 2014
- 3,837
- 19,387
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Thought this was interesting;
www.foxsports.com.au
This season we have got the ball I50 more often from kick-ins than any other team;
HOW YOUR TEAM STACKS UP (Inside 50 rate from kick-ins)
1. Sydney Swans: 37.3%
2. Geelong Cats: 31.4%
Jake Lloyd not doing too bad either. 24% Inside 50 rate, best of the top 15 kick-in specialists.
HOW THE PLAYERS STACK UP:
1. Jordan Ridley (Essendon): 41 kick-ins, 88% self, 20% inside 50 rate
2. Jack Ziebell (North Melbourne): 32 kick-ins, 88% self, 17% inside 50 rate
3. Dougal Howard (St Kilda): 30 kick-ins, 80% self, 17% inside 50 rate
4. Luke Ryan (Fremantle): 28 kick-ins, 68% self, 15% inside 50 rate
5. Jayden Short (Richmond): 28 kick-ins, 71% self, 10% inside 50 rate
6. Isaac Cumming (GWS Giants): 26 kick-ins, 73% self, 12% inside 50 rate
7. Jake Lloyd (Sydney Swans): 25 kick-ins, 100% self, 24% inside 50 rate
8. Jack Bowes (Gold Coast Suns): 25 kick-ins, 96% self, 12% inside 50 rate
9. Shannon Hurn (West Coast Eagles): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 22% inside 50 rate
10. Daniel Rich (Brisbane Lions): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 10% inside 50 rate
11. Jordan Dawson (Sydney Swans): 19 kick-ins, 95% self, 15% inside 50 rate
AFL’s new rules have released the handbrake. This is who’s flooring it... and who’s stuck in neutral: The Champion Index
AFL’s new rules have released the handbrake. This is who’s flooring it... and who’s stuck in neutral
www.foxsports.com.au
This season we have got the ball I50 more often from kick-ins than any other team;
HOW YOUR TEAM STACKS UP (Inside 50 rate from kick-ins)
1. Sydney Swans: 37.3%
2. Geelong Cats: 31.4%
Jake Lloyd not doing too bad either. 24% Inside 50 rate, best of the top 15 kick-in specialists.
HOW THE PLAYERS STACK UP:
1. Jordan Ridley (Essendon): 41 kick-ins, 88% self, 20% inside 50 rate
2. Jack Ziebell (North Melbourne): 32 kick-ins, 88% self, 17% inside 50 rate
3. Dougal Howard (St Kilda): 30 kick-ins, 80% self, 17% inside 50 rate
4. Luke Ryan (Fremantle): 28 kick-ins, 68% self, 15% inside 50 rate
5. Jayden Short (Richmond): 28 kick-ins, 71% self, 10% inside 50 rate
6. Isaac Cumming (GWS Giants): 26 kick-ins, 73% self, 12% inside 50 rate
7. Jake Lloyd (Sydney Swans): 25 kick-ins, 100% self, 24% inside 50 rate
8. Jack Bowes (Gold Coast Suns): 25 kick-ins, 96% self, 12% inside 50 rate
9. Shannon Hurn (West Coast Eagles): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 22% inside 50 rate
10. Daniel Rich (Brisbane Lions): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 10% inside 50 rate
11. Jordan Dawson (Sydney Swans): 19 kick-ins, 95% self, 15% inside 50 rate
Thanks but more CDThought this was interesting;
AFL’s new rules have released the handbrake. This is who’s flooring it... and who’s stuck in neutral: The Champion Index
AFL’s new rules have released the handbrake. This is who’s flooring it... and who’s stuck in neutral
This season we have got the ball I50 more often from kick-ins than any other team;
HOW YOUR TEAM STACKS UP (Inside 50 rate from kick-ins)
1. Sydney Swans: 37.3%
2. Geelong Cats: 31.4%
Jake Lloyd not doing too bad either. 24% Inside 50 rate, best of the top 15 kick-in specialists.
HOW THE PLAYERS STACK UP:
1. Jordan Ridley (Essendon): 41 kick-ins, 88% self, 20% inside 50 rate
2. Jack Ziebell (North Melbourne): 32 kick-ins, 88% self, 17% inside 50 rate
3. Dougal Howard (St Kilda): 30 kick-ins, 80% self, 17% inside 50 rate
4. Luke Ryan (Fremantle): 28 kick-ins, 68% self, 15% inside 50 rate
5. Jayden Short (Richmond): 28 kick-ins, 71% self, 10% inside 50 rate
6. Isaac Cumming (GWS Giants): 26 kick-ins, 73% self, 12% inside 50 rate
7. Jake Lloyd (Sydney Swans): 25 kick-ins, 100% self, 24% inside 50 rate
8. Jack Bowes (Gold Coast Suns): 25 kick-ins, 96% self, 12% inside 50 rate
9. Shannon Hurn (West Coast Eagles): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 22% inside 50 rate
10. Daniel Rich (Brisbane Lions): 23 kick-ins, 96% self, 10% inside 50 rate
11. Jordan Dawson (Sydney Swans): 19 kick-ins, 95% self, 15% inside 50 rate
Membling
Brownlow Medallist
They did get him relatively cheaply from us.
- Status
Similar threads
