Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Santoz]

I'm going around in circles with my rucks.
In the end, it comes down to this equation:

Martin and Pruess
Vs
Gawn and rookie ($117k)


It doesn't have to be Martin, just a player at his price.

I'm leaning towards Martin and Pruess; just to run the gauntlet and have a slightly different team

I really think ROB can go 110+ this season if you can manage him.

Screams breakout for me.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

I really think ROB can go 110+ this season if you can manage him.

Screams breakout for me.

If he had a round 12/13 bye id be going him over Grundy

 

[MacStradbroke]

I reckon at worst Rowell averages the same as Dusty but has potentially a higher ceiling.

McDonald is seagull 2.0 so could average 110 this year. Doc is a wait and see for me.

Dusty usually starts off slow so pick him up when he bottlms out as first upgrade.

Rowell and McDonald for me.

I have dusty every year but watching him in finals compared to h&a, they don’t add up. He’s still real good during the season but maybe a bit of whogivearatstossbag factor.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

I have dusty every year but watching him in finals compared to h&a, they don’t add up. He’s still real good during the season but maybe not quite the givearatstossbag factor.

Has the odd massive game. Will throw in a few 80's. Solid 100 average you'd think. Looking at the forwards he'll be easy top 6. Can't go to wrong starting him. Or you hope he starts slow then you get him slightly cheaper at some point.

 

[Mitchell54]

M.Crouch(M3), Cunnington(M6), Martin(F3) & Pruess(R2)
Vs
Atkins(M6), Cunnington(M5), Martin(F3) & Gawn(M2)
Vs
M.Crouch(M3), Heppell(M6), Daniher(F4) & Gawn(R2)

 

[ForeverHardcore]

M.Crouch(M3), Cunnington(M6), Martin(F3) & Pruess(R2)
Vs
Atkins(M6), Cunnington(M5), Martin(F3) & Gawn(M2)
Vs
M.Crouch(M3), Heppell(M6), Daniher(F4) & Gawn(R2)

Option 3 best balance
Crouch knows how to play in nicks system now and the back half along with laird and rob was huge
Heppell is a lock at 319k
Daniher a great option at that price
Gawn I’m assuming is r1 not r2 lock him in

 

[A Bit Dusty]

M.Crouch(M3), Cunnington(M6), Martin(F3) & Pruess(R2)
Vs
Atkins(M6), Cunnington(M5), Martin(F3) & Gawn(M2)
Vs
M.Crouch(M3), Heppell(M6), Daniher(F4) & Gawn(R2)

Anytime you can get Gawn in the Mids go for it

 

[Mitchell54]

Option 3 best balance
Crouch knows how to play in nicks system now and the back half along with laird and rob was huge
Heppell is a lock at 319k
Daniher a great option at that price
Gawn I’m assuming is r1 not r2 lock him in

****. I meant Grundy. 2 tall blokes who play AFL and rack up excessive SuperCoach points while both surnames start with G.

Basically the same

 

[Turly]

T.Stewart, Hately and Ziebell

Or

Short, Simpkin and W.Kelly

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

T.Stewart, Hately and Ziebell

Or

Short, Simpkin and W.Kelly

I actually like all 6 players here. Im going to go with option 2 though. Hopefully Simpkin improves his average enough to be a solid mid premium.

 

[Northernsoul74]

T.Stewart, Hately and Ziebell

Or

Short, Simpkin and W.Kelly

W Kelly is currently injured I believe.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Jelly vs titch

 

[Northernsoul74]

Jelly vs titch

I currently have Titch but it’s pending more info on his fitness.
Kelly could be an inspired pod pick but you can’t complain if/when he gets injured. We have enough history to say he’s injury prone. I might look if I feel I need a pod though.

 

[JDWCE]

Grundy + Atkins/Heppell
v
Oliver + Preuss

 

[King_Steele]

Grundy + Atkins/Heppell
v
Oliver + Preuss

Grundy & Heppell

 

[King_Steele]

Walsh v A.Brayshaw v Rowell

 

[JDWCE]

Walsh v A.Brayshaw v Rowell

Walsh. Longer quarters should only help him you'd think

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Oliver + Milera
vs
Lloyd + Hately

 

[Gresham2King]

Taranto and Steele vs Walsh and Merrett

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Taranto and Steele vs Walsh and Merrett

Walsh and Merrett easily IMO. I don't rate Taranto that highly and i dont think Steele will be much better, if any, than Merrett

 

[Northernsoul74]

Taranto and Steele vs Walsh and Merrett

Walsh and Merrett.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Walsh and Merrett easily IMO. I don't rate Taranto that highly and i dont think Steele will be much better, if any, than Merrett

Low ownership both of them as well.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Ok I'm thinking about playing some of these young guns midfield.

Macrae/Oliver/Heppell/Jones(Rookie Def)/Cox(Rookie Fwd) ----->Cerra/Simpkin/Macrae(Rookie Mid)/Short/Dunkley(Fwd)

 

[Turly]

Ok I'm thinking about playing some of these young guns midfield.

Macrae/Oliver/Heppell/Jones(Rookie Def)/Cox(Rookie Fwd) ----->Cerra/Simpkin/Macrae(Rookie Mid)/Short/Dunkley(Fwd)

View attachment 1055731
View attachment 1055733

I don't mind this.

Very risky but if it comes off you've potentially netted 14 keepers.

 

[Old Stuckup]

Short vs Simpkin (via Laird)