Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[ImissFrosty]

Short vs Simpkin (via Laird)

I think Simpkin, has a higher ceiling. I have both in my team rn. Both great picks.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Milrea vs H.Young.

Need to watch James Boarg cup on roles.

 

[Santoz]

Lloyd & Ziebell

vs

Duggan & Bolton

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Short vs Simpkin (via Laird)

Depends on what rookes are imo, might have to take an extra rookie defender, so Laird to mids.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Lloyd & Ziebell

vs

Duggan & Bolton

&

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Lloyd & Ziebell

vs

Duggan & Bolton

Lloyd & Ziebell. Reckon Bolton's average will stay about the same this year.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Guys Im really stuck on this one. Please help.

Hurn D3 vs Hurn D4

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Guys Im really stuck on this one. Please help.

Hurn D3 vs Hurn D4

Pussy make him D1

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Pussy make him D1

Theres looking like there might be enough rookies and I did say I was considering it

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Pussy make him D1

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

View attachment 1056252


View attachment 1056249

I'm drunk. Lets play a game.

100 likes and Ill lock this team in round 1

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Grundy dusty
Vs
Rob jelly/titch/620k and under mid

 

[pulpdriver]

Grundy dusty
Vs
Rob jelly/titch/620k and under mid

Grundy + whatever

 

[Santoz]

Grundy dusty
Vs
Rob jelly/titch/620k and under mid

ROB & Jelly before switching ROB to Grundy around Round 7 or 8.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Guys Im really stuck on this one. Please help.

Hurn D3 vs Hurn D4

Any D will do Shannon.

 

[blueiris]

Grundy dusty
Vs
Rob jelly/titch/620k and under mid

Rob could work if you have Gawn and Marshall as backup look at Zerrett

 

[Santoz]

Crows early fixture.



Only challenge is Goldy.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Crows early fixture.

View attachment 1056846

Only challenge is Goldy.

With goldy fading it’s not a bad shout at all!

I had rob the last few games last year and loved it. He was the first man in my off season notes to start. He looked heaps better then Grundy the last half of last year even though the scores didn’t really reflect it. I’ve normally viewed him as more of a AFL fantasy stud as he’s basically just a big pig with average disposal, but with natural growth he should average 110+ this year in supercoach imo.
Grundy gets bulk points for his hit outs to advantage and that’s something rob improved on late last year when he had a competent midfield with crouch and laird to palm to later in the year (112 the last 7 games)

For 6/7 games he’ll be worth a similar price to Grundy and under 5% ownership it’s definitely worth a crack. I don’t think Grundy will get his standard 150+ round 1 with stef Martin now to compete with as well as English. You also have cameron taking ruck time away. It’s not a bad strategy and gives me titch at m3 who’ll be a sure thing top 8 mid over someone like dusty/walsh who are both good picks but not on his level fantasy wise.

 

[Red Syrah]

Whitfield v Laird

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Whitfield v Laird

the one without a bruised liver

 

[Northernsoul74]

With goldy fading it’s not a bad shout at all!

I had rob the last few games last year and loved it. He was the first man in my off season notes to start. He looked heaps better then Grundy the last half of last year even though the scores didn’t really reflect it. I’ve normally viewed him as more of a AFL fantasy stud as he’s basically just a big pig with average disposal, but with natural growth he should average 110+ this year in supercoach imo.
Grundy gets bulk points for his hit outs to advantage and that’s something rob improved on late last year when he had a competent midfield with crouch and laird to palm to later in the year (112 the last 7 games)

For 6/7 games he’ll be worth a similar price to Grundy and under 5% ownership it’s definitely worth a crack. I don’t think Grundy will get his standard 150+ round 1 with stef Martin now to compete with as well as English. You also have cameron taking ruck time away. It’s not a bad strategy and gives me titch at m3 who’ll be a sure thing top 8 mid over someone like dusty/walsh who are both good picks but not on his level fantasy wise.

Starting to get tempted by taking on Grundy.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Whitfield v Laird

Laird
Too much uncertainty with whit and that injury
Could linger

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Starting to get tempted by taking on Grundy.

Yeah the more and more I see teams on here who are genuinely top 5k at least players the more I’m tempted to go against a few popular picks

Won’t name the backline guy I’m going against but Grundy will be way more achievable to buy from rob rather then preuss if he does actually start on should be a relatively easy swap round 7/8 or if rob truly breaks out a great long term pod

I still think Grundy will average 8-15 points more for the year but if rob matches him early it’s a huge win

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yeah the more and more I see teams on here who are genuinely top 5k at least players the more I’m tempted to go against a few popular picks

Won’t name the backline guy I’m going against but Grundy will be way more achievable to buy from rob rather then preuss if he does actually start on should be a relatively easy swap round 7/8 or if rob truly breaks out a great long term pod

I still think Grundy will average 8-15 points more for the year but if rob matches him early it’s a huge win

I'm actually considering Nic Nat over Grundy he played 17 games last year at an average of 110.5. With a full pre-season he should be 100% fit and CD love him. Also he has Round 13 bye and it would allow me to swap Cunnington---Dunkley

 

[Turly]

Whitfield v Laird

Laird

Simpkin, Brayshaw or Walsh