- Moderator
- #3,176
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Take nothing. That is my preference. Make him play for us. We have already paid him for the privilege.yes so how much more should they pay? He’s not worth a first. Belly will take what he can get in the end
How many contracted players have freo brought back to Perth over the years? He wants to move to melb for personal reasons. Freo will trade him.. wont be for a first. But will be for more then 29Take nothing. That is my preference. Make him play for us. We have already paid him for the privilege.
If the Dogs want to offer a 1st, then accept it. But I don't think they will because, like you say, he's not worth it. So instead do the thing that gets us the maximum value out of his contract: make him play.
It happened twice just last year, Lobb and Clark both came to Freo with a contract for 2022 - one of them was for Freo and is the same as Lobb this season. Same guy too.How many contracted players have freo brought back to Perth over the years? He wants to move to melb for personal reasons. Freo will trade him.. wont be for a first. But will be for more then 29
more then happy they kept lobb with 2 years on a deal. But with one year to go get the deal done. Think freo will trade him once they get Jackson doneIt happened twice just last year, Lobb and Clark both came to Freo with a contract for 2022 - one of them was for Freo and is the same as Lobb this season. Same guy too.
That's a generalisation.The only question with Treacy is his height. Key defenders are 200cms these days. The pav 193m forward is hard to cut it unless you are truly a gifted footballer b
So, looks like we're going back to the Gold Coast well with Corbitt and Sharp. Are they Brodie, Clark, Aish quality or Kersten/Matera quality? Must admit I'm a little concerned with Corbitt playing 4 games this year as a forward and only kicking 1 goal. At least with Brodie and Clark you could see that they were talented players who just hadn't gotten an opportunity. I'm not quite as sold on these two, but obviously the club must see something in them.
It won’t be much more… if they get a first rounder they should build belly a statue.
Don’t get it, all season fans bag him now he wants out they want way overs
Haha dreamingIt will get done because the Dogs will fold late and we get their pick #11.
Haha just being real & actually valuing players for what they are worthBe honest
R U Colin Young
At the time of the trade it was 13, 15, 20 and Geelong's future 4th for Cameron, GWS and Essendon's 2021 seconds. In 2021 Essendon, GWS and Geelong finished 8th, 6th, and 4th respectively.It was pick 15, 18 and 25 in 2020 for Cameron, pick 23 and pick 25 in 2021.
All up - it cost the cats pick 12 on a net basis to get Cameron.
They might be flogs but they have a point here you know…
What a joke of a comp!!
Haha dreaming
OK Colin. I would've thought pick 29 clearly wouldn't be enough for Lobb. No reason the Dogs can't trade up to an early 2nd/late first.Haha just being real & actually valuing players for what they are worth
GWS and GC cop a lot of flak but if you look at it impartially for those teams to complete on a level playing field they would need an extra 25 - 30% in the salary cap just to cover the frontier tax they have to pay to get players to stay
Wouldn’t mind 29 & F2 for Lobb & F3 freo get for acres
Haha you don’t actually believe they won’t trade him do you?
Belly wasn’t trading Lachie Neale in 2018 too
We’ll see he’ll get traded.
It won’t be much more… if they get a first rounder they should build belly a statue.
Don’t get it, all season fans bag him now he wants out they want way overs
What’s overs anything under 25 is overs really. If freo can get 29 with a little sweetener would be a good deal.
yes so how much more should they pay? He’s not worth a first. Belly will take what he can get in the end
How many contracted players have freo brought back to Perth over the years? He wants to move to melb for personal reasons. Freo will trade him.. wont be for a first. But will be for more then 29
more then happy they kept lobb with 2 years on a deal. But with one year to go get the deal done. Think freo will trade him once they get Jackson done
Another Colin Young bot account.Your not fooling anyone Mr Lobb.
I’m very interested as to what you think you know? Or were you just making a stereotypically poor judgement?
Ive said they'll get more then 29... be somewhere 20-25 hopefullyOK Colin. I would've thought pick 29 clearly wouldn't be enough for Lobb. No reason the Dogs can't trade up to an early 2nd/late first.
Guess we can all think whatever we want till he gets traded who knows. like i said if we go a first for lobb would be way oversI look at it from the opposite angle, what would we pay to have a structural player like Lobb, our best tall forward, next season? We won't find that in another player on our list already, we need to buy that. If we had to pay pick #11 this year to get him for one season and then trade him for a second round pick next season then I think it's worth the output.
Lobb to the Dogs is making a direct competitor better and us worse, Freo and the Dogs will be fighting for the same place in the finals. We can't be making them better by giving away a player we genuinely need.
They need to bleed. Just like Geelong for Tim Kelly.
Just like Melbourne will try and do for Jackson, but he is out of contract.