Teams 2022 Rate My Preseason Team

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Agent_99]

I am feeling pretty content with this team..


Options: Potentially downgrade Coleman to Curnow/ or Ralphsmith and then use the funds to upgrade Crisp to Lloyd. I can then also upgrade Durdin to Rachelle.

Thoughts?

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

very early team.. interested in thoughts

 

[JRyan23]

68k in bank, considering Weller and Whitfield to Wingard and Sicily, but happy with this atm

 

[JRyan23]

View attachment 1335566

Version two, needed an extra set in stone forward, so with a small shuffle i am locked in for round one barring no surprises this week. Scrolling the club boards, appears nearly everyone should be playing if the coaches listen to the fans. My four hours preseason work done!

Just don't like Lipinski at that price, maybe lower him to a 120k mid rookie and upgrade one of your 4 200kish FWDs to a premo

 

[Leeroy Brown 15]

If no cheaper rookies pop up in the next few weeks then I'm happy to go with this structure:

 

[Veer Right]

Just don't like Lipinski at that price, maybe lower him to a 120k mid rookie and upgrade one of your 4 200kish FWDs to a premo

Don't think he will become a fulltime mid?

 

[ImissFrosty]

Don't think he will become a fulltime mid?

even still, does he average enough to warrant the pricetag?

i'm happy to say i'm 95% sure the answer is no, at 360k you're wanting a 100 avg tbh. Will he get that. No ****ing way.

he's a terrible option imo

 

[Veer Right]

even still, does he average enough to warrant the pricetag?

i'm happy to say i'm 95% sure the answer is no, at 360k you're wanting a 100 avg tbh. Will he get that. No ******* way.

he's a terrible option imo

mmk well that 2/2 so i will look for a replacement. Know that i will haunt you both if he goes 105!

 

[Soggy2112]

mmk well that 2/2 so i will look for a replacement. Know that i will haunt you both if he goes 105!

He won’t

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Weak backline but otherwise i like this team. JHF can be downgraded if i feel i need extra cash. I dont really want to pick Whitfield but at that price he should be a bargain. Fingers crossed he doesnt get injured. Hewett and Richards have made their way into most of my plan teams now. Hewett recorded plenty CBAs and Richards passed the eye test big time in their practice games. Cripps, Rowell & Berry seem to be massive value although i am thinking of downgrading one of them but to be honest apart from Lloyd in defence and T.Thomas in forwardline, there arent many players not in my team that i want. Cant fit them all in anyway. Only ~5k in the bank

 

[Suma Magic]

My first crack. Rookies are just placeholders.

Hard locks:
Gawn
Grundy
Neale
Coniglio

Pretty set:
Whitfield
Butters
Sicily
Macrae

Could change:
Ridley
Short
Crisp
Rowell
Heeney
Mitchell
Berry
Dunkley

 

[Dunna Heartknee]

$80k in the bank

I think Chesser D/M is the perfect loophole player that will hopefully play later on in the season

 

[brendan84]

very early team.. interested in thoughts

View attachment 1335645

How about instead of Zilliams you just chuck your balls in a vice

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

My first crack. Rookies are just placeholders.

Hard locks:
Gawn
Grundy
Neale
Coniglio

Pretty set:
Whitfield
Butters
Sicily
Macrae

Could change:
Ridley
Short
Crisp
Rowell
Heeney
Mitchell
Berry
Dunkley

View attachment 1335690View attachment 1335689

Love it, just move the C to Gould and you're all set

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

$80k in the bank

I think Chesser D/M is the perfect loophole player that will hopefully play later on in the season


View attachment 1335726

Chesser is too expensive as a loop. Take Uwland instead. Lots of Sunday games and a chance at playing later in the season.

 

[Corleone]

Would appreciate any feedback

 

[BrutThough]

Settled on this for now. Any thoughts?

Mids a bit too cookie cutter so might end up changing one to keep it interesting.

Seems strange not having either Gawn or Grundy but happy going with Marshall. Think he's in for a big year,

I get burned by Heeney every year but maybe this will be the year it turns out differently.

 

[BrutThough]

Would appreciate any feedback

Pretty strong overall. Maybe 1 too many 200k players for my liking but that's also dependant on what rookies are named.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Would appreciate any feedback

Solid team.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Settled on this for now. Any thoughts?

Mids a bit too cookie cutter so might end up changing one to keep it interesting.

Seems strange not having either Gawn or Grundy but happy going with Marshall. Think he's in for a big year,

I get burned by Heeney every year but maybe this will be the year it turns out differently.

View attachment 1335763

I'd try and get Dunkley in for Heeney. If Dunkley starts like last year you'll struggle to get him in. Only thing that stops him being the top forward is injury imo.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Would appreciate any feedback

Just be wary of Dawson, didn’t play practice match and now won’t play this weeks either. Unknown role and probably doesn’t get kick outs either

 

[Petrify]

Loving this team. 12k in the bank. Obviously a fair few $102k rookies so will depend on who plays, but can downgrade Preuss to comben to fix that.

Also has anyone noticed how ****ed the byes are for rucks? Collingwood, Melbourne & Freo all have their bye on the same round

 

[Soggy2112]

Settled on this for now. Any thoughts?

Mids a bit too cookie cutter so might end up changing one to keep it interesting.

Seems strange not having either Gawn or Grundy but happy going with Marshall. Think he's in for a big year,

I get burned by Heeney every year but maybe this will be the year it turns out differently.

View attachment 1335763

Probably a few too many gambles IMO.

I’d have one, maybe two at the most of Heeney, Weller, Rowell and Marshall otherwise you risk burning through trades early.

 

[Duckworthy]

A few more weeks to work out the rest

 

[Thomas Hird 2020]

Looks a bit crazy - but leaning towards something like this.

I feel there is value to be had in the FWD line this year and am not sold on DEF rookies. So going skinny in the mids…