Analysis 2023 All Australian Team Awards Night

[TheUnicorn]

Here's my update after Round 17

B Aliir Andrews Ryan
HB Houston Moore Vlaustin
C Anderson N Daicos Merrett
HF Bontempelli Curnow Petracca
F Rozee Walker Greene

Ruck Darcy Dawson Butters

INT Sinclair, Taranto, Liberatore, Neale

IN - Vlaustin

OUT - Serong

On Watch:

Witts, Rowell, Ballard, Redman, Dunkley, Blicavs, Pendlebury, Mitchell, J Daicos, English, Nankervis, C Cameron, De Goey, Haynes, Bolton, Sicily, J Cameron, Finlayson, Parker, Hawkins, Gulden, J Kelly, Quaynor, Parish, Duncan, Serong, Marshall

Needs more Martin

 

[beerbandit]

M

Personally I'd put Rozee at HF and replace Degoey with Neale

Yeah fair enough.

Very reasonable, I’d be happy to swap Rozee with JDG. Neale was the name I crossed out to put Gulden in so he’s right in the mix for mine also.

 

[beerbandit]

Needs more Martin

Martin and J Daicos are the wingers for mine

 

[Red_man2008]

I’ll have a crack, I’ve thrown De Goey in, don’t think the 3 weeks out will hurt his chances

B - Sicily Moore Stewart
HB - N Daicos Andrews Sinclair
C - J Daicos Butters Martin
HF - Petracca Curnow De Goey
F - C Cameron Walker Greene
R - English Dawson Taranto
IC - Serong Merrett Rozee Gulden

So many picking C Cameron. He’s been rubbish for 2 months.

 

[Red_man2008]

Here's my update after Round 17

B Aliir Andrews Ryan
HB Houston Moore Vlaustin
C Anderson N Daicos Merrett
HF Bontempelli Curnow Petracca
F Rozee Walker Greene

Ruck Darcy Dawson Butters

INT Sinclair, Taranto, Liberatore, Neale

IN - Vlaustin

OUT - Serong

On Watch:

Witts, Rowell, Ballard, Redman, Dunkley, Blicavs, Pendlebury, Mitchell, J Daicos, English, Nankervis, C Cameron, De Goey, Haynes, Bolton, Sicily, J Cameron, Finlayson, Parker, Hawkins, Gulden, J Kelly, Quaynor, Parish, Duncan, Serong, Marshall

The fact Cerra is not on your watch list says you don’t watch slot of footy. Shat all over Andersons season. He’s atleast be interchange if not the 40.

 

[longdonkey]

The fact Cerra is not on your watch list says you don’t watch slot of footy. Shat all over Andersons season. He’s atleast be interchange if not the 40.

Yeah sure - move on I'm talking about Noah Anderson not Jed Anderson.

 

[Skipper_]

Yeah sure - move on I'm talking about Noah Anderson not Jed Anderson.

View attachment 1733534

You’re looking at career averages there.

 

[Progressive Aggresion]

My AA 40 SQUAD:

ADE - T. Walker, - J. Dawson - I. Rankine

BRI - H. Andrews - L. Neale - J. Dunkley - C. Cameron

CAR - A. Cerra - C. Curnow

COL - D. Moore - N. Daicos - J. Daicos - J. De-Goey

ESS - Z. Merrett - N. Martin - M. Redman - K. Langford

FRE - L. Ryan - C. Serong

GEE - T. Stewart - T. Hawkins

GOL - n/a

GWS - T. Green - T. Greene - S. Coniglio

HAW - n/a

MEL - C. Petracca - J. Viney - S. May

NOR - N. Larkey

POR - A. Allir - D. Houston - C. Rozee - Z. Butters - J. Finlayson

RIC - T. Taranto

STK - J. Sinclair - R. Marshall

SYD - E. Gulden

WCE - n/a

WBD - T. English - T. Liberatore - M. Bontempelli

 

[beerbandit]

Yeah sure - move on I'm talking about Noah Anderson not Jed Anderson.

View attachment 1733534

Adam Cerra has been very good this year, would be winning Carlton’s B & F in a canter

 

[longdonkey]

You’re looking at career averages there.

Yeah you're right - quick edit - same result though

 

[kreuze_missile]

Jacob Weitering

23

Jacob Weitering

Age

27

Ht

195cm

Wt

102kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.8

4star

K

9.1

4star

HB

4.7

3star

M

5.6

5star

T

1.3

3star

MG

189.4

3star

No current season stats available

D

16.8

4star

K

10.8

4star

HB

6.0

4star

M

6.0

5star

T

0.8

3star

MG

263.4

4star

.

That is all.

 

[longdonkey]

Got to love these Carlton supporters who want multiple players in the AA team while they are flying high in 11th.

 

[Progressive Aggresion]

My AA 40 SQUAD:

ADE - T. Walker, - J. Dawson - I. Rankine

BRI - H. Andrews - L. Neale - J. Dunkley - C. Cameron

CAR - A. Cerra - C. Curnow

COL - D. Moore - N. Daicos - J. Daicos - J. De-Goey

ESS - Z. Merrett - N. Martin - M. Redman - K. Langford

FRE - L. Ryan - C. Serong

GEE - T. Stewart - T. Hawkins

GOL - n/a

GWS - T. Green - T. Greene - S. Coniglio

HAW - n/a

MEL - C. Petracca - J. Viney - S. May

NOR - N. Larkey

POR - A. Allir - D. Houston - C. Rozee - Z. Butters - J. Finlayson

RIC - T. Taranto

STK - J. Sinclair - R. Marshall

SYD - E. Gulden

WCE - n/a

WBD - T. English - T. Liberatore - M. Bontempelli

MY AA 22

FB - L. Ryan - H. Andrews - A. Allir

HB - J. Sinclair - D. Moore - D. Houston

C - J. Dawson - T. Taranto - E. Gulden

HF - C. Petracca - T. Walker - C. Rozee

FF - T. Greene - C. Curnow - I. Rankine

FOLL - T. English - N. Daicos - Z. Merrett

INT - Z. Butters - L. Neale - M. Bontempelli - T. Stewart

 

[adammania9]

Current team:
B: James Sicily - Darcy Moore - Callum Wilkie
HB: Nick Daicos - Charlie Ballard - Jack Sinclair
C: Josh Daicos - Jordan Dawson - Zach Merrett
HF: Connor Rozee - Taylor Walker - Jeremy Cameron
F: Charlie Cameron - Charlie Curnow - Toby Greene
R: Tim English - Marcus Bontempelli - Zak Butters
I: Lachie Neale - Tim Taranto - Christian Petracca - Dan Houston

OUT: Charlie Ballard, Josh Daicos, Jeremy Cameron
IN: Harris Andrews, Tom Stewart, Tom Hawkins

B: James Sicily - Harris Andrews - Callum Wilkie
HB: Tom Stewart - Darcy Moore - Jack Sinclair
C: Nick Daicos - Jordan Dawson - Zach Merrett
HF: Connor Rozee - Taylor Walker - Christian Petracca
F: Charlie Cameron - Charlie Curnow - Toby Greene
R: Tim English - Marcus Bontempelli - Zak Butters
I: Lachie Neale - Tim Taranto - Tom Hawkins - Dan Houston

 

[kreuze_missile]

Got to love these Carlton supporters who want multiple players in the AA team while they are flying high in 11th.

Charlie Curnow is a lock. I assume you aren't disputing that.

Jacob Weitering hasn't lost a contest all year and leads what is stastically a top 4 backline. His claim is as good as any for the CHB spot.

IMO that's it at Carlton. Cerra's had a good month but I don't think he is in the mix.

 

[beerbandit]

Charlie Curnow is a lock. I assume you aren't disputing that.

Jacob Weitering hasn't lost a contest all year and leads what is stastically a top 4 backline. His claim is as good as any for the CHB spot.

IMO that's it at Carlton. Cerra's had a good month but I don't think he is in the mix.

Very subjective.

Charlie Curnow is by no means a lock. The KPF is very close IMO

 

[Shadow89]

My AA 40 SQUAD:

ADE - T. Walker, - J. Dawson - I. Rankine

BRI - H. Andrews - L. Neale - J. Dunkley - C. Cameron

CAR - A. Cerra - C. Curnow

COL - D. Moore - N. Daicos - J. Daicos - J. De-Goey

ESS - Z. Merrett - N. Martin - M. Redman - K. Langford

FRE - L. Ryan - C. Serong

GEE - T. Stewart - T. Hawkins

GOL - n/a

GWS - T. Green - T. Greene - S. Coniglio

HAW - n/a

MEL - C. Petracca - J. Viney - S. May

NOR - N. Larkey

POR - A. Allir - D. Houston - C. Rozee - Z. Butters - J. Finlayson

RIC - T. Taranto

STK - J. Sinclair - R. Marshall

SYD - E. Gulden

WCE - n/a

WBD - T. English - T. Liberatore - M. Bontempelli

Yeahhh even with Jez Cameron being out for a couple of weeks, he's still earned his spot over Langford and Finlayson.

 

[Yoda_]

My AA 40 SQUAD:

ADE - T. Walker, - J. Dawson - I. Rankine

BRI - H. Andrews - L. Neale - J. Dunkley - C. Cameron

CAR - A. Cerra - C. Curnow

COL - D. Moore - N. Daicos - J. Daicos - J. De-Goey

ESS - Z. Merrett - N. Martin - M. Redman - K. Langford

FRE - L. Ryan - C. Serong

GEE - T. Stewart - T. Hawkins

GOL - n/a

GWS - T. Green - T. Greene - S. Coniglio

HAW - n/a

MEL - C. Petracca - J. Viney - S. May

NOR - N. Larkey

POR - A. Allir - D. Houston - C. Rozee - Z. Butters - J. Finlayson

RIC - T. Taranto

STK - J. Sinclair - R. Marshall

SYD - E. Gulden

WCE - n/a

WBD - T. English - T. Liberatore - M. Bontempelli

Thats a pretty bloody good and accurate squad in my opinion

well done

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Got to love these Carlton supporters who want multiple players in the AA team while they are flying high in 11th.

Makes a lot of sense actually.
4-5 gun players and 40 VFL plodders.

 

[kreuze_missile]

Charlie Curnow is by no means a lock. The KPF is very close IMO

If Charlie Curnow isn't a lock then no-one is.

First picked every day of the week & twice on Sunday.

 

[Red_man2008]

Yeah sure - move on I'm talking about Noah Anderson not Jed Anderson.

View attachment 1733544

Id still take Cerra sue to Andersons 5+ Turnovers a game and his + 8% time on ground.

 

[Cringle]

Got to love these Carlton supporters who want multiple players in the AA team while they are flying high in 11th.

This is kind of what we do around here, pal.

 

[beerbandit]

If Charlie Curnow isn't a lock then no-one is.

First picked every day of the week & twice on Sunday.

Yes most likely for Carlton but definitely not in the AA team

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Pretty clear first picked is Nick Daicos, kents an absolute freakshow. Put him anywhere on the field you want but he's in the team even if he missed the rest of the season

 

[Fadge]

Adam Cerra has been very good this year, would be winning Carlton’s B & F in a canter

Not saying much though...