Analysis 2023 All Australian Team Awards Night

[citizen-erased]

Charlie Cameron slowly but surely losing grip on his spot.

i think it's gone. he had a patch that was better than Rankine, but Rankine has been consistently good this season. Not just scoring but getting up the ground and making things happen.

 

[Milux]

i think it's gone. he had a patch that was better than Rankine, but Rankine has been consistently good this season. Not just scoring but getting up the ground and making things happen.

Maybe. Charlie tries to get up the ground a heap. Sometimes he pops up in defence. But yeh Rankines been crazy good this year. If Charlie can kick 20 from the last 7 tho I think he might just get it.

 

[Warwick]

Merrett will start. Has been a top 5 sides best player all year. He starts

Strange logic. Neale’s been a top 3 side’s best player all year and not starting.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Got to love these Carlton supporters who want multiple players in the AA team while they are flying high in 11th.

Curnow will make the team.
Cerra should make the squad, probably won’t.
Weitering shouldn’t make the squad, probably will.

The rest are not in with a chance as it stands.

 

[HirdsTheWord]

Strange logic. Neale’s been a top 3 side’s best player all year and not starting.

I saw a stats flash on the telly that Merrett has been #1 player in the comp last 6-7 weeks.

Interesting to see where Neale ranks in that.

 

[tiger_tough]

Here are the 40 players who have been in the most Defensive 1 on 1 contests…

J. Buckley 81 (lost 19… 23.5%)
C. Ballard 64 (lost 15… 23.4%)
A. Aliir 60 (lost 17… 28.3%)
N. Balta 60 (lost 17… 28.3%)
H. Andrews 59 (lost 12… 20.3%)
A. Pearce 57 (lost 13… 22.8%)
J. Weitering 55 (lost 6… 10.9%)
C. Wilkie 54 (lost 16… 29.6%)
S. Collins 53 (lost 9… 17.0%)
S. May 51 (lost 9… 17.6%)
B. Zerk-Thatcher 51 (lost 19… 37.3%)
D. Howard 47 (lost 11… 23.4%)
N. Murray 47 (lost 7… 14.9%)
L. Jones 44 (lost 11… 25.0%)
T. Young 44 (lost 5… 11.4%)
T. Barrass 42 (lost 12… 28.6%)
J. Battle 42 (lost 12… 28.6%)
L. Young 41 (lost 12… 29.3%)
B. Cox 40 (lost 8… 20.0%)
D. Moore 40 (lost 7… 17.5%)
J. Butts 35 (lost 9… 25.7%)
J. Sicily 35 (lost 5… 14.3%)
N. Murphy 34 (lost 7… 20.6%)
E. Ratugolea 34 (lost 9… 26.5%)
J. Ridley 34 (lost 8… 23.5%)
T. McKenzie 33 (lost 12… 36.4%)
J. Payne 33 (lost 5… 15.2%)
C. Idun 31 (lost 3… 9.7%)
T. Doedee 30 (lost 8… 26.7%)
J. Lever 29 (lost 5… 17.2%)
D. Grimes 27 (lost 6… 22.2%)
A. Keath 27 (lost 9… 33.3%)
J. Blanck 26 (lost 7… 26.9%)
A. Corr 26 (lost 3… 11.5%)
S. Frost 25 (lost 8… 32.0%)
J. Ziebell 25 (lost 5… 20.0%)
T. McCartin 24 (lost 5… 20.8%)
L. Ryan 24 (lost 6… 25.0%)
B. Starcevich 24 (lost 6… 25.0%)
R. Fox 23 (lost 4… 17.4%)
B. McKay 23 (lost 8… 34.8%)

Pretty impressive by first year player Tylar Young....

 

[Warwick]

I saw a stats flash on the telly that Merrett has been #1 player in the comp last 6-7 weeks.

Interesting to see where Neale ranks in that.

It’s got nothing to do with Neale.

Why would it matter where you were ranked and for which team, when discussing whether a player starts or not (or is even included)?

 

[HirdsTheWord]

It’s got nothing to do with Neale.

Why would it matter where you were ranked and for which team, when discussing whether a player starts or not (or is even included)?

A Players rank doesn't matter to if he starts on the field or on the bench?

ok lol

 

[KissKiss]

So many picking C Cameron. He’s been rubbish for 2 months.

Charlie Cameron slowly but surely losing grip on his spot.

He had such a massive lead as a small forward for a while but that's gone now. Still could come home with it but needs to swing the form around fast.

Good chance we have another year with Greene as the only "true" small forward in the pocket and cram extra mids on the flanks. Not sure Charlie or Rankine can lock a spot in at the moment.

 

[00Stinger]

We'll be 5th this time next week, get ready to add a few more in.

 

[Warwick]

A Players rank doesn't matter to if he starts on the field or on the bench?

ok lol

Read what he said again champ.

 

[Mayes2Gray]

Yo

Green has been the best true centerman this year in my opinion he has been so consistent and is 3rd in disposals per game this year, he wins hard ball and uses it well he is a real asset, has had 3 goal games and 13 tackle games as well so can do both sides of the game.

I would put him on par with Bont this year.

My order of midfielders this year top 5

Daicos
Merrett
Bont
Green
Rozee/Serong/Neale

u rate Rozee above butters this year?

 

[Mayes2Gray]

Do

MY AA 22

FB - L. Ryan - H. Andrews - A. Allir

HB - J. Sinclair - D. Moore - D. Houston

C - J. Dawson - T. Taranto - E. Gulden

HF - C. Petracca - T. Walker - C. Rozee

FF - T. Greene - C. Curnow - I. Rankine

FOLL - T. English - N. Daicos - Z. Merrett

INT - Z. Butters - L. Neale - M. Bontempelli - T. Stewart

Does Rozee play hf often?

 

[Lingsface]

Yo

u rate Rozee above butters this year?

Yes as an overall season I rate Rozee as good as just about anyone, hasn’t played a bad game. So damaging gets length in every possesion uses it well and can score 2/3 goals along with close on 30 possesions some days.

 

[Joker91]

Yes as an overall season I rate Rozee as good as just about anyone, hasn’t played a bad game. So damaging gets length in every possesion uses it well and can score 2/3 goals along with close on 30 possesions some days.

Is averaging 0.9 goals a game.
Only had 30+ disposals once this season.

 

[Lingsface]

Is averaging 0.9 goals a game.
Only had 30+ disposals once this season.

Some days is the key word he can pop up for these types of games 28 possesions 2/3 goals.

His average game is 26 and 1.

 

[buttermuffs]

Maybe. Charlie tries to get up the ground a heap. Sometimes he pops up in defence. But yeh Rankines been crazy good this year. If Charlie can kick 20 from the last 7 tho I think he might just get it.

Charlie has managed 28 tackles inside 50 this year compared to 14 from Rankine (and 20 from Greene). Not the be all end all of course but he has been one of the best pressure smalls in the league still.

Whatever happens I hope Cameron loses out to another small forward instead of a midfielder being planted in the pocket.

 

[Mayes2Gray]

Yes as an overall season I rate Rozee as good as just about anyone, hasn’t played a bad game. So damaging gets length in every possesion uses it well and can score 2/3 goals along with close on 30 possesions some days.

Interesting. Not criticising, just an interesting neutral take. Think most of us would have rated butters season as better but maybe we are blinded by his breakout few weeks earlier in the season.

 

[raskolnikov]

We'll be 5th this time next week, get ready to add a few more in.

And how will this happen when you're 6 points behind 5th?

 

[Pistol Night]

And how will this happen when you're 6 points behind 5th?

Carlton are that shit if they beat Port the AFL will award them 8 points for encouragement

 

[Shadow89]

We'll be 5th this time next week, get ready to add a few more in.

I don't think you understand how the ladder works...

 

[Lingsface]

Interesting. Not criticising, just an interesting neutral take. Think most of us would have rated butters season as better but maybe we are blinded by his breakout few weeks earlier in the season.

Yeah either way bloody good to have them both in your side haha.

 

[bungalow_bill]

Strange logic. Neale’s been a top 3 side’s best player all year and not starting.

#1 clearance player

by comparison Merrett is 54th

 

[JyeDye]

And how will this happen when you're 6 points behind 5th?

Will and determination.

 

[Hava Alle]

B: Houston Andrews Stewart
HB: Daicos Moore Sinclair
C: Gulden Bontempelli Daicos
HF: Rozee Curnow Petracca
F: Greene Walker C Cameron
Foll: English Liberatore Butters
Int: Dawson Taranto Neale Dunkley

Ins: Houston, Gulden
Out: Redman, Martin

B: Houston Andrews Stewart
HB: Daicos Moore Sinclair
C: Gulden Bontempelli Daicos
HF: Rozee Curnow Petracca
F: Greene Walker C Cameron
Foll: English Liberatore Butters
Int: Dawson Merrett Neale Taranto

Ins: Merrett
Out: Dunkley