MVP 2023 GWS MVP - Round 19 vs Suns

Giant Strides · Jul 23, 2023

A very good result today, with a swag of players excelling. The problem from a game like this is how do you distribute your votes optimally. Don't be too stingy with your best players - the top player deserves 5 votes not 3! You have 15 votes, maximum 5 to any single player. Go and vote.

GWS Goose · Jul 23, 2023

4. Cogs
4. Kelly
3. Ash
2. Taylor
1. Toby g
1. Brent Daniels

Gigantic · Jul 23, 2023

4 Cogs
3 Taylor
2 Kelly
2 Greene
2 Whitfield
1 Daniels

Really wanted to give Briggs some points too.

MelbourneGWS · Jul 23, 2023

5- Sam Taylor
4- Stephen Coniglio
3- Toby Greene
2- Josh Kelly
1- Brent Daniels

Colonial · Jul 23, 2023

5- Cogs
4- Taylor
3- Daniels
2- Greene
1- Briggs

Orange crush · Jul 24, 2023

4- Sam Taylor
3- Stephen Coniglio
3- Toby Greene
2- Josh Kelly
1 - Perryman
1- Daniels
1- Buckley

BarryAglett · Jul 24, 2023

4 - Taylor
3 - Cogs
2 - HH
2 - Josh Kelly
2 - Toby G
1 - Daniels
1 - Whitfield

hdeifh · Jul 24, 2023

5 Daniels
4 Taylor
3 Greene
2 Coniglio
1 Whitfield

domologue · Jul 24, 2023

5- Sam Taylor
4- Stephen Coniglio
3- Toby Greene
2- Josh Kelly
1- Brent Daniels

GWS Goose · Jul 24, 2023

The coaches votes, I feel a bit vindicated that Lachie Ash got some votes, thought he was terrific, but no one on here or in the media had him in the best. At least one of the coaches agreed with me

Maximus 2011 · Jul 24, 2023

Sam Taylor - All 15 votes

Giant Strides · Jul 24, 2023

Maximus 2011 said:
Sam Taylor - All 15 votes

That you, Slammer? I'm unsure we can accept you voting for yourself?

Giant Strides · Jul 24, 2023

Well, the conundrum for me is who to choose from about 11 players who deserve recognition.

The key defenders - Taylor, Buckley & Himmelberg - intercepted, marked and spoiled most everything that came their way (especially after quarter time). The running defenders in Whitfield and Ash were superb in launching the counterattacks (498 & 442 MG respectively). Briggs outpointed Witts (who's a really good ruckman IMHO), and Cogs and Kelly got close enough to the Suns' mids in the clearance battle and won out in the larger contest battle. Greene was mesmeric up front, while Brown and Daniels were influential in the front half too.

So, apologies to the 5 guys who missed points, who all deserved to be rewarded more, but here's how I went:

5 - Stephen Coniglio: ultimately, I went with who impacted the midfield battle the most, and I thought it was Cogs
4 - Sam Taylor: a brick wall in defence, and led the backline superbly
3 - Lachie Whitfield: thought his counterattack was excellent
1 - Keiran Briggs: outpointed Witts in the ruck battle in clearances, tackles & influence on the outcome
1 - Lachie Ash: hitting his straps on the counter
1 - Binga Daniels: returning to his outstanding early season form after injury

Maximus 2011 · Jul 25, 2023

Giant Strides said:
That you, Slammer? I'm unsure we can accept you voting for yourself?

View attachment 1754008

Sorry mate, I only go by Ragnar.

Giant Strides · Aug 31, 2023

Round 19 voting tally - Taylor a hugely popular MVG.

Giant Strides · Oct 5, 2023

Progressive tally after round 19 - Sam Taylor making strides after his injury absence, while Greene, Kelly, Cogs & Green fight it out at the top!

WBBL Season 10 - Oct '24 to Dec '25

MVP 2023 GWS MVP - Round 19 vs Suns

Moderator

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Norm Smith Medallist

7th Round Draft Pick

Debutant

Senior List

Brownlow Medallist

All Australian

Moderator

Moderator

All Australian

Moderator

Moderator

MVP 2023 GWS MVP - Round 19 vs Suns

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account