2023 Trade Time Talk - Henley Beach Café Returns

Most Likely Option of this Trade Period

  • Nothing Happens but a few lame Pick swaps and we are let down

    Votes: 43 35.2%
  • Matt Crouch leaves and we get a 3rd round compo

    Votes: 20 16.4%
  • We recruit a second(3rd) rate defender for needs

    Votes: 25 20.5%
  • We somehow manage to move up in the draft

    Votes: 28 23.0%
  • A big name comes out of nowhere to us and we rejoice

    Votes: 11 9.0%
  • Organic Growth

    Votes: 40 32.8%

  • Total voters
    122
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

11 and 14 still good.
ok, time to break this down..

Brisbane:
11 - Lincoln McCarthy (Med Fwd). SA. 29. Getting on a bit. Unlikely.
14 - James Madden (Med Def). Ireland. 23. Right age. Not a need. Unlikely.

Carlton:
11 - Mitch McGovern (Med Def). WA. 28. LOL Very Unlikely.
14 - Oliver Hollands (Mid). VIC. 19. Wont move from Carlton. Unlikely.

Collingwood:
11 - Dan McStay (Key Fwd). VIC. 28. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Darcy Cameron (Ruck). WA. 28. Nice upgrade on ROB. Unlikely.

Essendon:
11 - Will Snelling (Med Fwd). SA. 26. Right age. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Jordan Ridley (Key Def). VIC. 24. Yes please! but unlikely.

Fremantle:
11 - James Aish (Mid). SA. 27. Hard pass and unlikely. We've had opportunity before.
14 - Nathan Wilson (Med Def). WA. 30. Not a need and too old. Unlikely.

Geelong:
11 - Cooper Whyte (Med Def). 20. No idea who this is. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - No 14?

Gold Coast:
11 - Touk Miller (Mid). VIC 27. Yes please but very unlikely.
14 - Lachie Weller (Med Def). QLD. 27. Not a need. Always injured. Unlikely.

GWS:
11 - Braydon Pruess (Ruck). 28. Talk about tanking your career. Too old, no good. Unlikely.
14 - Toby Bedford (Med Fwd). VIC. 23. Would love to have him. Unlikely.

Hawthorn:
11 - Connor Nash (Mid). Ireland. 25. Part of Hawthorn's rebuild. Unlikely but maybe gettable?
14 - Jack Scrimshaw (Med Def). VIC. 25. Maybe gettable. Do we want?

Melbourne:
11 - Max Gawn (Ruck). VIC. 31. Wont. ever. happen.
14 - Michael Hibberd (Med Def). VIC. 33. Too old. Not a need. Unlikely.

North:
11 - Luke McDonald (Med Def). VIC. 28. Maybe? Unlikely we want him?
14 - Liam Shiels (Mid). VIC. 32. Too old, too slow. Unlikely.

Port:
11 - Jeremy Finlayson (Key Fwd). NSW. 27. Not a need, no thanks. Unlikely.
14 - Miles Bergman (Med Def). VIC. 21. Good age. Is a need. Maybe gettable?

Richmond:
11 - Jason Castagna (Med Fwd). VIC. 27. Retired. Very Unlikely.
14 - Tim Taranto (Mid). VIC. 25. Mega contract. Very unlikely.

St Kilda:
11 - Hunter Clark (Mid). VIC. 24. Right age. Is a need. Maybe gettable?
14 - Liam Stocker (Med Def). VIC, 23. insert SOS smirk Unlikely.

Sydney:
11 - Tom Papley (Med Fwd). VIC. 27. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Callum Mills (Mid). NSW. 26. Yes please but very unlikely.

West Coast:
11 - Tim Kelly (Mid). WA. 29. Mega contract. Rebuilding West Coast. Maybe?
14 - Liam Duggan (Med Def). VIC. 26. Would be a great get. Maybe gettable?

Footscray:
11 - Jack Macrae (Mid). VIC. 29. Elite. Dogs salary dump? Maybe gettable?
14 - Rhylee West (Med Fwd). VIC. 23. Dogs father-son. Very unlikely.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ok, time to break this down..

Brisbane:
11 - Lincoln McCarthy (Med Fwd). SA. 29. Getting on a bit. Unlikely.
14 - James Madden (Med Def). Ireland. 23. Right age. Not a need. Unlikely.

Carlton:
11 - Mitch McGovern (Med Def). WA. 28. LOL Very Unlikely.
14 - Oliver Hollands (Mid). VIC. 19. Wont move from Carlton. Unlikely.

Collingwood:
11 - Dan McStay (Key Fwd). VIC. 28. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Darcy Cameron (Ruck). WA. 28. Nice upgrade on ROB. Unlikely.

Essendon:
11 - Will Snelling (Med Fwd). SA. 26. Right age. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Jordan Ridley (Key Def). VIC. 24. Yes please! but unlikely.

Fremantle:
11 - James Aish (Mid). SA. 27. Hard pass and unlikely. We've had opportunity before.
14 - Nathan Wilson (Med Def). WA. 30. Not a need and too old. Unlikely.

Geelong:
11 - Cooper Whyte (Med Def). 20. No idea who this is. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - No 14?

Gold Coast:
11 - Touk Miller (Mid). VIC 27. Yes please but very unlikely.
14 - Lachie Weller (Med Def). QLD. 27. Not a need. Always injured. Unlikely.

GWS:
11 - Braydon Pruess (Ruck). 28. Talk about tanking your career. Too old, no good. Unlikely.
14 - Toby Bedford (Med Fwd). VIC. 23. Would love to have him. Unlikely.

Hawthorn:
11 - Connor Nash (Mid). Ireland. 25. Part of Hawthorn's rebuild. Unlikely but maybe gettable?
14 - Jack Scrimshaw (Med Def). VIC. 25. Maybe gettable. Do we want?

Melbourne:
11 - Max Gawn (Ruck). VIC. 31. Wont. ever. happen.
14 - Michael Hibberd (Med Def). VIC. 33. Too old. Not a need. Unlikely.

North:
11 - Luke McDonald (Med Def). VIC. 28. Maybe? Unlikely we want him?
14 - Liam Shiels (Mid). VIC. 32. Too old, too slow. Unlikely.

Port:
11 - Jeremy Finlayson (Key Fwd). NSW. 27. Not a need, no thanks. Unlikely.
14 - Miles Bergman (Med Def). VIC. 21. Good age. Is a need. Maybe gettable?

Richmond:
11 - Jason Castagna (Med Fwd). VIC. 27. Retired. Very Unlikely.
14 - Tim Taranto (Mid). VIC. 25. Mega contract. Very unlikely.

St Kilda:
11 - Hunter Clark (Mid). VIC. 24. Right age. Is a need. Maybe gettable?
14 - Liam Stocker (Med Def). VIC, 23. insert SOS smirk Unlikely.

Sydney:
11 - Tom Papley (Med Fwd). VIC. 27. Not a need. Unlikely.
14 - Callum Mills (Mid). NSW. 26. Yes please but very unlikely.

West Coast:
11 - Tim Kelly (Mid). WA. 29. Mega contract. Rebuilding West Coast. Maybe?
14 - Liam Duggan (Med Def). VIC. 26. Would be a great get. Maybe gettable?

Footscray:
11 - Jack Macrae (Mid). VIC. 29. Elite. Dogs salary dump? Maybe gettable?
14 - Rhylee West (Med Fwd). VIC. 23. Dogs father-son. Very unlikely.
If nothing else. That is some work putting that together.

And yet I feel that none of those listed are players we'd be getting.

On CPH2333 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Alex has turned up
Fran Healy Reaction GIF by Travis
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2023 Trade Time Talk - Henley Beach Café Returns

Back
Top