![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,112
- 22,019
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Draper and Lombard being that far down is mind melting.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
I’m with you, some of the picks here are way off imo. No Ben Campo in top 30? Usually RMC so spot on, but they drank six stubbies watching the last VicM Vs VicC game and ranked them on that.Draper and Lombard being that far down is mind melting.
Highlights how even the draft is. People's opinions will be very different and volatileI’m with you, some of the picks here are way off imo. No Ben Campo in top 30? Usually RMC so spot on, but they drank six stubbies watching the last VicM Vs VicC game and ranked them on that.
Richmond's only one is Zaydyn Lockwood. Probably more rookie.Anyone can tell me or know where I can find all the F/S and NGA kids that clubs are likely to take this year? Trying to make a massive phantum draft but not sure about the more unknown 'priority access' kids
Yeah I'm normally pretty aligned with RMC most years but this year's rankings seem way off. I know I'm the lone one out with FOS but Lalor in the top 5 ahead of Lombard who's been killing it all year is a bit mind boggling.I’m with you, some of the picks here are way off imo. No Ben Campo in top 30? Usually RMC so spot on, but they drank six stubbies watching the last VicM Vs VicC game and ranked them on that.
Mate you’re not the only one that’s questioning FOS I was on our board a few weeks back too. Went about as well for me as it has for you in here.Yeah I'm normally pretty aligned with RMC most years but this year's rankings seem way off. I know I'm the lone one out with FOS but Lalor in the top 5 ahead of Lombard who's been killing it all year is a bit mind boggling.
As others have said, unusually even draft crop this year so I guess we're going to see some serious differences in opinion.
I like seeing against the norm of what Twomey and others suggestI’m with you, some of the picks here are way off imo. No Ben Campo in top 30? Usually RMC so spot on, but they drank six stubbies watching the last VicM Vs VicC game and ranked them on that.
RMC are the main "others", after Twomey.I like seeing against the norm of what Twomey and others suggest
A lot of people are watching the U18 footy these days, not just the National Championships. There's a lot of posters here who are at CTL games every week. Others at SANFL and WAFL colts, etc.At the end of the day anyone can do that. All they do is listen, look at stats, see who played 18s last year and come to a very similar list.
For years, the main criticism of Twomey is that he gets a lot of his information that influence his ranking from recruiters.I want to see the ones that rate the Phoenix Gothards above the norm ect
Recruiters have fairly different spots for players to Twomey
Twomey put Tauru on the map two weeks ago, talking him up on his AFL Vlog.But its still pretty stock standard
They don't rate Travaglia and Langford as much as others do. Maybe can add the inside Campo to that as well. I'd not heard of Tauru so good to see they rate a name like that
The top 10 of Twomey's first phantom form guide every year (i.e. July) usually has the vast majority of players who end up going top 10, so I reckon he goes pretty well.I like seeing against the norm of what Twomey and others suggest
At the end of the day anyone can do that. All they do is listen, look at stats, see who played 18s last year and come to a very similar list.
I want to see the ones that rate the Phoenix Gothards above the norm ect
Recruiters have fairly different spots for players to Twomey
But its still pretty stock standard
They dont rate Travaglia and Langford as much as others do. Maybe can add the inside Campo to that aswell. Id not heard of Tauru so good to see they rate a name like that
July | |
1 | Levi Ashcroft |
2 | Josh Smillie |
3 | Finn O'Sullivan |
4 | Harvey Langford |
5 | Murphy Reid |
6 | Jagga Smith |
7 | Luke Trainor |
8 | Sam Lalor |
9 | Sid Draper |
10 | Bo Allan |
11 | Leonardo Lombard |
12 | Taj Hotton |
13 | Tobie Travaglia |
14 | Harry Armstrong |
15 | Isaac Kako |
16 | Xavier Lindsay |
17 | Joe Berry |
18 | Jack Whitlock |
19 | Cooper Hynes |
20 | Tom Gross |
21 | Samuel Marshall |
22 | Christian Moraes |
23 | Alex Dodson |
24 | Alix Tauru |
25 | Harrison Oliver |
26 | Matt Whitlock |
27 | Jobe Shanahan |
28 | Jonty Faull |
29 | Thomas Sims |
30 | Noah Mraz |
Yeh his info is spot on for the top 10The top 10 of Twomey's first phantom form guide every year (i.e. July) usually has the vast majority of players who end up going top 10, so I reckon he goes pretty well.
RMC are the main "others", after Twomey.
Im not sure Twomey pays enough attention to watching players to have that impact their ranking. He does rely on others. At the end of the day the top 10-15 is pretty easy to determine for anyoneA lot of people are watching the U18 footy these days, not just the National Championships. There's a lot of posters here who are at CTL games every week. Others at SANFL and WAFL colts, etc.
For years, the main criticism of Twomey is that he gets a lot of his information that influence his ranking from recruiters.
Ahh ok, well cant even give them credit for that now either ha. Ignore that oneTwomey put Tauru on the map two weeks ago, talking him up on his AFL Vlog.
And yet Twomey has them even lower! Which I’m also surprised by.Draper and Lombard being that far down is mind melting.
Jeez whiz, Murphy Reid top 5, Lombard at 11And yet Twomey has them even lower! Which I’m also surprised by.
Has Langford much higher though - 20 spots higher! More where he should be imo
Twomey has gone with similar. Maybe that’s just how a lot of clubs view the Ben campo.I’m with you, some of the picks here are way off imo. No Ben Campo in top 30? Usually RMC so spot on, but they drank six stubbies watching the last VicM Vs VicC game and ranked them on that.
Ben Campo's kicking is a pretty big flaw, fix that and he'd fly up the rankings.Twomey has gone with similar. Maybe that’s just how a lot of clubs view the Ben campo.
The top 10-12 are very even though, each club will have different guys they like and it’ll be pick your poison.
Draper and Lombard being that far down is mind melting.
July - Espn | |
1 | Sid Draper |
2 | Jagga Smith |
3 | Leonardo Lombard |
4 | Finn O'Sullivan |
5 | Josh Smillie |
6 | Sam Lalor |
7 | Levi Ashcroft |
8 | Tobie Travaglia |
9 | Luke Trainor |
10 | Harvey Langford |
11 | Xavier Lindsay |
12 | Joe Berry |
13 | Taj Hotton |
14 | Isaac Kako |
15 | Bo Allan |
16 | Murphy Reid |
17 | Alex Dodson |
18 | Jobe Shanahan |
19 | Christian Moraes |
20 | Harry Armstrong |
21 | Ben Camporeale |
22 | Kayle Gerreyn |
23 | Jack Whitlock |
24 | Samuel Marshall |
25 | Jonty Faull |
26 | Tom Gross |
27 | Harry O'Farrell |
28 | Matt Whitlock |
29 | Cooper Hynes |
30 | Hamish Davis |
Hopoate could lend a hand and run a program developing the concept of finger awareness.First AFL player to be taken off for finger awareness?