List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

[Ticky009]

 

[Bloods86]

Only just realised Bowman was 30 for Twomey. Obviously clubs have mentioned him, but really hope it's not us with one of our firsts.

Before today, wouldn't have thought he'd be Top 50. Would take Davis, Murphy, McKenzie, Sulzberger, Day-Wicks etc before Bowman.

 

[RUNVS]

None of these names are surprising (generally rated in the 40s) but probably Will Hayes is the biggest bolter- he's your quintessential skinny outside flanker.

Stop. Longmire can only get so erect.

 

[Slingshot Footy]

It looks like the key talls will really shape the second half of the first round.

I hope we take a tall with our first pick and hopefully it's not our least favourite left standing. I'd be very curious to know what order the Swans would rank Shanahan, Armstrong, the Whitlock twins, Faull and Trainor and whether we'd still take Matt Ling over the lot of them!

If we trade up to take one we'll know exactly how we and the other clubs perceive this year's key forward stock.

Worst outcome is another team trades up to poach one, that or the bloody Bulldogs take another tall just to piss everyone off!

Twomey has us taking Jonty Faull and although his contested marking worries me slightly I like that he came back strong after missing the first of the year and seems to have the inner drive and desire to improve and compete.

I'm bloody nervous and excited at the same time because I feel like this is a really important draft to nail in order to shape our forward line for the foreseeable future.

We need a tall and we need a small and they need to be bloody great!

Get the job done Kinnear.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

It looks like the key talls will really shape the second half of the first round.

I hope we take a tall with our first pick and hopefully it's not our least favourite left standing. I'd be very curious to know what order the Swans would rank Shanahan, Armstrong, the Whitlock twins, Faull and Trainor themselves and whether we'd still take Matt Ling over the lot of them!

If we trade up to take one we'll know exactly how we and the other clubs perceive this year's key forward stock.

Worst outcome is another team trades up to poach one from us, that or the bloody Bulldogs take another tall just to piss everyone off!

Twomey has us taking Jonty Faull and although his contested marking worries me slightly I like that he came back strong after missing the first of the year and seems to have the inner drive and desire to improve and compete.

I'm bloody nervous and excited at the same time because I feel like this is a really important draft to nail in order to shape our forward line for the foreseeable future.

We need a tall and we need a small and they need to be bloody great!

Get the job done Kinnear.

We are dead keen on Armstrong but there no hope on earth us having the capital to trade for him unfortunately that sort of tells you our ranking not a surprise he’s been the no1 key forward all year

 

[bedford]

We are dead keen on Armstrong but there no hope on earth us having the capital to trade for him unfortunately that sort of tells you our ranking not a surprise he’s been the no1 key forward all year

I would be happy

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I would be happy

With Armstrong? Yeah would love him too no chance as teams aren’t trading down really would cost both our firsts even then doubt it is in the ballpark.

Love the ones Cal gave us.

 

[Kiama Chris]

With Armstrong? Yeah would love him too no chance as teams aren’t trading down really would cost both our firsts even then doubt it is in the ballpark.

Love the ones Cal gave us.

I'd be happy with either of the twins but don't have much of an opinion beyond them for the talls. Not to say someone else might not be marginally better but I'd be satisfied.
Hannaford or Dattoli with our other first round pick. Each has their pluses and not too much in the minus column. Again, either for a tick.
I hope Cochran slides enough to take as a fifth or preferably rookie and we can get a medium and a mid with the other two picks. There seem to be choices available who could make the grade in time, which is what we need, rather than a silver bullet.
I can't see any value in trading up as it looks unlikely to get us to a significantly better player.
F1? Tricky question. Could it get us Hannaford AND Dattoli? That would be an interesting proposition worth considering. What do you think caesar88 ?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I'd be happy with either of the twins but don't have much of an opinion beyond them for the talls. Not to say someone else might not be marginally better but I'd be satisfied.
Hannaford or Dattoli with our other first round pick. Each has their pluses and not too much in the minus column. Again, either for a tick.
I hope Cochran slides enough to take as a fifth or preferably rookie and we can get a medium and a mid with the other two picks. There seem to be choices available who could make the grade in time, which is what we need, rather than a silver bullet.
I can't see any value in trading up as it looks unlikely to get us to a significantly better player.
F1? Tricky question. Could it get us Hannaford AND Dattoli? That would be an interesting proposition worth considering. What do you think caesar88 ?

I’ve been consistent saying I’d trade our f1 for one of Richmond’s later picks could we get 23 with that? Maybe we look at a medium with that extra pick in the 20’s. However everyone on here just wants to keep our 1 next year. I’d trade it back ourselves to be top 4, we aren’t needed it anyway