Opinion 2024 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[Catastrophe!]

Last decision, and I reckon I'll be close to set -

M. Crouch and R. Marshall
T. Green and Gawn
Touk and Gawn +130K

1st option changes my byes dramatically. Other two options seem superior, but again, byes.

 

[Tex Danger]

Salem Amon Xerri
V
Coffield Viney Gawn

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Salem Amon Xerri
V
Coffield Viney Gawn

.

 

[DukeX]

Hopefully final on field tinkering.
Left vs Right:

I feel like Left presents a bit more value but keeps Roberts' scores on the bench, but Right gives a reliable C option (which I am lacking) and keeper in Dawson and a slightly more reliable scorer in Fyfe... Thoughts?

*edit: Wilson v Fyfe for Forward line, not mid

 

[happy_eagle]

Trying to figure out a replacement for Coleman (inj) and Fyfe (not confident).

Budarick + Amon
or
Z.Williams + Newcombe

(via reshuffle of extra forward rookie to open up midfield spot)

Then there are still a few 50/50s to consider like Sheezel vs Whitfield and Jackson vs Heeney (currently the former on both).

 

[Shaunn]

Trying to figure out a replacement for Coleman (inj) and Fyfe (not confident).

Budarick + Amon
or
Z.Williams + Newcombe

(via reshuffle of extra forward rookie to open up midfield spot)

Then there are still a few 50/50s to consider like Sheezel vs Whitfield and Jackson vs Heeney (currently the former on both).

Williams/Newcombe for me, other is riskier.

 

[samFFC]

Salem Amon Xerri
V
Coffield Viney Gawn

1

Hopefully final on field tinkering.
Left vs Right:
View attachment 1923360
I feel like Left presents a bit more value but keeps Roberts' scores on the bench, but Right gives a reliable C option (which I am lacking) and keeper in Dawson and a slightly more reliable scorer in Fyfe... Thoughts?
View attachment 1923361
*edit: Wilson v Fyfe for Forward line, not mid

Left

Trying to figure out a replacement for Coleman (inj) and Fyfe (not confident).

Budarick + Amon
or
Z.Williams + Newcombe

(via reshuffle of extra forward rookie to open up midfield spot)

Then there are still a few 50/50s to consider like Sheezel vs Whitfield and Jackson vs Heeney (currently the former on both).

Latter

 

[Wels Eicke]

I think I'm down to this.

1. English, Liberatore, Budarick (Daicos in mids)

2. English, Crouch M4, Wines M5, Daicos in def in place if Budarick.

3. Grundy, Liberatore, Wanganeen-Milera (Daicos in mids)

I like the English options as he will be a bit more unique, and one less Sydney bye player to worry about. But I think option 3 scores more points most weeks, though only just. Any thoughts?

 

[tigs2010]

I think I'm down to this.

1. English, Liberatore, Budarick (Daicos in mids)

2. English, Crouch M4, Wines M5, Daicos in def in place if Budarick.

3. Grundy, Liberatore, Wanganeen-Milera (Daicos in mids)

I like the English options as he will be a bit more unique, and one less Sydney bye player to worry about. But I think option 3 scores more points most weeks, though only just. Any thoughts?

I think 3 just due to Grundy already has the hot start built in and guaranteed price rise. Who is your other ruck?

 

[Wels Eicke]

I think 3 just due to Grundy already has the hot start built in and guaranteed price rise. Who is your other ruck?

Gawn. Yeah, Grundy a gift no doubt. I put English in my post, could be Marshall also. Too much time spent worrying about byes probably, I should just go the obvious picks and worry about byes when they come.

But I'd be lost if I wasn't worrying about some aspect of my team!

 

[tigs2010]

Gawn. Yeah, Grundy a gift no doubt. I put English in my post, could be Marshall also. Too much time spent worrying about byes probably, I should just go the obvious picks and worry about byes when they come.

But I'd be lost if I wasn't worrying about some aspect of my team!

Marshall has a softer draw. Think English has Gawndy early. I tried Marshall after Grundy went poorly in PS but can't pass up the value there and the high ownership.

 

[cutterman]

Bonner, Z Williams, Coffield +$93k in bank
OR
Short, Howes, Sharp +$37k in bank

Talking onfield here, Howes will be bench in option 1. It’s mainly a decision between Bonner and Sharp, will the extra c.$200k for Bonner be worth it. Or will Sharp be strong enough to utilise the funds elsewhere

 

[bettingonbetts]

Bonner, Z Williams, Coffield +$93k in bank
OR
Short, Howes, Sharp +$37k in bank

Talking onfield here, Howes will be bench in option 1. It’s mainly a decision between Bonner and Sharp, will the extra c.$200k for Bonner be worth it. Or will Sharp be strong enough to utilise the funds elsewhere

First option easy

 

[bettingonbetts]

Grundy + Steele
Or
Xerri + Green?

 

[Tex Danger]

Grundy + Steele
Or
Xerri + Green?

Grundy + Steele

 

[bettingonbetts]

Grundy + Steele

That’s where I was leaning. Thanks mate

 

[tigs2010]

Yeo & Newcombe v Budarick & Rozee

Coffield & 200k v Reid & Windsor/Sharp

 

[tigs2010]

1: Isaac Heeney + Ollie Wines + Jhye Clark (Bench)
2: Luke Jackson + Max Holmes + Aaron Cadman (Bench)

1 provided Clark plays.

Clark will make money way faster than Cadman. Heeney already has a large score built in. Wines has a great draw to start, has the best bye and is an easy upgrade on his bye to a Green or Gulden from memory who have the bye the week before.

 

[Lonhro21]

Hey all.
Budarick + RoMa or
Naicos + Xerri ?
Cherrs

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Yeo & Newcombe v Budarick & Rozee

Coffield & 200k v Reid & Windsor/Sharp

Reid & Simpson

 

[Tasfut]

Buderick, Reid (d6), Gawn
Vs
Salem, Coffield (d6), Xerri

Thanks

 

[tigs2010]

Reid & Simpson

Simpson actually going to play of just be a sub?

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Hey all.
Budarick + RoMa or
Naicos + Xerri ?
Cherrs

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Simpson actually going to play of just be a sub?

Call someone who cares!

 

[tigs2010]

Call someone who cares!

Ghost shipping?