List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets

[Heave Ho Bro]

Yeah, it sucks when you try to have a proper discussion about the club and it all just boils down to "We're still so young" "We have a lot to be happy about!!"

I'm all for positivity but there has to be some balance. Delusional optimism pisses me off.

 

[DragoDelph]

Even with Cerra out, how can Carlton afford Trac..?!?! It's pretty preposterous

As said before, Martin, Williams, McGovern either gone or on reduced contracts moving forward.

Plus I'm sure Visy has some food service related subsidiary

 

[Lach72]

Who is taking Cerra on with his dodgy hammies? It’s not like he’s set the world on fire either

 

[Quazar2]

As said before, Martin, Williams, McGovern either gone or on reduced contracts moving forward.

Plus I'm sure Visy has some food service related subsidiary

Maybe so, but even now (before any said trade/s) their list must have the most bloated, clandestine income. It's pretty gross

 

[MadMundy]

I'm all for positivity but there has to be some balance. Delusional optimism pisses me off.

I've been told I'm not a real fan on there for criticising the club, apparently you don't talk down about your club and support them no matter what.

 

[guidodp15]

Yeah, it sucks when you try to have a proper discussion about the club and it all just boils down to "We're still so young" "We have a lot to be happy about!!"

they are all casual fans who look at stats, any thing you say that is critical and they can't respond to you get downvoted with no discussion its ****ed.

 

[Joao]

There's been murmurs around Butters leaving at the end of his contract.

Maybe he's decided to go early, and they've convinced Houston to stay with a spot in the middle?

(plus his preferred destination up sugar creek without so much as a paddle pop)

Would be brave to let him go now. Ramsey is a jet.

Who is taking Cerra on with his dodgy hammies? It’s not like he’s set the world on fire either

The hammies are a big problem, but he was playing really well last year before they set in.

 

[DragoDelph]

Do we need an "AITA for criticising the club?" thread?

 

[MadMundy]

they are all casual fans who look at stats, any thing you say that is critical and they can't respond to you get downvoted with no discussion its ****ed.

"Go support another club then" is the usual response.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Who is taking Cerra on with his dodgy hammies? It’s not like he’s set the world on fire either

Melbourne seem determined not to full rebuild for whatever reason. If not jump, they'd be pretty happy to take him and a Carlton 1st for Petracca all things considered I'd think

 

[DragoDelph]

"Go support another club then" is the usual response.

flipping hell. I'm as bullish as anyone on our future.

But the club has a shit ton to do to get there.

Criticism isn't hate. We criticise because we want to see success

 

[DragoDelph]

Melbourne seem determined not to full rebuild for whatever reason. If not jump, they'd be pretty happy to take him and a Carlton 1st for Petracca all things considered I'd think

Yep, hedge the bets.

 

[theGav56]

There is no way if I am Fyfe or Walters, would I be looking to retire early. Especially Fyfe, who has a decent chance of being best 22 for 10 or so games next year.

They both would love a flag to finish their career.

Being best 22 for 10 or so games is a curly way of saying your playing in the WAFL isn't it?

 

[Paracleet]

Is reddit our prominent other board? Dockerland isn't really a thing anymore is it?

Seems activish?:

 

[Dayts]

Blues & Pies most likely.

Mackay off the table, so Cerra out makes sense.

DeGoey & Quaynor have been raised to generate capital by Pies, but don't think that makes sense, would send them backwards.

I’m so bricked up for a couple of dangerous smalls running around that if the Kozzie thing fell over I’d consider trading pick 10 for Hill & another 2nd.

10 is overs for Bobby but if you look at it like Shultz for Hill, Simpson & another 2nd ain’t to bad.

 

[malpaso]

I think we need to get the Pickett deal done first and quickly before any Petracca deal is done.

 

[DragoDelph]

I’m so bricked up for a couple of dangerous smalls running around that if the Kozzie thing fell over I’d consider trading pick 10 for Hill & another 2nd.

10 is overs for Bobby but if you look at it like Shultz for Hill, Simpson & another 2nd ain’t to bad.

Yeah, that would make sense from both sides.

Pies could then keep Richards to fill that role.

But I like Koz more.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Seems activish?:

View attachment 2096410

Interesting, it is activish. Thought it died (though I've never used it). Possibly more active than reddit even.

 

[Joao]

Cornes said on SEN yesterday that he knows that Tom Morris is confident that West Coast are Kossie's preference.

This is going to be interesting in the Daniels vs Morris contest.

 

[Ge3ks]

Houston claims he's not going anywhere:

'I am not leaving': Power star shuts down trade rumours

Star defender Dan Houston says he's rejecting offers from rival clubs and is staying at Port Adelaide

www.afl.com.au

 

[Eski3]

When do we have to make our list decisions by ? ie i wouldnt want to re sign emmet and then we get both of these 2.

Not until after trade period. I suspect Emmett won't know if he'll be offered a contract for next year until after trade period is done. I wouldn't be surprised if the only other player we sign up between now and trade period is NOD

 

[DragoDelph]

Cornes said on SEN yesterday that he knows that Tom Morris is confident that West Coast are MELBOURNES preference.

This is going to be interesting in the Daniels vs Morris contest.

Fixed.

Also, he probably is just salty he chose WA (Freo) over Port.

 

[Alfonz]

Blues & Pies most likely.

Mackay off the table, so Cerra out makes sense.

DeGoey & Quaynor have been raised to generate capital by Pies, but don't think that makes sense, would send them backwards.

It has to be Carlton for Petracca. The Blues will find a way to pay him. Brown paper bags aside, they can take the players mentioned (some of whom are on stupid money ... Williams on 800-900k for example) and replace them with Petracca and minimum/reduced wages.

Petracca has Italian heritage. Not sure that is even a consideration for his brand, but nonetheless Carlton is the club for Italians.

Collingwood are heading for the same situation as Melbourne with a fall from grace after they jagged a flag. Would be a much higher risk move by Petracca to go there. Chance of success at Carlton is much higher.

 

[mike91]

"Go support another club then" is the usual response.

Cringe. Though one of our own nuffies on this board accused me of being a West Coast fan because I vented how bad it was that we missed finals. Nuffies everywhere. This board in general is alright compared to other places, like Reddit

 

[DragoDelph]

It has to be Carlton for Petracca. The Blues will find a way to pay him. Brown paper bags aside, they can take the players mentioned (some of whom are on stupid money ... Williams on 800-900k for example) and replace them with Petracca and minimum/reduced wages.

Petracca has Italian heritage. Not sure that is even a consideration for his brand, but nonetheless Carlton is the club for Italians.

Collingwood are heading for the same situation as Melbourne with a fall from grace after they jagged a flag. Would be a much higher risk move by Petracca to go there. Chance of success at Carlton is much higher.

Yeah, Carlton seem to be firming. It's just how they get it done.