List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

[stax on the mull]

I wonder if there will be a Joe Brierty radio snippet somewhere

I just posted it in the media thread. (I had posted the wrong interview link, but it's fixed now)

 

[apuchar]

So according to a handful of people Fyfe is why we lost yesterday but Frederick with his weak efforts, Johnson with hardly any touches, Reidy getting monstered by Sweet, yes Sweet, Walker's man kicking 3 on him and our players missing 4 or 5 easy ones in the second quarter had nothing to do with it.

Clearly if Fyfe wants to play on he will be back in 2025.

I don't think we are blaming him alone although his lack of defensive run and the 50 metre penalty was very costly. Good mark and goal though. It is a for and against ledger with Fyfe now and it feels like it is starting to fall the way of against.But we may be losing more experience this year by the sounds of it so I doubt we would want to add to it.. Walker gave away a silly free kick early and then did a pretty good job on Rioli until the last quarter, I think. But our midfield did fall away. Generally, I thought our backline was pretty good. Not many are defending Johnson and I certainly don't defend the coaches selection of him if he was injured. They are acting like he is Dangerfield or something. It has gone beyond a joke.

 

[Taylor]

Really. ha ha

At their best and fairest in front of everyone, he gave that wolf of wall street "I'm not leaving" speech. Then left.

 

[apuchar]

At their best and fairest in front of everyone, he gave that wolf of wall street "I'm not leaving" speech. Then left.

I think Tarrent did the same thing during the best and fairest.

 

[Sherriff Incorporated]

McKay is on the table.

Correct.

Not sure how Carlton get both petracca and Houston deals done though.

While its only at the rumour stage its believed Harry McKay will be part of the deal with another Carlton player for Petracca. Maybe someone like Durdin. Perhaps Carltons first this year and next for Houston with a late pick coming back to help Carlton math bids for Camporeale bro's.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

 

[Taylor]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

Warner (10 years), Bolton (8 years), Picket (10 years, 2 suspened), Petracca (five years)

 

[Lach72]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

Warner
Bolton
Petracca
Pickett

 

[Cobbler]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

Ewww to most of the actual deals, but:

Bolton
Warner
Pickett
Petracca

 

[s_wd6]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

1. Pickett
2. Warner
3. Bolton
4. Petracca

Feel like Pickett is the biggest missing piece from the team at the moment. Just a genuine small forward who kicks goals. Warner would add a lot, but a lot pricier and not in as big a glaring holefor us. Bolton flaky, but good when he's on. Kicks goals. Petracca old and injured.

 

[millsy]

Warner (10 years), Bolton (8 years), Picket (10 years, 2 suspened), Petracca (five years)

Agree with this. Although pickett feels expensive in comparison to the other options, so I'd almost bump Petracca if his medical is fine.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Ewww to most of the actual deals, but:

Bolton
Warner
Pickett
Petracca

Talking contracted stars, clubs arent letting them go for less than ew

 

[JammoMonty]

Rank in order of preference, you can have ONE of these players for the prices specified.

• Bolton: 1m a season, 9 and 17
• Warner: 1.2m a season, 9, 10, 27
• Pickett: 800k, 9 and 10
• Petracca: 1m, 9 and 10

Warner
Pickett
Petracca
Bolton

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Agree with this. Although pickett feels expensive in comparison to the other options, so I'd almost bump Petracca if his medical is fine.

I made Pickett the most expensive trade wise because he's the one with the absolute least reason to let go if you're Melbourne

 

[s_wd6]

Surprised Pickett is so low tbh. Kicked basically 40 goals a season for his past four seasons and is only 23.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I tried to make Warner almost unpalatable and you still all have him near 1 or 2 haha

 

[Taylor]

Surprised Pickett is so low tbh. Kicked basically 40 goals a season for his past four seasons and is only 23.

I think both Warner and Bolton can kick forty goals playing a midfield rotation more than Pickett will, but all four are effectively burst mid options that play forward.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Surprised Pickett is so low tbh. Kicked basically 40 goals a season for his past four seasons and is only 23.

At a good contract, he'd be my number 1 as well, overpaying in picks be damned

 

[millsy]

I made Pickett the most expensive trade wise because he's the one with the absolute least reason to let go if you're Melbourne

Yeah makes sense why you would price him like that, just makes him less attractive paying 9 & 10 comparatively for mine.

 

[s_wd6]

When are exit interviews? Can our ITKs drop all the players that want out now so that I can mentally prepare myself thanks.

 

[Taylor]

When are exit interviews? Can our ITKs drop all the players that want out now so that I can mentally prepare myself thanks.

Murphy is going back east.

But he's too old to play.

 

[apuchar]

Murphy is going back east.

But he's too old to play.

I thought you meant the other Murphy. I nearly had a seizure

 

[s_wd6]

Murphy is going back east.

This'll be true soon enough too though

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I wonder if we get a formal team from Baker this week

 

[The Feeder Club]

Bolton option is the best from that list for mine

There's something immensely dick swinging about the potential of giving Richmond pick 9 as part of a deal for Bolton but keeping pick 10 ourselves. With Walls in the house, it has all the potential of Richard Tambling

Richard Tambling

Age

38

Ht

180cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

14.9

4star

K

8.4

3star

HB

6.5

4star

M

4.6

4star

T

2.9

4star

No current season stats available

D

8.4

3star

K

5.6

3star

HB

2.8

3star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.8

4star

vs Buddy Franklin episode two.