List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

[Ge3ks]

NoD

 

[bruzaar62]

Heard this news last night but wasn’t supposed to be announced until next week(hush hush).
Heard Raz had a good exit meeting and has been assured a bigger role next year!
Fyfe and Walters to have reduced roles I believe.
Couple clubs sniffing around Knobel but nothing significant-but who knows?

Is that better,Snuff and Apuchar?…..

 

[Wizard]

Literally never seen anything like it. Bizarre

He wants to go to WCE, he’s just waiting to make sure he likes the coach and vice versa.

We’re his back up option. He can **** off.

 

[DragoDelph]

He wants to go to WCE, he’s just waiting to make sure he likes the coach and vice versa.

We’re his back up option. He can **** off.

I think we’re each others backup tbh.

 

[nurries]

Yep if he wanted to come to us, he would of said so. He is waiting to see who the coach is

 

[benfica]

lol

 

[Van_Dyke]

The only reason I endorse us still being somewhat of a baker option is to maximise the odds that they need to use/split significant capital to trade for him. splitting pick 3 to get him and say 10 or so would be objectively dumb in my book, would be fantastic

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Yeah echo that if Baker doesn't choose us (or I would hope costs too much) it's not a big loss, keep the draft capital.

We've got more than 1-2 holes in the list going forward and short of getting everyone listed in the poll we still need draft picks.

WCE prolonging the pain would be a bit lol but might make sense if they think it's their only option to keep Reid.

 

[Superkoops]

On a rough stat comparison, you would have to say Campbell Chesser is lucky he was a first round draft pick and still has a year on his contract.

Zane Trew and Campbell Chesser AFL Stats Comparison

Zane Trew and Campbell Chesser AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

Doesn’t really show a lot except they are both crapola. Chesser has been saved by exactly the points you raise - contract for 2025 and being a first round draft pick.

I know from a contact at WC that they are extremely disappointed with the lack of progress from Chesser and he will be lucky to survive end of next year if things don’t improve significantly.

 

[Docker82]

View attachment 2114456lol

He’s cooked.

Would have to play forward for us tbh and let’s be honest he’s too slow these days so it’d be about body strength in marking contest only. His forward pressure would be close to zero too.

No thanks.

 

[Taylor]

Yeah echo that if Baker doesn't choose us (or I would hope costs too much) it's not a big loss, keep the draft capital.

We've got more than 1-2 holes in the list going forward and short of getting everyone listed in the poll we still need draft picks.

WCE prolonging the pain would be a bit lol but might make sense if they think it's their only option to keep Reid.

If Baker picks WC it might be good for us, if Richmond really, really want that pick #3 then we can ransom our picks knowing they need them to give to WC for that #3.

We might be able to leverage it to get more back from then or less spent to begin with.

 

[ilikepotatoes]

It's scarily looking like we might not trade anyone of note out this offseason.

Can't shake the feeling someone will request out at some point though.

 

[s_wd6]

It's scarily looking like we might not trade anyone of note out this offseason.

Can't shake the feeling someone will request out at some point though.

Now why did u have to say it…

 

[oldgoat]

North Melbourne is crutching at straws.

So they're buying a camel?

 

[Dockeroo]

Great to see NOD signed on. Reading the apparent quote from him last week he seemed 99% gone, it was so similar to Liam Henry last year.

I’m in the bring baker in camp. I think he’s an excellent addition to fix some of our weaknesses.

Bolton too, seems a no brainer.
The only slight concern with these guys is their motivation levels. It is a genuine risk, even if it’s small, it would be foolish not to acknowledge go_the_dockers point that some players just lose that hunger and desperation that made them great, when they win a lot early in their careers. Hopefully that does not happen here.

However on balance you have to take that chance, especially when a player of Bolton level wants in.

 

[oldgoat]

Banfield was our best forward by score involvements and goals scored.

But even with those two you've chosen, there's 60 more score involvements with Baker and Bolton. Let's say it's 180 points across the 23 games, so 8 points a game.

We then beat the Blues (10 points with that extra kick from a double goal), Power (3 points), Pies, Bombers

That puts us at 2nd on the ladder.

That's plenty of needle moving

I like this version of phantasy footy...
It's like painting by numbers!
Flagmantle25!

 

[Docker82]

Great to see NOD signed on. Reading the apparent quote from him last week he seemed 99% gone, it was so similar to Liam Henry last year.

I’m in the bring baker in camp. I think he’s an excellent addition to fix some of our weaknesses.

Bolton too, seems a no brainer.
The only slight concern with these guys is their motivation levels. It is a genuine risk, even if it’s small, it would be foolish not to acknowledge go_the_dockers point that some players just lose that hunger and desperation that made them great, when they win a lot early in their careers. Hopefully that does not happen here.

However on balance you have to take that chance, especially when a player of Bolton level wants in.

If NOD, Voss and Reidy all re-sign as expected it’s hard to see how we fit both Bolton and Baker on the list and have a decent presence in the draft tbh. Without trading out players anyway.

If our third best draft selection is kind of late I think that’s a good time to stop but I don’t think I’d be taking any less than three selections in any draft.

We can probably view one of the Irish guys as a free selection so we’d still be bringing four in - the turnover will be bigger next year with Fyfe and Walters renting imo.

 

[oldgoat]

If Jye Amiss improves his involvements the same rate as he did this year but recaptures his accuracy at goal from 2023 then...

... he kicks 54 goals in 2025. 18 extra goals on this season.

Game, set, match!

 

[Midnite65]

If NOD, Voss and Reidy all re-sign as expected it’s hard to see how we fit both Bolton and Baker on the list and have a decent presence in the draft tbh. Without trading out players anyway.

If our third best draft selection is kind of late I think that’s a good time to stop but I don’t think I’d be taking any less than three selections in any draft.

We can probably view one of the Irish guys as a free selection so we’d still be bringing four in - the turnover will be bigger next year with Fyfe and Walters renting imo.

We're not aiming to have a decent presence in the draft.

 

[fnerd]

Just on WC and Reid , how’s that Adam Simpson interview where he stated A grade players were ringing WC up to say they want to come play with Harley…. and then it dried up after few losses (lol)

Not sure exactly how accurate simmos statement is but imagine a player wanting to change clubs just so they could play at WC as to be immersed in Harley mania?!

Seems crazy but then I remembered we had a player request a trade for fashion reasons so maybe this the new norm

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

If NOD, Voss and Reidy all re-sign as expected it’s hard to see how we fit both Bolton and Baker on the list and have a decent presence in the draft tbh. Without trading out players anyway.

If our third best draft selection is kind of late I think that’s a good time to stop but I don’t think I’d be taking any less than three selections in any draft.

We can probably view one of the Irish guys as a free selection so we’d still be bringing four in - the turnover will be bigger next year with Fyfe and Walters renting imo.

I'm convinced they are desperately trying to find a place to offload Brodie. Seems insane to carry his list spot with where they seem in the pecking order

 

[Purple Suit]

He’s cooked.

Would have to play forward for us tbh and let’s be honest he’s too slow these days so it’d be about body strength in marking contest only. His forward pressure would be close to zero too.

No thanks.

It doesn’t matter anyway, Dusty has zero interest in rocking into a new club full of strangers. Dimma will let him do what ever he wants in terms of no media and it’s all for marketing purposes for GC as he’s cooked.

 

[Dockeroo]

If NOD, Voss and Reidy all re-sign as expected it’s hard to see how we fit both Bolton and Baker on the list and have a decent presence in the draft tbh. Without trading out players anyway.

If our third best draft selection is kind of late I think that’s a good time to stop but I don’t think I’d be taking any less than three selections in any draft.

We can probably view one of the Irish guys as a free selection so we’d still be bringing four in - the turnover will be bigger next year with Fyfe and Walters renting imo.

Oh listen I’m 100% in agreement with you here.
We NEED to take 4 national draft picks this year.
Emmett and Stanley should both be cut.
Brodie just has be traded out. If Carlton are telling all those guys to look around, surely, surely we are saying the same to Brodie?

A deep draft like this you have to take advantage of. Even if it’s picks in the 40s or 50s.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

What are we at then.

Excluding Corbett and Williams

Tabs, Hughes and Kuek are three spots. Assume one of the rucks goes out and then both Stanley and Emmett? Could bring in 3 and draft 3. Would still help to move Brodie if we could.

 

[Dockeroo]

What are we at then.

Excluding Corbett and Williams

Tabs, Hughes and Kuek are three spots. Assume one of the rucks goes out and then both Stanley and Emmett? Could bring in 3 and draft 3. Would still help to move Brodie if we could.

Didnt we have a spare list spot not used in the MSD? Is that counted?