List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

[JammoMonty]

Can anyone tell me who finished 1 & 2 in the BnF last night??

 

[freoforever94]

Can anyone tell me who finished 1 & 2 in the BnF last night??

Caleb serong first place
Andy brayshaw second place
Hayden young third place

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Can anyone tell me who finished 1 & 2 in the BnF last night??

Batman and Robin (Caleb and Andy)

 

[Taylor]

What's that all about - for the Facebook averse?

Suggesting that Fremantle trades either #9 or #10 to North for their future first and then North trades that pick to Port with something else for Houston.

Freo trade the other pick and the other first to Richmond for Bolton.

Then next year we have North's first, Freo's first and pick up Warner then. Or, we just trade that now for him too.

 

[DragoDelph]

Would love for this all to be no-nonsense.

Freo, Sydney, Rich rock up day 1, sign some papers, walk out.

All while the media are focused on interviewing the other list managers.

 

[fnerd]

There is a reason the best taggers the game has seen recently; Cameron Ling, Ryan Crowley etc are all huge 190cm ish guys

Ras

 

[freo_leo29]

This finals series is great for his development and confidence

I was pretty vocal last year to drop him to peel at the back end as he was like 1 game off qualifying for finals, instead we played him as sub

Baffling decision, he really could've used a finals series last year

 

[arsesmart]

Thanks for pointing it out.

We often consider him an underrated player.

I would 100% rather keep him vs Bolton for our rebuild.

You may have a bigger sample size than me, but my impression from watching Baker closely whenever I watched Richmond was that this year was a fair drop off in edge and quality from last year.

I think there a large number of AFL players who can produce stretches at A grade level. What separates them is how frequently and how long.

 

[freo_leo29]

The three-club trade that could unlock Houston's move to Victoria - https://www.afl.com.au/news/1223163

Such a nonsense article, can anyone actually see us not getting Shai

 

[apuchar]

If the new coach wants Baker and Bolton and both are willing and WC is prepared to split pick 3

 

[Docker82]

Such a nonsense article, can anyone actually see us not getting Shai

I don't understand. Are they saying North would trade their future first for Pick 9 or 10. Doubt they'd be stupid enough to trade it for both tbh. They're still sh**e enough that they could be trading out pick 1 - I'd expect pick 3 at best because Richmond and West Coast will be awful again but pick 1 isn't impossible with an injury run from hell.

 

[Taylor]

I don't understand. Are they saying North would trade their future first for Pick 9 or 10. Doubt they'd be stupid enough to trade it for both tbh. They're still sh**e enough that they could be trading out pick 1 - I'd expect pick 3 at best because Richmond and West Coast will be awful again but pick 1 isn't impossible with an injury run from hell.

Scuttlebutt was that North wanted to trade their future first for Houston but Port said no, they want a pick this season.

So it costs North the same no matter which way.

 

[DOCKERZ]

I don't understand. Are they saying North would trade their future first for Pick 9 or 10. Doubt they'd be stupid enough to trade it for both tbh. They're still sh**e enough that they could be trading out pick 1 - I'd expect pick 3 at best because Richmond and West Coast will be awful again but pick 1 isn't impossible with an injury run from hell.

When they get Houston and ole rubber t!ts on board, they will be aiming high!
And looking at next years draft they may think Houston is better than what is coming through at their projected pick.

 

[DragoDelph]

Surely we’d ask for a bit more to trade out of this draft though.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Scuttlebutt was that North wanted to trade their future first for Houston but Port said no, they want a pick this season.

So it costs North the same no matter which way.

Where does North finish next year.

You would still have them bottom 5 surely.

Gee is must be hard for the recruiters to push picks into next year, when you no it is a good draft crop plus you want the instant gratification.

Surely we’d ask for a bit more to trade out of this draft though.

My thoughts exactly
10 for F1 and pick 20, and it is deal

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Would love for this all to be no-nonsense.

Freo, Sydney, Rich rock up day 1, sign some papers, walk out.

All while the media are focused on interviewing the other list managers.

I reckon Shai will be agreed on early doors but actually get done at the death for 'suspense' as nobody will give a shit about other trades like Darling to North and Martin to Geelong enough for those to be held over

 

[DragoDelph]

I reckon Shai will be agreed on early doors but actually get done at the death for 'suspense' as nobody will give a shit about other trades like Darling to North and Martin to Geelong enough for those to be held over

Not when there’s Houston that will involve a big vic club.

 

[Piggy Smalls]

I don't understand. Are they saying North would trade their future first for Pick 9 or 10. Doubt they'd be stupid enough to trade it for both tbh. They're still sh**e enough that they could be trading out pick 1 - I'd expect pick 3 at best because Richmond and West Coast will be awful again but pick 1 isn't impossible with an injury run from hell.

The implication is they'd get our pick plus change, otherwise they would just hand the future first directly to Port for Houston.

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Even if Bolton/Baker did fall through, I honestly couldn't see us trading out 9 and 10 for a future first from North. I also don't think JL can afford to put all his apples into getting Warner for 2026 when we clearly need a game breaking small forward to drive us up the ladder.

 

[DragoDelph]

Pretty sure if Warner isn’t this year, then we look at koz/baker and worry about Chad next year.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I reckon Shai will be agreed on early doors but actually get done at the death for 'suspense' as nobody will give a shit about other trades like Darling to North and Martin to Geelong enough for those to be held over

I think Barrass and Smith are set up to provide trade radio talking points through to the deadline (Smith in particular is going to be nasty I think). Bolton will be done week 1 easily IMO.

 

[freo_leo29]

Future trading is in next year anyway

We don't need to shift anything forward

Will have 2+ first rounders anyway

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Pretty sure if Warner isn’t this year, then we look at koz/baker and worry about Chad next year.

Agree, but the article was suggesting we could miss out on Bolton and Baker, and if we did we should convert the currency into our 2025 draft hand for another crack at Warner. I don't think we have a year to wait, we need to improve the list now.

 

[freo_leo29]

I think Barrass and Smith are set up to provide trade radio talking points through to the deadline (Smith in particular is going to be nasty I think). Bolton will be done week 1 easily IMO.

Start of week 2 is what will happen

Freo usually folds after a weekend



Nothing will happen week 1, just the bare minimum

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Start of week 2 is what will happen

Freo usually folds after a weekend



Nothing will happen week 1, just the bare minimum

Nah, I think this is a long way progressed and will need to happen for other deals. Backing in week 1