Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Saints4ever]

Holmes
vs
Richards
vs
Hinge (less flexibility)

Holmes.
Traded him in 2 weeks ago and haven’t regretted it.
Runs super hard to present as an option.
It’s amazing when you have a player and you watch him so close like never before you can discover there flaws.
Holmes flaw doesn’t go in super hard but his running ability makes up for this.
Just my 2 cents.

 

[VainGlorious]

Curnow vs Dylan moore for f6

Dylan Moore

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Dylan Moore

But Curnow has an easy run home look at what he did to the Tigers yesterday...

 

[VainGlorious]

But Curnow has an easy run home look at what he did to the Tigers yesterday...

My problems only begin there mate.

Fisher F4
Curnow F5
Greene/Bolton F6/7

 

[No eye deer]

I actually dodged a bullet with my ineptitude.
Forgot to do the Greene Curnow trade on Saturday.

 

[No eye deer]

Ryan vs Rankine.
Fisher fwd or back depending on trade.
Last trade to complete my side.
Currently sitting on 7 trades.
Got a few spuds still, like most though.
I'm looking at you Rowell, Greene and Fisher.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I actually dodged a bullet with my ineptitude.
Forgot to do the Greene Curnow trade on Saturday.

Curnow had a mare .
He wasn't alone ...

 

[Scythe94]

Ryan vs Rankine.
Fisher fwd or back depending on trade.
Last trade to complete my side.
Currently sitting on 7 trades.
Got a few spuds still, like most though.
I'm looking at you Rowell, Greene and Fisher.

Ryan (by a fair bit) IMO.

 

[ubeaut]

Evans vs Schoenmakers for D7

Trading out T. Brown

 

[SC fish]

Evans vs Schoenmakers for D7

Trading out T. Brown

Both seem to be well rated by their respective fans - but who knows whether that translates to continue getting games and scoring OK. I only saw Schoenmakers first game and he looked good.

I thought I'd be grappling with this decision too, but have decided to keep TBrown at D7 for the season and conserve my three trades

 

[Blues of 77]

Evans vs Schoenmakers for D7

Trading out T. Brown

Suspect Evans keeps his spot longer and is cheaper. Humphries probably a better pick with DPP but needs to hold his spot.

 

[Blues of 77]

I will make one more trade. Trading out either Fisher or Ridley. Fisher injured this week might seem like an obvious choice but if I keep Fisher down back (when trading Ridley) I have DPP action across my team with the need for only one premo sub on the bench (in any position). Ridleys breakeven of 155 is also a factor. Thoughts? Who scores better from here?

 

[Blues of 77]

I will make one more trade. Trading out either Fisher or Ridley. Fisher injured this week might seem like an obvious choice but if I keep Fisher down back (when trading Ridley) I have DPP action across my team with the need for only one premo sub on the bench (in any position). Ridleys breakeven of 155 is also a factor. Thoughts? Who scores better from here?

I should note that I'll be trading Rankine in for both of these trades. And a final piece of info that is useful - I am concerned about Fisher's role with McK back.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I will make one more trade. Trading out either Fisher or Ridley. Fisher injured this week might seem like an obvious choice but if I keep Fisher down back (when trading Ridley) I have DPP action across my team with the need for only one premo sub on the bench (in any position). Ridleys breakeven of 155 is also a factor. Thoughts? Who scores better from here?

Trade out Ridley I reckon.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I should note that I'll be trading Rankine in for both of these trades. And a final piece of info that is useful - I am concerned about Fisher's role with McK back.

Mckercher won't affect Fisher much when he comes back next week. They were both scoring well together when in the same team.

 

[gh172]

Trade out Rowell or Fisher?
Trade in Caldwell or Rozee ?

Sent from my SM-G986B using Tapatalk

 

[Jiska]

Xerri vs Nank vs TDK.

If I had trades left I’d def go TDK, but this will be my last so prob too risky,

 

[Judd_Magic]

Xerri vs Nank vs TDK.

If I had trades left I’d def go TDK, but this will be my last so prob too risky,

Xerri

 

[Judd_Magic]

Take Kreugers 63 or roll with Humphries?

 

[Jiska]

Take Kreugers 63 or roll with Humphries?

Humphries (if not sub).

 

[Judd_Magic]

Humphries (if not sub).

Will be too late to decide by then as I have to switch Sexton with Fisher in order to play Humphries at D6.

You'd think Mannagh or Knevitt would be sub.

 

[Jiska]

Will be too late to decide by then as I have to switch Sexton with Fisher in order to play Humphries at D6.

You'd think Mannagh or Knevitt would be sub.

Yeah would say he starts. Hopefully doesn’t get subbed out. You’d think he’d match 63

 

[Judd_Magic]

Yeah would say he starts. Hopefully doesn’t get subbed out. You’d think he’d match 63

So go with Humphries uncle or play it safe with Kreuger?

 

[toxic]

So go with Humphries uncle or play it safe with Kreuger?

Go with Humphrey

 

[Kedford]

Keep Fisher & Steele or trade for Rankine and Rozee

Will have 6 trades with 2nd option and still need a 6th forward next week with either option with Dowling covering atm.