Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Scoops at a low ebb. Wouldn't know Thompson Dow from a bar of soap, Nathaniel has also infiltrated Scoops' safe space. Send help.
View attachment 1903893
What's this kent Dow done to get picked?

1707722388997.png

Going at this rate he'll need 40 each week to ton up.

1707722443207.png


Bad Hair Day Love GIF by Danny Casale
 
Got a good crack the last 3 games. TOG 74/82/80, decent CBA's. Kick/hand ball ratio a worry, as is the lack of tackles and marks. Watch him in the PS I guess......


View attachment 1903922


View attachment 1903921
Yeah, placeholder to an extent, but honestly, if he does get a run, he might be OK.
Don’t really love Harmes and others in that similar bracket,for example, but actual games will change all sorts of stuff.
 
Yeah, placeholder to an extent, but honestly, if he does get a run, he might be OK.
Don’t really love Harmes and others in that similar bracket,for example, but actual games will change all sorts of stuff.
Yeah, if he was a forward it's a different story. Seems a waste of a spot in midfield though.
 
What's this kent Dow done to get picked?

View attachment 1903907

Going at this rate he'll need 40 each week to ton up.

View attachment 1903909


Bad Hair Day Love GIF by Danny Casale

Well it is hard to break into a multiple premiership winning side but I'm sure you wouldn't understand. At least you have a burnt out coach to tell you about the good times.:moustache:

Back on Dow you could also show all 4 games he played and not just 1 selected game.:thumbsupv1:
If he gets his kick to handball ratio closer he will be a good supercoach player. We get 3 games to decide whether he is worth stating with.

1707725884267.png
 
My view is it will be Danger, Tom Atkins, Cam Guthrie, Tanner Bruhn and Max Holmes as the main guys. Then probably rotate a whole bunch through - Blicavs, Clark, MOC, Parfitt.

Guthrie will get the role, but just don't think he will score the 100/105 he needs to be worth it as a pick.


Personally wouldn't pick either!
The points have to go somewhere. I don’t see a ball hog in that bunch. Guthrie will get plenty of possessions IMO
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The points have to go somewhere. I don’t see a ball hog in that bunch. Guthrie will get plenty of possessions IMO
Guthrie would probably be the biggest ball hog of the bunch outside of beast-mode Danger, which we aren't likely to see for long.

When we went on our winning streak from Round 10 in 2022, he averaged 105 from 26 possies a game, which includes a 9 disposal, 55-point game where he got injured. He was 29 when he did that and he's 31 now with nearly a year's rest in his body, so he's certainly capable of that, and he's averaged 110+ before (in 2021).

So you would pick Guthrie with the expectation that he blitzes the start of the season and makes you some cash, at which point you cash him out for a $100,000+ pay day. Saints, Crows, Hawks, Dogs, North and Lions is an up-and-down 6 weeks difficulty-wise, but he's gone 120+ against all of those teams before (especially Crows).

There is no chance he ends up a top 8 mid though, so you'd better hope the purple patch is early and he doesn't start the year with a 64 (15 disposals) and a 77 (25) like he did last year.
 
Here's my first iteration of a team for this season. I've been flat out with a heap of stuff and have done zero research - I literally threw this together in about 20 minutes.

I'm interested in some feedback especially on any mid-pricers or rookies that are looking like traps.

1707781211597.png
Have at it.
 
Here's my first iteration of a team for this season. I've been flat out with a heap of stuff and have done zero research - I literally threw this together in about 20 minutes.

I'm interested in some feedback especially on any mid-pricers or rookies that are looking like traps.

View attachment 1904251
Have at it.
Well.....you have quite a few R0 players, they all have a bye in the first 6 weeks so may not be great starting picks. Most people seem to be trying to limit themselves to one premo in each bye round.

Curious why you have 3 forward premo's in midfield?

Chapman just did his hammy and will miss round 1, DevRob has been injured in PS too. Not sure Jeffrey is best 22 currently either. You definitely want Mckercher and Sharp in as rookies.
 
Here's my first iteration of a team for this season. I've been flat out with a heap of stuff and have done zero research - I literally threw this together in about 20 minutes.

I'm interested in some feedback especially on any mid-pricers or rookies that are looking like traps.

View attachment 1904251
Have at it.
Forward line stinks.
Chapman won’t play R1 did a hammy.
Why are Bolton, Flanders & Macrae in mids?
 
Well.....you have quite a few R0 players, they all have a bye in the first 6 weeks so may not be great starting picks. Most people seem to be trying to limit themselves to one premo in each bye round.

Curious why you have 3 forward premo's in midfield?

Forward line stinks.
Chapman won’t play R1 did a hammy.
Why are Bolton, Flanders & Macrae in mids?
This is the shit I want - thanks!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team


Write your reply...

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top