Chrome extension desktop only called SC mod
Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team
- Thread starter Better Loosen Up
- Start date
- Tagged users None
toxic
Hall of Famer
Lack of real elite captain options would scare meHi all, would appreciate any feedback. Daicos is hopefully gettablr after the Fin blanket has been applied.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
- Sep 25, 2013
- 3,456
- 4,356
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Ahhhh, we should come up with a name for this phenomenon.Someone help me please - everytime I put Heeney back into my team it looks so much better
It's like the Supercoach equivalent of beer goggles
Thoughts on Draft # 2 - 4.2K left in Bank
Ahh gotcha! Thanks for clarifying
Tbh bye structure is overrated - it's best 18 anyway.
Most people's teams will significantly change by the time the main bye's come mid season.
- Sep 25, 2013
- 3,456
- 4,356
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Pretty solid.
Personally don't like the Naismith selection. Think he makes way for Nank as soon as he is ready. Rather have the 102k donut there.
Both Reville and Brown unlikely to play any time soon, if at all. Need to find playing rookies for cash generation.
Downgrading Wines would be how I would find the funds to do so, but up to you
Wines > Holmes
It's best 18 but if you have too many round 0 players you will have more rookie scores in that 18 whereas other teams will have more premo scoresAhh gotcha! Thanks for clarifying
Tbh bye structure is overrated - it's best 18 anyway.
Most people's teams will significantly change by the time the main bye's come mid season.
Round one teams drop in the next few hours. It's finally upon us. Best of luck for the year folks
Blues / Tigers only?
- Sep 25, 2013
- 3,456
- 4,356
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Ok...I'm in fine tuning mode!!
Still torn on afew spots.. Dawson v Traca, Miller v Newcombe, Stewart v Sicily...
Any feedback or suggestions will be much welcomed!
View attachment 1926530
Good team - nothing wrong with it.
In terms of your "torn" decisions - they are just coin flips with both options quality.
If it was me - I'd go Dawson, only because he plays 1 more game than Petracca (meaning an extra 60 or so points in that bye week). Dawson arguably more scope to improve with Adelaide's potential rise and less likely to play forward but on the flip side, Trac has been elite for longer.
For Miller vs Newcombe - again, both good choices. I've gone Miller simply because he has proven he can go 120+ (twice) before (and is only this cheap due to injury). Newcombe's scores jump every year and expect that will happen again but I'm conservative and will always go for the player that has proven he can do it over those that are yet to do so (cos predicting 'breakouts' is a hard business). I also think Gold Coast are likely to be a bit better which usually means that 'quiet' games are not as low scoring.
Stewart vs Sicily is another coin flip. I've gone Stewart for no real reason, other than possible anti-bias (I seem less likely to choose Hawthorn players). If I were to over-analyse, I might suggest it is because Sicily's scores seem a little more volatile (2 sub 65 scores to Stewart's 0) and I prefer the consistent scorer to the feast/famine types but even that is splitting hairs looking at the data (this volatility seems to come when Sicily has to be "extra lockdown" whereas Stewart is always freewheeling). The only other tiny difference is Stewart's ave includes an injury affected 18 so he is slightly under his true average price. Again, absolute hair splitting.
NinjaSwan
Brownlow Medallist
This is what I've got currently, still undecided on a couple things (could do Stewart down to Houston/Sheezel and then one of my 'value' mids up to a 600k+ player) but I'm happy enough with it.
With Heeney/JJ I plan on an aggressive move trading one or both of them after Round 4, the bye should coincide with the return of Parker & Adams, and I can then bring in someone like Flanders whose bye would have already passed, or see if any other #1 forward option has emerged through the first month of the season.
Yup
TennisPlayerAndy
Game #6 Klay
- Apr 1, 2008
- 60,039
- 108,159
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Raiders, GSW, QPR, NYM
I think I’ve done it:
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Heeney is like an emotionally abusive ex begging for another final chance.
Sam Flanders got to beat up on a Tigs side still looking to find its rhythm, impossible to.gauge his output level.
L Jackson could be strong with no bye and DPP, but hard to see him being 'value' on the year unless Darcy misses 6+ games.
Heeney into Flanders can work, but it consumes a trade at a slightly awkward time.
All a bit of unnecessary drama tbh.
Sam Flanders got to beat up on a Tigs side still looking to find its rhythm, impossible to.gauge his output level.
L Jackson could be strong with no bye and DPP, but hard to see him being 'value' on the year unless Darcy misses 6+ games.
Heeney into Flanders can work, but it consumes a trade at a slightly awkward time.
All a bit of unnecessary drama tbh.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
I don't see any of those mid wookies are going to be picked..
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Scoops getting ahead of himself.Or they are sleeping cause it's the middle of fluffing night
On a Tuesdee
More bath water boy's?
Scoopsmorrow with the quick clip.over the ear to put an end to the head wobbles.
Hallmark of a quality leader
Ok kenties I think this is my final team.
I would have liked Houston up back to have 4 defence premos but I find that imbalances the team elsewhere.
I would have liked Houston up back to have 4 defence premos but I find that imbalances the team elsewhere.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
I don't have any of them .
I won't get beating up.
Bruise free.
I won't get any sexy time .
Lonely.
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Watch status of Carroll and S Campbell with expected team ins.Been settled on this basic structure for a while, just playing around with which premo's to choose based on how much dough I have remaining. With this iteration I have a whopping $400. I'd love another viable option instead of Windsor but I won't be holding my breath. Probably take him in the end
View attachment 1926514
Happy for any feedback
Sharp leg.kmock in last state league hitout, reckon he's pretty iffy.
Cadman and Burgess options with likely good JS up forward (Cadman definitely,.Baby John wait and see),.you could cull Sharp,.shift Windsor to MIDs and go Cadman.+ Burgess or Nyuon or ... up forward if needed.
Just be prepared for reshuffles like that if needed
- Dec 7, 2019
- 24,152
- 65,471
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Manchester United, All Blacks
On reflection Scoopsmorrow might have bit a little sharp with the feedbackScoops getting ahead of himself.
Scoopsmorrow with the quick clip.over the ear to put an end to the head wobbles.
Hallmark of a quality leader
Possibly over did it a little
Off to run laps and consider moderation in all it's forms (but not forums)
Structure looks pretty solid, not sure on Jackson he looks like a possible trap. Flanders taking up an onfield mid spot is interesting. Other than that looks clean although Rd 3 and 5 byes will be interesting
vanders
Brownlow Medallist
The extra money is to upgrade whichever rookie is the biggest dud by round 3 to Lyons after his first bye.
