2024 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

[kerrazy]

SHeezel missing out. Mass missing the wing. Xerri missing out for Gawn. Jezza getting in on his name.

These are not that controversial, its subjective after all.

But Waterman as a forward?!! You have to laugh really. He has been bog average since the bye. Absolutely baffling

20 goals in 9 games. I wouldn't call that bog average considering the Eagles were far worse after the bye. Allen also came into the side.

 

[mattwa]

Nick Daicos broke nearly every record in the book for a 1st & 2nd year player and is walk up AA.

Sheezel matches him step for step for 2 years...

In a team that's finished 18th and 17th...

 

[stallon]

20 goals in 9 games. I wouldn't call that bog average considering the Eagles were far worse after the bye. Allen also came into the side.

Exactly, wouldnt say he was bog average, just the media talk about him stopped

 

[JasRulz63]

The selectors actually selected two wingmen last year with Gulden and J. Daicos.

If they're going to pick the best players based on their position, then D'Ambrosio should've been the other one.

McClugagge was one of the better wingers in the competition and made the squad for four years in a row from 2019-2022, and never made the team.

 

[RAPPA]

Weitering and McGovern aren’t fit to tie Andrews’ boots.

Tell me you’re a pillock without telling me you’re a pillock

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Nick Daicos broke nearly every record in the book for a 1st & 2nd year player and is walk up AA.

Sheezel matches him step for step for 2 years...

What a joke of a comment.

Sheezel couldn’t tie Daicos shoes

 

[ep2018]

McGovern deserves his spot, has been fantastic this season in a poor team. Waterman is a curious choice but I presume it had more to do with how good a season he's had compared to his average. He has improved out of sight.

 

[Hoops]

Stengle with as many goals as the much maligned Jake Stringer. There’s a good reason be didn’t make the side

More than Moore

 

[FreoRicci]

Curnow injured by round 20, apparently that’s not enough.
Waterman was injured most games as well. Bizarre

 

[adammania9]

More than Moore

Moore had an undeniably better year thanks to his contributions up the ground

 

[Ash1337]

In a team that's finished 18th and 17th...

It was 17th both years.

 

[CBSlogger]

In a team that's finished 18th and 17th...

Waterman, McGovern.

Last time I checked teams don't make the AA team.

 

[goondog]

McGovern deserves his spot, has been fantastic this season in a poor team. Waterman is a curious choice but I presume it had more to do with how good a season he's had compared to his average. He has improved out of sight.

Begs the question, should we have a Most Improved Player award?

 

[Shinboner roo]

What a joke of a comment.

Sheezel couldn’t tie Daicos shoes

No need to throw a tandy because jhf didn't get a jacket

 

[BuddysBiggestFan]

More than Moore

Stengle sits at the back and waits for cheapies.

Even the wizard does a hell of a lot more.

 

[TY24]

McGovern if he stays fit

 

[boncer34]

In a team that's finished 18th and 17th...

Is AA a team award?

 

[Jcpdragonx]

McGovern deserves his spot, has been fantastic this season in a poor team. Waterman is a curious choice but I presume it had more to do with how good a season he's had compared to his average. He has improved out of sight.

McGovern was a clear choice for 3rd tall, shouldnt have had any competition. Andrews was a walk up for KPD and somehow didnt get it.

 

[TY24]

Weitering and McGovern aren’t fit to tie Andrews’ boots.

Have you ever watched football?

 

[Ash1337]

Curnow had a great first half but was very average after bye before injured I think. Likely why he wasn't selected.

 

[Snarls Barkley]

7 years between AAs - is that a record?

Hope someone has this stat, would be interesting

Going back through the sides a little bit

Some I found were: Naitanui (8yrs, 2012-2020), Hawkins (7yrs, 2012-2019), Richardson (9yrs, 1999-2008)

I'm sure there is got to be some real long ones though

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

No need to throw a tandy because jhf didn't get a jacket

Comparing Sheezel to arguably the best player in the comp for the last 18 months is just silly. Has a long long way before he is half the player nick is

 

[Hoops]

Moore had an undeniably better year thanks to his contributions up the ground

So there's different positions now. But didn't you mention Stringer?

 

[QuietB]

No Xerri on the bench... vic bias

There should only ever be 1 ruck

 

[LongSerong]

Weitering and McGovern aren’t fit to tie Andrews’ boots.

McGovern has achieved more than Andrew's by a long way to this date