Game Day 2024 Trade Period - Lian Yu - that liminal space between trade and draft.

[Polo342]

Get ready

Tell us

 

[Paracleet]

 

[DocT]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

 

[Azz 27]

It's an early Dockers type move, you know, just awful.

Similar to the Lobb trade, which was shocking.

 

[Cayman Docker]

I would say its still possible we pay a stupid price for Bolton and everyone gets upset.

I don’t care what we pay. It will still be worth it. And if it all falls on its a$$ it wasn’t meant to be and bring on the draft, it’s bloody great.

 

[Azz 27]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

Stop using points unless talking about father son or accademy players.

Or at least, use the points from next year's system which is half fair.

 

[rubydoomsday]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

we're in the window.

west coast are... not

when you have a legit shot at the brass ring, you roll the dice. swing for the fences.

you don't do this when you're whatever the f WC are rn

 

[Van_Dyke]

I'll be staggered if we trade out an F1-F3 with Warner on the table.

This is possibly set to be the first time since future pick trading started that we’re keeping our F2, it feels strange and unnatural

 

[G Mus]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

List profile, we’re not rebuilding

 

[Arkhitect]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

We aren't in the early stages of a rebuild like WC are. We're adding the cream on top.

 

[Purple Suit]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

Point system is broken so not a good way to judge trades. WC also split pick 3 for Baker so it is a considerably dumber idea.

They basically lost the next Sheezle for Chesser & Baker.

On comparison to Freo it looks like we are trading the next Ras & Sturt for Bolton.

 

[DragoDelph]

All for west coast cooking their rebuild with this trade but why did they have to let Carlton benefit. Wonder if they will pull off another Paddy Dow special with pick 3 this year.

Petracca or draft

 

[arsesmart]

Stop using points unless talking about father son or accademy players.

Or at least, use the points from next year's system which is half fair.

True, you can't really think of draft picks like money. It's about what's available at that pick, which is both variable (both in real and perceived terms) and limited. It's more like real estate.

 

[DragoDelph]

Deal is official

 

[Purple Suit]

This is possibly set to be the first time since future pick trading started that we’re keeping our F2, it feels strange and unnatural

 

[bigfoopy]

HAHAHAHAHAH

 

[freo1997]

The New Fitzroy

 

[One_Wing]

This board's trade discussion is odd...
We are mercilessly mocking WCE for valuing Baker at Pick 14.
The general consensus was Baker is worth a decent 2nd rounder eg pick 25.
Points value difference 14 - 25 = 434 points.
While simultaneously...
Most here are happy that Bolton is worth 10 and 18
AND some of whom can talk about adding in pick 30 to get the deal done.
Pick 30 = 454 points.
Why is one absoutely nothing but dumb while the other is reasonable?

They gave up pick 3

 

[go_the_dockers]

Deal is official

Bolton?

 

[DragoDelph]

Bolton?

The west coast one

 

[FD2646]

Their planning a protest at training on the WCE board.... hilarious. What a day, what a trade!

 

[go_the_dockers]

The west coast one

You got me excited.

 

[DragoDelph]

 

[largebus]

There was an audible gasp from the office eagle supporter just now.

All hail Matt Clarke!

 

[freo84]

Freo fans after reading west coast doing that trade.