Game Day 2024 Trade Period - Lian Yu - that liminal space between trade and draft.

[Farrand]

More I look at the deal, the more I’m fine with it.

Hopefully Tigers are paying cap but

Better be.

 

[Lach72]

We paid the equivalent of pick 2 in points people, that is way overs. It's not a coincide we paid overs for Jackson.

Pick 4 according to draft guru

 

[SupermanCapes]

Good trade, good business. Get the fella in who addresses a glaring list need, maintain a first round pick in an historically deep and even draft and get on with being a serious footy club.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

How good are the nga players next year? Like first round good or second to third round?

One maybe late first. Another one hard to place.

Having said that I remember when Jason Carter was talked about in those terms a year out.

 

[A New Hope]

To get Bolton done so early today, we must have some more irons in the oven surely.

 

[freocuz]

So is it Shy or Shay?


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Wabjub]

Who says we want Bo Allen?

Why can people not be unhappy with the trade?

Well we can be in for whoever we want. We got a 4 pick upgrade from 18.

And if you want to be pissed be my guest but put your thinking hat on and realise we upgraded 18 to 14. Richmond always wanted 10 and 11. We made the most out of it.

 

[wakojako]

Pick 4 according to draft guru

That doesn't make it better. We were all ridiculing WC for giving up pick 3 and we did the same.

 

[Freoforever86]

Better be.

It’s still pick 10 & 18
We’ve just downgraded 11 to 14.

 

[dont bowl there]

We paid the equivalent of pick 2 in points people, that is way overs. It's not a coincide we paid overs for Jackson.

 

[Bigger]

So im only new here but seeing Tigers fans coming in here trying to haggle like we are all list managers and trying to convince us to agree to their pro-Richmond views of how the trade should look is fckn bizarre to me

What is the rationale? Do they think if they can convince us Freo fans to see things their way and agree on a certain set of terms being fair that itll somehow affect the real trade?

"If we can get Freo fans to agree then our list manager will have the blueprint to convince Walls as well! Quick - to the Freo board!"

Do they think the list managers lurk here looking for intel or ideas?

"Cave and give us all your picks or we will keep Bolton!" Yeah, you do that in your imaginary list managers role. Great job buddy

It’s something that I have never grasped. I get trade hypotheticals but actual haggling with oppo nuffies? It’s taking being irrelevant to whole new places.

Otherwise a decent place. I am enjoying the Meth Coast dalliance with gallows humour. Being arsef(cked on the reg has revealed some quite funny blue and piss-yellas. They still all need more humiliation though.

The Richmond campaigners are all cut from the same Spotlight cloth. Like they studied arrogance from the Hawthorn arseholes but are still fundamentally damaged and fragile.

Port people are the best. Absolute frothing nutcases. Like how South Fremantle folk would be if they had East Fremantle’s record.

 

[Swiggy]

Don't hate it get a gun, & top 15 pick & points for Toby Whan & Basil Hart next year

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Ok. Well now I’m just trading out 14 to Swans if they still want to offer 19 and 22. Stuff it.

There was just a smidge of players at 11 possibly available.

Yeah i'd be on this if no one we want falls.

 

[Docker82]

Also what’s the point of clubs not being allowed to announce deals if all the journos know exactly what they’re going to be anyway.

 

[nurries]

We paid the equivalent of pick 2 in points people, that is way overs. It's not a coincide we paid overs for Jackson.

With the future 3rd (pick37), equivalent to pick 4.

 

[BStaff17]

I think it’s remarkable that Tigers can lose: Baker, Rioli, Graham, Bolton and the narrative is about how well they’re going to be able to rebuild with the picks they have.

Class and leadership walking out. Doesn’t seem to be the story.

Just interesting.

They won 3 flags i reckon i could cop a 5+ year full rebuild off a 3-premiership dynasty.

Heck i would even cop it if we won 1 like the Demons.

Every premiership is hard to get and no guarantees despite the quality and age brackets you can win multiple flags. Take everything you get and always cherish every flag.

 

[SupermanCapes]

That doesn't make it better. We were all ridiculing WC for giving up pick 3 and we did the same.

But we're trying to win a flag next year? Also it's pretty silly to think that drafting two players at 10 and 18 is remotely the same as drafting a Sheezel or Reid in the top 3. It's a good trade and there's no doubt there is salary at play behind the scenes. Walls isn't a fool.

 

[fnerd]

Good trade, good business. Get the fella in who addresses a glaring list need, maintain a first round pick in an historically deep and even draft and get on with being a serious footy club.

No it’s not it’s shit ,management again trying to cover their arses for lack of progress

 

[go_the_dockers]

Dunno why people are pissed off this much.

It's a 3 pick downgrade or a 4 pick upgrade from 18? We are still in for Bo Allen now. And got Shai.

Stop having a melt down.

It depends on the draft order, and who gets picked where. Who knows how the draft order will end up, and who we are chasing.

I think the 3 pick down grade costs us any chance of Berry (you need to remember that Lombard, Kako and Ashcroft are all father son or NGA, so our pick will drop a bit )


Davo's Phantom Draft

1. Rich - Lalor
2. Bris - (bid) Ashcroft
3. NM - J.Smith
4. Carl - FOS
5. Adel - Draper
6. Ess - (bid) Kako
7. Melb - Smillie
8. GCS - (bid) Lombard
9. Rich - Langford
10. StK - Armstrong
11. StK - M.Reid
12. Melb - Tauru
13. Rich - Berry
14. Frem - Bo Allan
15. WCE - Travaglia
16. Port - Gerreyn
17. Rich - Lindsay
18. Carl - (bid) B.Camporeale
19. GWS - Hotton
20. GWS - Ough
21. WB - Trainor
22. Rich - Hynes
23. Syd - Shanahan
24. Bris - (bid) Marshall
25. Rich - Stumpf


Chris Phantom Draft

1. Levi Ashcroft (179cm mid, Brisbane)
2. Finn O'Sullivan (182cm mid, Vic Country)
3. Harvey Langford (191cm mid, Vic Country)
4. Xavier Lindsay (183cm mid, Vic Country)
5. Alix Tauru (193cm def, Vic Country)
6. Jagga Smith (182cm mid, Vic Metro)
7. Murphy Reid (181cm mid, Vic Metro)
8. Sid Draper (182cm mid, South Australia)
9. Joe Berry (181cm fwd, Vic Country)
10. Sam Lalor (188cm mid, Vic Country)

11. Leonardo Lombard (179cm mid, Gold Coast)
12. Josh Smillie (195cm mid, Vic Metro)
13. Tobie Travaglia (187cm def, Vic Country)
14. Harry Armstrong (195cm fwd, Vic Metro)
15. Hamish Davis (190cm fwd, Western Australia)
16. Harrison Oliver (181cm def, Vic Metro)
17. Luke Trainor (194cm def, Vic Metro)
18. Bo Allan (191cm def/mid, Western Australia)
19. Isaac Kako (176cm fwd, Vic Metro)
20. Taj Hotton (182cm mid/fwd, Vic Metro)

21. Jobe Shanahan (195cm fwd, Allies)
22. Angus Clarke (189cm def, South Australia)
23. Cooper Hynes (190cm fwd, Vic Country)
24. Tom Gross (181cm mid, Vic Metro)
25. Jesse Dattoli (179cm mid/fwd, Vic Metro)
26. Sam Marshall (185cm mid, Brisbane)
27. James Barrat (194cm def, Vic Country)
28. Christian Moraes (183cm mid, Vic Metro)
29. Jack Whitlock (200cm fwd, Vic Country)
30. Oliver Hannaford (180cm fwd, Vic Country)

eDPS phantom draft

 

[freoshocker]

We've been absolutely shafted. first round slide and F3 pick means naff all.

We should have stuck to our guns and said 10 & 18, if not see you later!

Now we've been shafted do we trade pick 14 for a future round one pick?

 

[fnerd]

But we're trying to win a flag next year? Also it's pretty silly to think that drafting two players at 10 and 18 is remotely the same as drafting a Sheezel or Reid in the top 3. It's a good trade and there's no doubt there is salary at play behind the scenes. Walls isn't a fool.

Oh well give them everything they ask then shall we?

 

[rubydoomsday]

Dunno why people are pissed off this much.

It's a 3 pick downgrade or a 4 pick upgrade from 18 (which is more likely thr case as Tiges always wanted 10 and 11) We are still in for Bo Allen or whoever the club wants. And got Shai.

Stop having a melt down.

no we're not (in for Allan) necessarily, Eagles pick before us and they too will target WA talent

ofc, we can rest assured they may yet find a way to shit the bed there, too

 

[Farrand]

It’s still pick 10 & 18
We’ve just downgraded 11 to 14.

As much as I can agree with that, I, personally, don't care for the Bolton trade. I would happily have waited until next year for Pickett (if available) or Warner (if available) while drafting in a strong draft. Whatever trades for futures be what they may.

 

[arsesmart]

We've basically turned Schultz into Bolton and a 3 picks backslide.

 

[dont bowl there]

Oh well give them everything they ask then shall we?

We offered 10 and 18 and it ended up splitting the middle. We also got the most talented small we have had at the club since prime Sonny. Add him to this list and we are going places.

 

[Wabjub]

It depends on the draft order, and who gets picked where. Who knows how the draft order will end up, and who we are chasing.

I think the 3 pick down grade costs us any chance of Berry (you need to remember that Lombard, Kako and Ashcroft are all father son or NGA, so our pick will drop a bit )


Davo's Phantom Draft

1. Rich - Lalor
2. Bris - (bid) Ashcroft
3. NM - J.Smith
4. Carl - FOS
5. Adel - Draper
6. Ess - (bid) Kako
7. Melb - Smillie
8. GCS - (bid) Lombard
9. Rich - Langford
10. StK - Armstrong
11. StK - M.Reid
12. Melb - Tauru
13. Rich - Berry
14. Frem - Bo Allan
15. WCE - Travaglia
16. Port - Gerreyn
17. Rich - Lindsay
18. Carl - (bid) B.Camporeale
19. GWS - Hotton
20. GWS - Ough
21. WB - Trainor
22. Rich - Hynes
23. Syd - Shanahan
24. Bris - (bid) Marshall
25. Rich - Stumpf


Chris Phantom Draft

1. Levi Ashcroft (179cm mid, Brisbane)
2. Finn O'Sullivan (182cm mid, Vic Country)
3. Harvey Langford (191cm mid, Vic Country)
4. Xavier Lindsay (183cm mid, Vic Country)
5. Alix Tauru (193cm def, Vic Country)
6. Jagga Smith (182cm mid, Vic Metro)
7. Murphy Reid (181cm mid, Vic Metro)
8. Sid Draper (182cm mid, South Australia)
9. Joe Berry (181cm fwd, Vic Country)
10. Sam Lalor (188cm mid, Vic Country)

11. Leonardo Lombard (179cm mid, Gold Coast)
12. Josh Smillie (195cm mid, Vic Metro)
13. Tobie Travaglia (187cm def, Vic Country)
14. Harry Armstrong (195cm fwd, Vic Metro)
15. Hamish Davis (190cm fwd, Western Australia)
16. Harrison Oliver (181cm def, Vic Metro)
17. Luke Trainor (194cm def, Vic Metro)
18. Bo Allan (191cm def/mid, Western Australia)
19. Isaac Kako (176cm fwd, Vic Metro)
20. Taj Hotton (182cm mid/fwd, Vic Metro)

21. Jobe Shanahan (195cm fwd, Allies)
22. Angus Clarke (189cm def, South Australia)
23. Cooper Hynes (190cm fwd, Vic Country)
24. Tom Gross (181cm mid, Vic Metro)
25. Jesse Dattoli (179cm mid/fwd, Vic Metro)
26. Sam Marshall (185cm mid, Brisbane)
27. James Barrat (194cm def, Vic Country)
28. Christian Moraes (183cm mid, Vic Metro)
29. Jack Whitlock (200cm fwd, Vic Country)
30. Oliver Hannaford (180cm fwd, Vic Country)

eDPS phantom draft

View attachment 2143569

Draft nights also have alot of players who are taken early which throws some players deeper into the first round. It's a 50/50 with Berry. Hopefully we asked Richmond to leave him as we want him.