Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[Choppers]

Peatling v Parker v Sanders

I gotta take one...

 

[rocker_oz33]

Peatling v Parker v Sanders

I gotta take one...

PS watch .
Pealting mid only will have to avg well to keep.
Parker git dpp. Might be a keeper.

 

[Choppers]

PS watch .
Pealting mid only will have to avg well to keep.
Parker git dpp. Might be a keeper.

PS watch for sure.....I rate Peatling but will he get game time, and what role will Parker have, and then there's Bevo...

 

[rocker_oz33]

PS watch for sure.....I rate Peatling but will he get game time, and what role will Parker have, and then there's Bevo...

Crows mid feild will an interesting watch.
Seen a post with.
Laid moved back.
Dawson wing.
Pleating killing it in the guts.

But only PS training.

I'm taking it with a gain of salt .
At this stage

But pleating cheap and could score the best in that price range.say vs mills etc.

 

[stevebbb]

Peatling v Parker v Sanders

I gotta take one...

Peatling.

 

[King_Steele]

Peatling v Parker v Sanders

I gotta take one...

Peatling

 

[Raveneyes]

A few teams were scrambling to get Peatling during the AFL trading afternoon (lol at 2 weeks).
Getting bulk mid minutes over PS would seal the deal.
But he would be the first I cut from my team if we get a stack of decent mid rookies playing early.

Parker is one I like. Underestimated on here.
Fills a deep experience void on ball. 2 years ago he averaged in the 90's, after 5 consecutive 100+ years.
I don't think the drop off is here yet, as he was only moved due to the Swans deep midfield. Even Adams couldn't get a look-in. Is in my side.

Sanders is a PS watch.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

English(R2) + Flynn(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Noddy(Flex)

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

English(R2) + Noddy(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Flynn(Flex)

Xerri and Flynn

 

[stevebbb]

English(R2) + Noddy(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Flynn(Flex)

Is that a typo? What am I even comparing?

total spend is $780k vs $908k. What is that extra ~$130k used for?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Is that a typo? What am I even comparing?

total spend is $780k vs $908k. What is that extra ~$130k used for?

Oops typo
Fixed

English(R2) + Flynn(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Noddy(Flex)

 

[Raveneyes]

Oops typo
Fixed

English(R2) + Flynn(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Noddy(Flex)

I don't mind the English + Noddy + $130k option.

Could that cash be used elsewhere?

 

[stevebbb]

Oops typo
Fixed

English(R2) + Flynn(Flex) vs Xerri(R2) + Noddy(Flex)

That makes more sense

If I had to choose, Xerri and NOD (although I currently have Xerri and Flynn)

I'm starting to get nervous with Flynn. Not only am I worried about his body, but he has a tough run: Witts, BigO, Darcy/Jackson, Briggs, TDK. Even if his body does hold up, I'm not convinced he averages 70-80 (especially with BJW in the side sharing the load).

NOD is an interesting one. If he slots in on a wing and stays fit, he can easily go ~80. But I'm not convinced he's in the best 23, and he can't stay fit.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I don't mind the English + Noddy + $130k option.

Could that cash be used elsewhere?

It's not $130k difference it would be $64k
It could be used to upgrade a $120k rookie to a high priced but already have about 5 $160+ rookies

 

[A Bit Dusty]

That makes more sense

If I had to choose, Xerri and NOD (although I currently have Xerri and Flynn)

I'm starting to get nervous with Flynn. Not only am I worried about his body, but he has a tough run: Witts, BigO, Darcy/Jackson, Briggs, TDK. Even if his body does hold up, I'm not convinced he averages 70-80 (especially with BJW in the side sharing the load).

NOD is an interesting one. If he slots in on a wing and stays fit, he can easily go ~80. But I'm not convinced he's in the best 23, and he can't stay fit.

The Freo board seem to think he is best 23 and all the Footy sites have him on a wing as well.
I think he would be a great player to start with, he can score well and will be a nice POD and worst case can be sideways traded to any Rookie scoring better.

Current High priced mid rookie ownership over $180k.

Lalor 30%
FOS 15%
Draper 44%
Jagga 64%
Ashcroft 55%
Allan 9%
Langford 14%
Noddy 2%

 

[stevebbb]

The Freo board seem to think he is best 23 and all the Footy sites have him on a wing as well.
I think he would be a great player to start with, he can score well and will be a nice POD and worst case can be sideways traded to any Rookie scoring better.

Current High priced mid rookie ownership over $180k.

Lalor 30%
FOS 15%
Draper 44%
Jagga 64%
Ashcroft 55%
Allan 9%
Langford 14%
Noddy 2%

On-field option? $200k on the bench is rough.

Jagga and Lalor are locks imo.

Then if you take one more at M8, you got a decision to make. Pretty sure Lashcroft is currently sidelined and he doesn't need to be rushed into the most stacked squad in the AFL. For me it's currently Maric vs Tsatas, but you make a good case, so I'll throw Noddy into the mix.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

On-field option? $200k on the bench is rough.

Jagga and Lalor are locks imo.

Then if you take one more at M8, you got a decision to make. Pretty sure Lashcroft is currently sidelined and he doesn't need to be rushed into the most stacked squad in the AFL. For me it's currently Maric vs Tsatas, but you make a good case, so I'll throw Noddy into the mix.

If I start NOD 100% it will be on field.
I have had Maric in and out of my team a couple of times and I'm not sure he has that HB role locked in.

 

[Raveneyes]

It's not $130k difference it would be $64k
It could be used to upgrade a $120k rookie to a high priced but already have about 5 $160+ rookies

Is that a typo? What am I even comparing?

total spend is $780k vs $908k. What is that extra ~$130k used for?

English and NOD, not English and Flynn. $130kish like Stevo said.

I liked your typo better.