Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[Obese Arachnid]

They got Willi etc .

Title of Kegs sex tape, amylrite VainGlorious .

 

[marcmurphy3]

Ok Kangas what are your thoughts on Sheezle vs Kerch?
There is $158,700 price difference between the two of them. Now I know Sheezle is a star but he might find it hard backing up a 118 average season especially if he goes forward a bit more. Kerch if he is playing Midfield probably isn't a great starter but if he has that HB role again he could go 100-105 and be a bargain at $476k

Thoughts?

buttox
Makeshift Park
FAILTOSUCCEED

Both. I reckon Kerch plays mainly back. Kangas have lots of options through the middle. Dont need him there atm. Would be wasted on a wing. Will be great watching he and Daniel chip the ball around to eachother. 100-105 Easy.

I could see Sheezel going 120+ if the Kangas improve. They arent going to give his midfield time to Phillips and Powell, regardless of how many touches they get against the roos vfl team in training. Him spending time at half forward just gives them a look at some different guys. He'll be in the guts come round 1.

 

[buttox]

Ok Kangas what are your thoughts on Sheezle vs Kerch?
There is $158,700 price difference between the two of them. Now I know Sheezle is a star but he might find it hard backing up a 118 average season especially if he goes forward a bit more. Kerch if he is playing Midfield probably isn't a great starter but if he has that HB role again he could go 100-105 and be a bargain at $476k

Thoughts?

buttox
Makeshift Park
FAILTOSUCCEED

I love them both obviously. But I think the sc board is sleeping on kerch a bit because he had a few injury games.
His first season average was elite it is comparable to daicos and sheez . I'm confident he improves it a fair bit this year and I've not heard anything from the club saying he is moving from hbf.
Sheez on the other hand is probably close to maxed out but more proven also. Less risk less of a punt.
Both works

 

[Makeshift Park]

Ok Kangas what are your thoughts on Sheezle vs Kerch?
There is $158,700 price difference between the two of them. Now I know Sheezle is a star but he might find it hard backing up a 118 average season especially if he goes forward a bit more. Kerch if he is playing Midfield probably isn't a great starter but if he has that HB role again he could go 100-105 and be a bargain at $476k

Thoughts?

buttox
Makeshift Park
FAILTOSUCCEED

We don’t have enough intel to make a call on either yet I think.

Too much uncertainty over their 2025 positions I reckon.

 

[Significant]

Brayshaw and Peatling
vs
Day and JHF

 

[Ash1337]

Brayshaw and Peatling
vs
Day and JHF

Day & JHF

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Ok Kangas what are your thoughts on Sheezle vs Kerch?
There is $158,700 price difference between the two of them. Now I know Sheezle is a star but he might find it hard backing up a 118 average season especially if he goes forward a bit more. Kerch if he is playing Midfield probably isn't a great starter but if he has that HB role again he could go 100-105 and be a bargain at $476k

Thoughts?

buttox
Makeshift Park
FAILTOSUCCEED

I have both currently.

If Sheezel plays too much forward in PS i will be dropping him.

Kerch should play HB mostly still in my opinion, with some stints in the middle. Ill back him to go 100+.

 

[King Max]

Brayshaw + English….
Serong + TDK….

 

[Amacca 23]

Just seen that in jhf last 11 games last year he had only 2 games over 100 i just dont get why youd pick him

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[King_Steele]

Brayshaw + English….
Serong + TDK….

Serong & TDK

 

[marcmurphy3]

Brayshaw + English….
Serong + TDK….

Serong plus TDK. I think Serongs gamestyle suits SC more then Brayshaw. Brayshaws ceiling us M6-8. Serongs is M1-3.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Just seen that in jhf last 11 games last year he had only 2 games over 100 i just dont get why youd pick him

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah, I dropped him after seeing that.

I think he'll improve and be F1-3, but dont think he has the consistency to see his price get out of reach. Even if he has an AA standard season he'll drop 3-4 shockers. There will be plenty of chances to get him for equal or less then his starting price.

 

[Amacca 23]

Yeah, I dropped him after seeing that.

I think he'll improve and be M1-3, but dont think he has the consistency to see his price get out of reach. Even if he has an AA standard season he'll drop 3-4 shockers. There will be plenty of chances to get him for equal or less then his starting price.

Exactly if you look at jhf v rankine and rankine first 6 rounds its a no brainer

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Just seen that in jhf last 11 games last year he had only 2 games over 100 i just dont get why youd pick him

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yet those 11 games still yielded a 93 ave

The first 10 games went at 105 ave

JHF is entering his 4th season of AFL .....typically we see more natural progression, with improved AFL fitness

 

[King_Steele]

Brayshaw and Peatling
vs
Day and JHF

Brayshaw & Peatling

 

[Amacca 23]

Yet those 11 games still yielded a 93 ave

The first 10 games went at 105 ave

JHF is entering his 4th season of AFL .....typically we see more natural progression, with improved AFL fitness

I get that wayne but they are 1 injury away from jhf having to play as a forward

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I get that wayne but they are 1 injury away from jhf having to play as a forward

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

I think the same can be said of Rozee, who came into the AFL system as a HFF

PORT are apparently changing their gameplan ....it's certainly a watch & see in the PS

Rankine, last year was his first getting significant CBA's (38%) ......if during the PS, he gets 50%+ CBA's he'll be a must ....we just need to see the impact of Peatling's role

 

[Amacca 23]

I think the same can be said of Rozee, who came into the AFL system as a HFF

PORT are apparently changing their gameplan ....it's certainly a watch & see in the PS

Rankine, last year was his first getting significant CBA's (38%) ......if during the PS, he gets 50%+ CBA's he'll be a must ....we just need to see the impact of Peatling's role

Im betting it will be and ANB role will have a lot to do with it

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[King Max]

Peatling or Pou….

Leaning towards Peatling more.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Peatling or Pou….

Leaning towards Peatling more.

Pou is cheaper and has DPP

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Pou is cheaper and has DPP

He also plays for St Kilda, not Adelaide

 

[Significant]

Peatling or Pou….

Leaning towards Peatling more.

I've found room for both. I'm not very bullish on Pou for some reason... had to predict break-outs and I think by the end of the season he will sit just below Top 6-8.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Peatling or Pou….

Leaning towards Peatling more.

Pou. Cheaper and a chance of being a keeper (given DPP).

 

[SaintWrld]

Peatling or Pou….

Leaning towards Peatling more.

I think pou is shaping to be a huge trap. Disregarding the fact people are selecting based off 4 games in which two were 80s he’s a very awkward price, who could you correct him to if he fails if you don’t keep any cash in the bank? I think pou will go an 80 average and peatling will go a 95. Both won’t be keepers.
Ross deploys a tagger in 50% of all games being the ultra defensive minded guy that he is, usually Windhager or Stocker last year, so every second game all those cbas will disappear because it won’t be taken from Steele and Macrae. Also the trio of Steele Macrae Poo would be the slowest midfield ever assembled, I don’t think it will be long until the likes of Sinclair are going through there again.
For an example, George Wardlaw is a far more advanced midfielder craft wise than pou, he was norths second fiddle midfielder with over 60% cba behind LDU, and he only averaged 85 last year. Not sure why people think poo will average more than this

 

[Sherman41]

I think pou is shaping to be a huge trap. Disregarding the fact people are selecting based off 4 games in which two were 80s he’s a very awkward price, who could you correct him to if he fails if you don’t keep any cash in the bank? I think pou will go an 80 average and peatling will go a 95. Both won’t be keepers.
Ross deploys a tagger in 50% of all games being the ultra defensive minded guy that he is, usually Windhager or Stocker last year, so every second game all those cbas will disappear because it won’t be taken from Steele and Macrae. Also the trio of Steele Macrae Poo would be the slowest midfield ever assembled, I don’t think it will be long until the likes of Sinclair are going through there again.
For an example, George Wardlaw is a far more advanced midfielder craft wise than pou, he was norths second fiddle midfielder with over 60% cba behind LDU, and he only averaged 85 last year. Not sure why people think poo will average more than this

Tagger doesn’t have to be at the CBA, they tend to locate them after the bounce from a wing or HFF.