Player Watch #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - has reportedly signed a 1yr deal & will be a Roo til end '25

[Sillygit]

right on cue

 

[Spud11]

“Did I just hear someone defend Phillips????”

 

[swaeney]

He's been putrid and his effort is not there.

Lmao do you honestly think that we’d have been 53 points up against Collingwood if he was not playing? Do you think that we’d be a kick off beating Melbourne, if he wasn’t playing? I’m sick of your shit posting on here every day just living in this thread.

I’m blocking you so I don’t have to see your diarrhoea anymore. I wish you the best and hope you can get the help you need.

 

[Junk yard]

Lmao do you honestly think that we’d have been 53 points up against Collingwood if he was not playing? Do you think that we’d be a kick off beating Melbourne, if he wasn’t playing? I’m sick of your shit posting on here every day just living in this thread.

I’m blocking you so I don’t have to see your diarrhoea anymore. I wish you the best and hope you can get the help you need.

No one can tell if we'd have won those games or lost by more. The fact is the coaches don't see the value in it, they also don't rate his performances in the two's, that is backed with facts. Thanks for the good wishes.

 

[The Warlord]

Love me a poster with an irrational dislike* of an individual player.

* My dislike of Aaron Hall

43

Aaron Hall

Age

33

Ht

185cm

Wt

85kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

19.0

5star

K

11.8

4star

HB

7.2

4star

M

3.6

4star

T

3.3

5star

MG

268.3

4star

D

14.9

4star

K

8.9

4star

HB

6.0

3star

M

2.3

2star

T

2.6

4star

MG

268.3

4star

D

13.2

4star

K

8.0

3star

HB

5.2

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

3.6

5star

was entirely rational.

 

[The acurate one]

Lmao do you honestly think that we’d have been 53 points up against Collingwood if he was not playing? Do you think that we’d be a kick off beating Melbourne, if he wasn’t playing? I’m sick of your shit posting on here every day just living in this thread.

I’m blocking you so I don’t have to see your diarrhoea anymore. I wish you the best and hope you can get the help you need.

The art of blocking revolves around the blockee not knowing they're blocked by the blocker.
It allows one to remain classy and respect the right of another to have an opinion, whether you agree doesn't matter. I reaslised many years ago you don't often succeed in changing peoples opinions.

Now it's a rather a busy night as I can see four posters online. lol

That fyi was a joke , the four posters bit, not the rest

 

[Horizons_00]

W.Phil has been consistent in the VFL? Just last week he got 22 disposals and 5 clearances?



He's putting in effort. I know I defend him a lot but....

 

[Spud11]

W.Phil has been consistent in the VFL? Just last week he got 22 disposals and 5 clearances?

View attachment 2051029

He's putting in effort. I know I defend him a lot but....

That’s super consistent and with that body of work people defending him aren’t biased. Just facts.

 

[Horizons_00]

That’s super consistent and with that body of work people defending him aren’t biased. Just facts.

To say he isn't putting effort in is ridiculous IMO

The amount of shinboner spirit and competitiveness he shown as a tagger this year has been immense too.

Heard from plenty of players in interviews that he trains hard too and has a great attitude, even though he gets dropped and elevated more than any other player

 

[Spud11]

To say he isn't putting effort in is ridiculous IMO

The amount of shinboner spirit and competitiveness he shown as a tagger this year has been immense too.

Heard from plenty of players in interviews that he trains hard too and has a great attitude, even though he gets dropped and elevated more than any other player

I saw him in action live and all this seems to be true - my respect for Will increased tenfold that day. I already rated him before that.

 

[Horizons_00]

I saw him in action live and all this seems to be true - my respect for Will increased tenfold that day. I already rated him before that.

I've always liked him. I know he wants to be a leader but that attitude is exactly what we need IMO

 

[Whereitallbegan]

The art of blocking revolves around the blockee not knowing they're blocked by the blocker.
It allows one to remain classy and respect the right of another to have an opinion, whether you agree doesn't matter. I reaslised many years ago you don't often succeed in changing peoples opinions.

Now it's a rather a busy night as I can see four posters online. lol

That fyi was a joke , the four posters bit, not the rest

This “blocking” thing. If one was actually interested in using said device, how would one go about it?…..asking for a friend
This is actually a genuine question, as I’m not sure and I’m building quite a considerable list.
PS: I hope you haven’t blocked me and get this message

 

[Makeshift Park]

This “blocking” thing. If one was actually interested in using said device, how would one go about it?…..asking for a friend
This is actually a genuine question, as I’m not sure and I’m building quite a considerable list.
PS: I hope you haven’t blocked me and get this message

 

[Whereitallbegan]

View attachment 2051149

Great, thanks for that, now I’d best get to work, I could be at this awhile
Oh, sorry, you didn’t make my list!!!

 

[R00StaR]

To say he isn't putting effort in is ridiculous IMO

The amount of shinboner spirit and competitiveness he shown as a tagger this year has been immense too.

Heard from plenty of players in interviews that he trains hard too and has a great attitude, even though he gets dropped and elevated more than any other player

And thats why we keep him, unless a club offers a deal mutually beneficial to both him and us.

He knows he needs a massive preseason and take his tank to the next level and only the foolish would doubt he'll do it. I love the kid's attitude and want him to make it almost as bad as he does despite him not being my pick in his draft. I wanted either Thilthorpe or Hollands who looked a bust up until this year.

Unfortunately for Will i think Mother's Milk Francis leaving has hurt him as much as anything. It meant we got the Warlord who i see plays the get down and dirty in and under style which Phillips is best suited. Its not hard to see, LDU, Sheezel, JHF and Phillips is pretty balanced. LDU, Sheez, Warlord and Phillips is less so.

That not to say he cant be worked into the rotations even if everyone is fit.

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

And thats why we keep him, unless a club offers a deal mutually beneficial to both him and us.

He knows he needs a massive preseason and take his tank to the next level and only the foolish would doubt he'll do it. I love the kid's attitude and want him to make it almost as bad as he does despite him not being my pick in his draft. I wanted either Thilthorpe or Hollands who looked a bust up until this year.

Unfortunately for Will i think Mother's Milk Francis leaving has hurt him as much as anything. It meant we got the Warlord who i see plays the get down and dirty in and under style which Phillips is best suited. Its not hard to see, LDU, Sheezel, JHF and Phillips is pretty balanced. LDU, Sheez, Warlord and Phillips is less so.

That not to say he cant be worked into the rotations even if everyone is fit.

I think one area we really need to look to bolster within our midfield stocks ever since JHF took flight is the petulant and selfish type who doesn't respond well under adversity, sulks, and gives away 50 metre penalties. We just don't have anything like that midfield archetype on our list. I wonder if WilPhil could develop that within his game.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Will's just a bit of an "almost" player for me at the moment.

I think it might be worth persisting for 1 more year as he has some positive attributes to work with.

But, he's obviously going to have to put in a hell of a lot of effort to cement his spot in the team.

 

[King Corey]

Got an uneasy feeling that the club will want to trade Will.

Reckon they'll look for a 2nd or 3rd rounder or outside chance trade him for a needs player (eg tall forward) not getting a game elsewhere.

Maybe finds himself in the same spot that Clarkson found himself 30 years ago.

Hope I'm wrong and we keep him.

 

[R00StaR]

I think one area we really need to look to bolster within our midfield stocks ever since JHF took flight is the petulant and selfish type who doesn't respond well under adversity, sulks, and gives away 50 metre penalties. We just don't have anything like that midfield archetype on our list. I wonder if WilPhil could develop that within his game.

I remember the AA captain being the same way.
And of course im not talking about character, im talking about the similar roles Wardlaw and Phillips play. Im perfectly fine with Wardlaw over JHF, its just not helped Phillips imo.
But you go ahead and spin it how you do.

 

[Ashley B]

Got an uneasy feeling that the club will want to trade Will.

Reckon they'll look for a 2nd or 3rd rounder or outside chance trade him for a needs player (eg tall forward) not getting a game elsewhere.

Maybe finds himself in the same spot that Clarkson found himself 30 years ago.

Hope I'm wrong and we keep him.

I would like us to keep Will. But said a couple of yrs back while we continue to use our draft picks for midfielders that we are likely to trade some for players we need ie key position types.

 

[The acurate one]

Got an uneasy feeling that the club will want to trade Will.

Reckon they'll look for a 2nd or 3rd rounder or outside chance trade him for a needs player (eg tall forward) not getting a game elsewhere.

Maybe finds himself in the same spot that Clarkson found himself 30 years ago.

Hope I'm wrong and we keep him.

And why is that a bad thing mate, the club needs to be brave.

1.LDU
2.Wardlaw
3.Simpkin
4.Sheezel
5.Powell

Give that group another 12 months, all will still have years left in them, if our backs and fwds could match them , we'd never lose another game.

And probably another mid added this year. I would though rather we did a trade for Phillips, dunno a small fwd who like Phillips has shown signs.

 

[pupstar]

W.Phil has been consistent in the VFL? Just last week he got 22 disposals and 5 clearances?

View attachment 2051029

He's putting in effort. I know I defend him a lot but....

I'm glad you do it is warranted .

 

[Chadwiko]

And why is that a bad thing mate, the club needs to be brave.

1.LDU
2.Wardlaw
3.Simpkin
4.Sheezel
5.Powell

Give that group another 12 months, all will still have years left in them, if our backs and fwds could match them , we'd never lose another game.

And probably another mid added this year. I would though rather we did a trade for Phillips, dunno a small fwd who like Phillips has shown signs.

Just my opinion of course, but Will Phillips is more talented than Tom Powell for my money.

Phillips is right at the top of the list for players I want kicking from a centre clearance to our forwards.

 

[Junk yard]

Just my opinion of course, but Will Phillips is more talented than Tom Powell for my money.

Phillips is right at the top of the list for players I want kicking from a centre clearance to our forwards.

More talented than Tom Powell?? I've heard it all now. Don't like admitting when you're wrong do you.

 

[Chadwiko]

More talented than Tom Powell?? I've heard it all now. Don't like admitting when you're wrong do you.

That's rich...