It would be a lot of the same posters, too. They can't see talent in advance, only finally acknowledging it when it's rammed down their throats.
I don't watch a lot of juniors so going in relatively blind and review based on performance. LDU sounded great on paper but didn't show it for a few years, injury seems to be the main culprit there. For as much as you say it is acknowledging talent in advance, sometimes it is admitting that there is a gap between talent and performance and for as much as there are those those that you miss talent in advance, there are plenty of others that prove to be correct. It is an opinion game and personal preferences play into it.