Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[Elton Johns Wig]

Because that's what you do now You are now highlighting a few lines . I posted that as an explanation on someone else's post. And you present them as conclusive evidence that I think that will be the reason Treloar will go to the Pies. If you would have read the previous quotes, you could have seen where I was referring too. Nuff said about that.
Anyway, we both agree it is circumstantial . And for the Tiger fans I will try to multi quote a bit more so that you don't start overreacting over nothing. Relax. We get Treloar, you get Motlop.

If you get Treloar, I hope we don't get Motlop. Refuses to run both ways, doesn't work hard enough.

 

[Bay Pie]

If you get Treloar, I hope we don't get Motlop. Refuses to run both ways, doesn't work hard enough.

If you get Treloar, I hope we don't get Motlop. Appears to have all the tools as an outside runner but oh so flaky.

 

[ryza87]

Motlop is a gun! He kicked three very important goals today.

 

[ryza87]

If you get Treloar, I hope we don't get Motlop. Refuses to run both ways, doesn't work hard enough.

He laid 11 tackles today...suggests he runs both ways

 

[CotchNCo]

He laid 11 tackles today...suggests he runs both ways

It actually suggests that he tackles a fair bit.

 

[TradeDraft]

Pies 1st Pick keeps getting Higher

 

[bluespooner]

Pies 1st Pick keeps getting Higher

It will still never get to pick 1 though. If Treloar were in the draft he would go number 1, so a pick around 10 and a player that collingwood doesn't want isn't equal to pick 1 or Treloar.

 

[ryza87]

It actually suggests that he tackles a fair bit.

Correct. And to tackle you have to run defencively to get to your opponent, to then lay the tackle.

 

[Bay Pie]

It will still never get to pick 1 though. If Treloar were in the draft he would go number 1, so a pick around 10 and a player that collingwood doesn't want isn't equal to pick 1 or Treloar.

When a player leaves his club and nominates just the one club, the club that he left never gets equal value at the time of trading.

It's always a case of getting the best you can. It's just the way the system works.

And I doubt any recruiter takes Treloar over Weitering at pick 1.

 

[jiphoc]

When a player leaves his club and nominates just the one club, the club that he left never gets equal value at the time of trading.

It's always a case of getting the best you can. It's just the way the system works.

And I doubt any recruiter takes Treloar over Weitering at pick 1.

A proven and young A grade potential elite midfielder would be overlooked as number 1? A lot of clubs would take the proven and still very young talent.

 

[pie time]

A proven and young A grade potential elite midfielder would be overlooked as number 1? A lot of clubs would take the proven and still very young talent.

being the potential that an interstate team finishes last, I don't think they would take him at pick 1 especially knowing he could go home in 2 years.

 

[jiphoc]

being the potential that an interstate team finishes last, I don't think they would take him at pick 1 especially knowing he could go home in 2 years.

So any team that finishes number 1 is only going to pick a player from their home state?

 

[pie time]

Did i say that did i? Why would Draft a player you already know wants to go home.

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

When a player leaves his club and nominates just the one club, the club that he left never gets equal value at the time of trading.

It's always a case of getting the best you can. It's just the way the system works.

And I doubt any recruiter takes Treloar over Weitering at pick 1.

Of course any recruiter would take Treloar over Weitering. Treloar has proven he is going to be a star.

 

[captain cotch 9]

Treloar is the one player from GWS that always talks about how much he loves the club and that he wants to be there from the start to when they are successfull.
He will re-sign IMO.
If he does go though I just hope he dosnt go to Melbourne!!!!! I hate those K-hunts

 

[TradeDraft]

Treloar is the one player from GWS that always talks about how much he loves the club and that he wants to be there from the start to when they are successfull.
He will re-sign IMO.
If he does go though I just hope he dosnt go to Melbourne!!!!! I hate those K-hunts

Well all the Talk is that he is not Staying.

What I am hearing IF he leaves it be Collingwood or Richmond

 

[captain cotch 9]

Well all the Talk is that he is not Staying.

What I am hearing IF he leaves it be Collingwood or Richmond

All the talk from where?
Do you have a source inside clubland or ru just reading the tabloids? No offence

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

so some 7 journalist said tigers leading the race for treloar

 

[Colonial]

All the talk was shiel had signed with tigs, jezza with adelaide, cogs with eagles. And yet.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[TradeDraft]

All the talk from where?
Do you have a source inside clubland or ru just reading the tabloids? No offence

Well I read people saying they know people in the Club that has said this.

But where there is Smoke there is Fire

so some 7 journalist said tigers leading the race for treloar

I think he is the Only 1 Saying That

 

[captain cotch 9]

All the talk was shiel had signed with tigs, jezza with adelaide, cogs with eagles. And yet.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

And Trelor is yet to re-sign.
If the media keeps guessing they will get one right

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Well I read people saying they know people in the Club that has said this.

But where there is Smoke there is Fire



I think he is the Only 1 Saying That

yeah probably a load of shit but I think we are in to him if we get him or not remains to be seen

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

All the talk was shiel had signed with tigs, jezza with adelaide, cogs with eagles. And yet.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

Cameron was never leaving.cogs is a loyal bloke.as for shiel he was the most likely to leave but he stuck around most of the tigers links came because his dating chocos daughter. why did he only sign for two years?

 

[pie time]

why has Treloar put negotiations on hold? seems fairly strange to a lot of people that 2 months ago he said he would stay, two months later his contract has been put off til the end of the year.

you would have to be blind not to see the writing on the wall.

 

[Roverjg]

why has Treloar put negotiations on hold? seems fairly strange to a lot of people that 2 months ago he said he would stay, two months later his contract has been put off til the end of the year.

you would have to be blind not to see the writing on the wall.

27 Sep 2013 - "I could sign (with Collingwood) before any sort of trade week period is up and that settles everything," Thomas told radio station Nova 100.
"And then everyone will have egg on their face and a lot of kids will have to get their No.13 jumpers out of the bin because apparently a lot of them are throwing them out."

3 Oct 2013 - Collingwood's decorated midfielder Dale Thomas is set to join Carlton as a free agent, with the Blues about to secure him on a four-year deal worth close to $700,000 a season.

Well it only took Daisy 6 days to change his mind