Preview AFL RD 15 - Collingwood vs Carlton - Changes and Prematch Discussion

[TradeDraft]

IN: Witts Keeffe/Reid Young

Out: Lynch Russell Williams/Sinclair

 

[Temploar]

IN: Witts Keeffe/Reid Young

Out: Lynch Russell Williams/Sinlair

I dont think Keeffe is ready, if Reid is not 100% then we don't need 2 tall defenders for the blues anyway.

In: Reid - Young - Witts - Krakouer
Out: Lynch - Sinclair - Macaffer - Kennedy

PLEASE can we just get a good side out there for once.

 

[Yidaki]

Think we might just get flogged by Carlton in this one. I'd rather we finish outside the 8. Can't stand this shit football at the moment.

 

[HeavyPop]

inb4 someone calls for Sinclair to be dropped.

 

[SuperSub17]

Words cannot describe how much I want to win this game.

Consign them to four losses in a row and almost wreck their finals chances

Sadly on current form we are no chance...

 

[Baird]

Why do you people want Sinclair to be dropped...?

 

[SuperSub17]

inb4 someone calls for Sinclair to be dropped.

/thread

Think we might just get flogged by Carlton in this one. I'd rather we finish outside the 8. Can't stand this shit football at the moment.

I'd much rather we make it. A finals win would just about best result from here and it would be great experience for the side going forward.

 

[Army13]

IN: Witts Reid Young

Out: Lynch Russell Sinclair

Williams is good, need him on betts/garlett

 

[blaze036]

In: Young - Gives us needed run and penetration
Reid(if fit) - Gun tall defender
Mooney - Fabulous in the VFL and gives us much needed pressure and speed
Krakouer - Deserves a game
Witts - Time to prepare him for 2014, can't do much worse than Lynch.

Out: Lynch - USELESS, 14 disposals, no points, no goals, NO TACKLES
Josh Thomas - Kicking is horrible and is too 1 dimensional
Sidebottom - Give him a kick up the sidebottom and maybe he'll come back the player of old
Blair - Just extremely costly with his turnovers, doesn't get a lot of the ball and doesn't do any scoreboard damage, lacks height and pace.
Sinclair - Shocking disposal, will be a liability in finals as he has a really weak body. Love his attitude though

 

[TheFreshBanana]

In: Reid, Krakeour
Out: Russell, Martin

I don't think there's a need for too many changes but Reid for Russell is an obvious one and I really think we need Krakeour up forward and Martin unfortunately gets the knock as I'd prefer Kennedy as sub.

 

[TradeDraft]

Words cannot describe how much I want to win this game.

Consign them to four losses in a row and almost wreck their finals chances

Sadly on current form we are no chance...

Same Here - I want to Smash the Scum and there Scum Coach MM.

If we win this game I can accept missing the Finals

 

[blaze036]

Why do you people want Sinclair to be dropped...?

Because he is a bad player??

 

[TheFreshBanana]

inb4 someone calls for Sinclair to be dropped.

No one really to handle Betts or Garlett outside of Williams and Sinclair.

 

[jayceontaylor]

out: hudson, martin, kennedy, russell
in: jolly, young, krakouer, reid

 

[blaze036]

In: Reid, Krakeour
Out: Russell, Martin

I don't think there's a need for too many changes but Reid for Russell is an obvious one and I really think we need Krakeour up forward and Martin unfortunately gets the knock as I'd prefer Kennedy as sub.

Did you watch the game

 

[mattys123]

We need Williams and Sinclair next week, they are the only half decent small defenders we have, and yes, you don't want either getting too much of the ball but they do their job defensively.

In: Jolly (please god), Reid (please god x 2), Krakouer (it has come to this), Young, Witts
Out: Martin, Kennedy (has had a run, time to go back), Russell, Lynch, Hudson

If there's less than 4 changes I will go off, tonight wasn't good enough and things need to change.

 

[blaze036]

No one really to handle Betts or Garlett outside of Williams and Sinclair.

Betts and garlett have both been in woeful form, shaw and williams can take care of them

 

[Yidaki]

Same Here - I want to Smash the Scum and there Scum Coach MM.

If we win this game I can accept missing the Finals

We won't win TD. Sorry mate. The scum will beat us...

 

[blaze036]

We won't win TD. Sorry mate. The scum will beat us...

Well.. we could win..?

 

[Baird]

Because he is a bad player??

But he was good tonight?? And has been the last 3 weeks

 

[Shade]

Not sure How anyone thinks Lynch is worth a game next week .

i miss chris dawes.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Did you watch the game

Yes I did but I'm just hoping that tonight is a massive wake up call.

I don't think the problem comes from 4 or 5 players that need to be dropped but it's as a team mindset. Just hoping it will be addressed.

TBH there aren't many great options that are waiting on the sidelines and I don't like the idea of rushing players back into the side.

 

[Baird]

In: Young - Gives us needed run and penetration
Reid(if fit) - Gun tall defender
Mooney - Fabulous in the VFL and gives us much needed pressure and speed
Krakouer - Deserves a game
Witts - Time to prepare him for 2014, can't do much worse than Lynch.

Out: Lynch - USELESS, 14 disposals, no points, no goals, NO TACKLES
Josh Thomas - Kicking is horrible and is too 1 dimensional
Sidebottom - Give him a kick up the sidebottom and maybe he'll come back the player of old
Blair - Just extremely costly with his turnovers, doesn't get a lot of the ball and doesn't do any scoreboard damage, lacks height and pace.
Sinclair - Shocking disposal, will be a liability in finals as he has a really weak body. Love his attitude though

awks...1 ineffective touch out of 19

 

[HeavyPop]

On the bright side, if anyone has a forward line that is as dysfunctional as ours, it's Carlton.

 

[blaze036]

But he was good tonight?? And has been the last 3 weeks

Okay sinclair is a great player... no point even arguing.