Preview AFL Round 10 - Collingwood vs Brisbane - Changes & Prematch Discussion

[Temploar]

Another week, another injury.

OUT: Russell(inj), Witts, Clarke ||| Maxwell, Kennedy
IN: Didak, Paine, Shaw ||| Johnson, Martin

(Johnson and Martin depending on VFL performance)

Need to go back to making 'wholesale' changes and getting our best team out there.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

OUT: Basically everyone bar Cloke, Ball and Pendles.
IN: A bunch of fans (some from this board) chosen from a try out session in the vein of the movie "Invincible" starring Marl Wahlberg.

 

[MeisterBot]

OUT: Basically everyone bar Cloke, Ball and Pendles.
IN: A bunch of fans (some from this board) chosen from a try out session in the vein of the movie "Invincible" starring Marl Wahlberg.

Bloke in your avatar doesn't deserve a call up?

 

[tazzawazza]

Another week, another injury.

OUT: Russell(inj), Witts, Clarke ||| Maxwell, Kennedy
IN: Didak, Paine, Shaw ||| Johnson, Martin

(Johnson and Martin depending on VFL performance)

Need to go back to making 'wholesale' changes and getting our best team out there.

If Bucks doesn't change (selection wise) I reckon we will actually lose to Brisbane and I wouldn't really mind it.

 

[tazzawazza]

OUT: Basically everyone bar Cloke, Ball and Pendles.
IN: A bunch of fans (some from this board) chosen from a try out session in the vein of the movie "Invincible" starring Marl Wahlberg.

How about Cafs? He has been awesome!!

 

[Temploar]

The shining lights from tonight:

Ball, Pendles, Cloke, Caff, Williams, Seedsman

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Caff won't be with us next week because he'll be taking over as God.

 

[MeisterBot]

Caff won't be with us next week because he'll be taking over as God.

Should tag Voss next week IMO. Hopefully that gives Bucks the advantage in the coaches box.

 

[tazzawazza]

Goodes abused, bad bad bad

 

[biggiemediums]

Out - 90% of the team.

In - anyone who'll even pretend to care about that beautiful Guernsey.

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

In: Shaw, Hudson, Didak, Paine, Johnson
Out: Russell (inj), Jolly (rest), Kennedy, Witts, Clarke (all omit)

Kennedy maybe a little unlucky but i think he needs a full game. Play Didak as a sub.

 

[SwanBet]

Thought i would make multiple changes now after such a pathetic loss.
*bucks will make about 1 change*

IN: T.Goldsack/J.Paine, A.Didak, B.Johnson, H.Shaw, B.Hudson
OUT: J.Witts, M.Clarke, J.Russell(inj), B.Kennedy(sorry), D.Jolly(suspended)

i would honestly consider playing Jolly and Hudson together the way the Q stick has performed in the last 4 weeks.

B: M.Williams, N.Brown, N.Maxwell
HB: H.Shaw, B.Reid, B.Johnson
C: H.O'brien, L.Ball, P.Seedsman
HF: J.Blair, Q.Lynch, S.Sidebottom
F: J.Elliott, T.Cloke, T.Goldsack/J.Paine
R: B.Hudson, D.Swan, S.Pendlebury
I: S.Dwyer, B.Macaffer, A.Didak
Sub: A.Krakouer(give him a little rest)

 

[35Daicos]

Good to see people here are being sensible and mature about the disappointing loss last night. I was really worried we'd see posters reacting badly.

 

[Pera]

Can someone tell me what happened to Russell? Thought he was one of our best tonight.

And why the f*** has Kennedy been sub three times in the last several weeks?

Give the kid a f****** go.

 

[100volt1]

Good to see people here are being sensible and mature about the disappointing loss last night. I was really worried we'd see posters reacting badly.

They all learnt from the win against Geelong

 

[half_back_flank]

Can someone tell me what happened to Russell? Thought he was one of our best tonight.

And why the f*** has Kennedy been sub three times in the last several weeks?

Give the kid a f****** go.

Limped off with a sore ankle, pretty sure he came back on but looked really proppy.

 

[Pera]

Limped off with a sore ankle, pretty sure he came back on but looked really proppy.

Hope its nothing major.

Seriously think he is best 18. Our whole backline has been under the pump lately.

 

[blaze036]

Can someone tell me what happened to Russell? Thought he was one of our best tonight.

And why the f*** has Kennedy been sub three times in the last several weeks?

Give the kid a f****** go.

First year player, doesn't have the fitness to play a full game.

 

[Pera]

First year player, doesn't have the fitness to play a full game.

Rubbish. No player should be sub three weeks on the trot, and if they dont have the fitness to play a full game, dont play them.

 

[blaze036]

Rubbish. No player should be sub three weeks on the trot, and if they dont have the fitness to play a full game, dont play them.

Who are you to say no player should be sub three weeks on the trot? fairly sure many AFL clubs have done it...

Gaff was the sub about 10 weeks in a row !

If they don't have the fitness to play a full game but the coach thinks they deserve a game then why not play them as a sub?

 

[premierpies13]

As long as Witts is out, completely fuc****g ridiculous that he has been carried for 3 weeks, embarrassing.

As soon as Keeffe strings some performances together id be putting heat on a bloke like Ben Reid, gone backwards at a million miles an hour

 

[premierpies13]

And i would drop one of our short people, to many blokes just to bloody small, draft some big bodied midfielders FFS

Blair should go IMO

 

[half_back_flank]

As soon as Keeffe strings some performances together id be putting heat on a bloke like Ben Reid, gone backwards at a million miles an hour

Clearly playing injured atm.

If Keeffe was up and running he'd be able to give Reid the rest he needs.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

I wish we would have the balls to try something different, like Ben Reid as a forward. Especially when Keeffe comes back.

 

[boxy99]

Out- coaching staff (no idea)