- Apr 10, 2014
- 21,971
- 60,770
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #101
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
AFLW AFLW List Management 2023-24
- Thread starter Marmozet
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Lol wtf.
Why would we give up pick 4 and the chance to get window , who is the standout player and a midfielder we absolutely need.
Sure, pick 14 still keeps us ahead of the crows pick 18 but it’s not hard to see that the crows could trade pick 18 up to 13 or earlier and get ahead of us.
Seems really weird to risk missing out on a star player so we can trade for a 29 yr old midfielder.
All I can think of is the dogs are playing hardball and / or were trying to hold onto pick 21 as we have our eyes on a 2nd player in the draft.
It’s just dumb.
Take window, do a trade with the dogs that doesnt jeopardise that.
Window has the chance to be what hatchard is to the crows for us. Don’t **** it up.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
If we can trade back and still get window, add lamb, and draft a player at 21 it looks like great business.
But I’m still not risking losing a player of windows quality for the chance to do that.
But I’m still not risking losing a player of windows quality for the chance to do that.
Malibu#27
Premium Platinum
Im no AFLW trade expert - so just reading through te trade wrap article, but it would appear to me that so long as we stay ahead of the Crows with our first pick we are guaranteed first call on Window.
14 sits ahead of 18, so that would be fine in isolation, however WB still need to get hold of 14, and the other issue is the Crows are trying to shake 11 out of Richmond for Montana McKinnon according to the same article.
So logic says we cant do this deal if we want Window until after McKinnon is traded and we know where we sit ... we cant afford the Crows to get 11 or another pick they can bundle with 18 to jump ahead of 14.
You also dont really want to to trade out 21 for Lamb as our next pick falls after the Crows and we surely want to take 2 of the top 3 SA girls on top of what we already have.
The only other moving part I see is Lily Johnson being linked to Melbourne, and I dont see any rumoured pick values associated with her but Melbourn currently have 5,19,26,56,75 so I assume one of these would be used. Which pick is used and the number of list spots we intend to use, may influence what we do.
14 sits ahead of 18, so that would be fine in isolation, however WB still need to get hold of 14, and the other issue is the Crows are trying to shake 11 out of Richmond for Montana McKinnon according to the same article.
So logic says we cant do this deal if we want Window until after McKinnon is traded and we know where we sit ... we cant afford the Crows to get 11 or another pick they can bundle with 18 to jump ahead of 14.
You also dont really want to to trade out 21 for Lamb as our next pick falls after the Crows and we surely want to take 2 of the top 3 SA girls on top of what we already have.
The only other moving part I see is Lily Johnson being linked to Melbourne, and I dont see any rumoured pick values associated with her but Melbourn currently have 5,19,26,56,75 so I assume one of these would be used. Which pick is used and the number of list spots we intend to use, may influence what we do.
Trade period closes in 5 minutes - gonna be a Dodoro-like frenzy finish...
I received an alert about an 11 team trade from the AFL.
If this is correct (as per Riley Bev tweet) then we are still ahead of the Crows in the draft order:
Last edited:
- Apr 10, 2014
- 21,971
- 60,770
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #113
So, after all that do we still have the draft pick to get Piper Window??
If Piper has nominated for state based draft then yes if we select her.
Pick 18 (Port) v Pick 22 (Crows).
Port Adelaide welcomes All-Australian Kirsty Lamb
Kirsty Lamb is heading to Port Adelaide as part of an 11-club trade deal.
Sounds like she goes OK, went AA in 2022 too
- Mar 2, 2014
- 6,870
- 1,876
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
I think we gave up too much in this mega draft in 1st round picks 4 & 21
Doesn't look like it, although I can't see why the final draft order can't be confirmed today - there's a delisted free agency window open tomorrow and Saturday, but that wouldn't involve compo picks. Maybe just confirming what list vacancies each club has:
Key dates for the 2023 AFLW Trade and Draft periods
Thursday, December 7Trade Period Opens
Restricted Free Agency Period Opens
Delisted Free Agency Period (1) Opens
Wednesday, December 13
Delisted Free Agency Period (1) Closes
Thursday, December 14
Trade Period Closes (2pm AEDT)
Restricted Free Agency Period Closes
Friday, December 15
Delisted Free Agency Period (2) Open
Saturday, December 16
Delisted Free Agency Period (2) Closes
Sunday, December 17
AFLW Draft Order confirmed
Monday, December 18
2023 AFLW Draft
Monday, February 5 2024
Supplemental Selection Period Open
Rookie Signing Period Open
Friday, March 1 2024
Supplemental Selection Period Closes
Rookie Signing Period Closes
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
If the Crows don't trade ahead of us we'll be drafting the same player with pick 18 as we'd have drafted with pick 4 anyway.
- Mar 26, 2007
- 21,278
- 45,954
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Anaheim Ducks, White Sox
Are Lily Johnson and Yasmin Duursma dating? Of course it doesn't matter, just curious. Seen a lot of pics with the 2 of them together, now appears they've both effectively moved to Melb together. Obviously at a minimum they must be great friends. I felt she was a player that certainly deserved more time, she had good skills was just super light.
- Mar 26, 2007
- 21,278
- 45,954
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Anaheim Ducks, White Sox
The trade is certainly us giving up a lot. Down grading 3 picks and losing Lily Johnson. However as per the above if we're still ahead of the Crows, the loss of 4 for 18 means nothing.
IF the crows don’t trade ahead of us
(I don’t know if there is draft day trading but I would assume so)
If we lost out on window that would be one of the worst bonehead moves in sports ever.
I wouldn’t do anything that even leaves a 1% chance of missing out on her.
she’s that dominant a mid.
I do think tho that they must be confident that it won’t happen or they wouldn’t have traded the picks away.
Ford Fairlane
Moderator
- Feb 21, 2002
- 81,991
- 202,390
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
- Moderator
- #123
At this point the crows could only trade future picks and who is going to give up much for their future first round pick when they consistently finish near or top of the ladder?
Ford Fairlane
Moderator
- Feb 21, 2002
- 81,991
- 202,390
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
- Moderator
- #124
Oh and 11 club trade, you have to tip your hat
- Apr 10, 2014
- 21,971
- 60,770
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #125
Tell you what, I’m crossing my fingers and toes that we get to play the Western Bulldogs next year.
They won the spoon this year and have been gutted even more by losing experienced players, so they’d be a near-guaranteed win for our girls.
They won the spoon this year and have been gutted even more by losing experienced players, so they’d be a near-guaranteed win for our girls.
