List Mgmt. Aisho Going Elsewhere

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
why is Aish worth 2 second rounders in the 20's plus something but Freeman was only just worth a future second rounder???
Because Aish came 4th in the rising star in his debut year whilst Freeman has never set foot on the park in two years?

Why is that so hard to understand?
 
Could we somehow trade in another future 2nd rounder so we have two for Brisbane.

We already have the saints one.
If North are involved, we only need 1 future 2nd round pick.
Brisbane: Bastinic & Pies 2016 2nd round
North: Pies pick 26 or 28
Pies: Aish

We go to draft with picks 26 or 28, 47, 63...
 

Log in to remove this ad.

We no longer have our 2 first rounders the next two years. I feel like we'd be better off using the picks to assist areas of need. Aish is not a need, he's a luxury. Midfield in general is not a need right now, unless we can pickup someone with elite speed and footskills. I feel like we are going after the cherry to put on top of the cake rather than looking at sorting the cake out which is far from finished at this point.

I disagree. Have you seen our kicking into the forward line lately? Those kicks usually come from midfielders and we currently don't have enough that have good kicking skills.
 
If North are involved, we only need 1 future 2nd round pick.
Brisbane: Bastinic & Pies 2016 2nd round
North: Pies pick 26 or 28
Pies: Aish

We go to draft with picks 26 or 28, 47, 63...


Didn't the Bastinac trade already go through? I'm sure I heard it on the radio earlier. I could be wrong as I'm almost deliriously sick.
 
Didn't the Bastinac trade already go through? I'm sure I heard it on the radio earlier. I could be wrong as I'm almost deliriously sick.
Nothing from Patrick Keane, i.e. didn't happen.
 
Aish is imperative. A player has nominatied us, he fits a need and he would flourish in our midfield.
You ok there big fella, you don't seem your usual self!

I agree 100%.

I reckon he'll be the final piece of a great trade period. Let's hope it's over early tomorrow, not sure i can handle going through another day like today
 
Aishpie_zpsu8ru3fiz.jpg
 
Pick 17 - North.
Pick 28 - North.

Bastinac - Brisbane.
Aish - Collingwood.

Would then flick 26 to North, they would flick 34 back. Would downgrade pick to sweeten deal.

Brisbane gain - Bastanic
North gain - Pick 17, 26 & 28.
Pies gain - Aish & 34.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Stay calm.

Hine and Pickers are involved and brokering the deal.
The people suggesting conspiracy theories are probably the same whack-jobs mooting that GWS were trying to screw us out of Treloar just two minutes before the deal today.

So long as Aish stands fat then we're in with a better than average shot.
 
The people suggesting conspiracy theories are probably the same whack-jobs mooting that GWS were trying to screw us out of Treloar just two minutes before the deal today.

So long as Aish stands fat then we're in with a better than average shot.

I have confidence in all parties to do this deal.
Hine seemed very confident despite admitting to a bit of work to be cleared up by tomorrow but that's the trade period.
 
From the sounds of things Norf and Brisbane are playing funny buggers...

Really not confident on this one as it stands.

If Brisbane play funny buggers and we don't get a trade done, they lose a highly rated player for nothing and we go to the draft with our two second rounders. They might be thick but they aren't that thick
 
What? He has to do what is in the best interest of his player. Either way Aish will be at Collingwood. It is what Pickering has said as soon as he nominated us and it will happen with out a trade or not.
He said he wants to go to Collingwood, so anything else would be "kidnapping".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top