Prediction Best 22 for Round One, 2017

[Rancid_Beasties]

Just my opinion but seeing David Astbury on the last line of defence still worries me greatly

Agree 100%...should have picked up Frost.

 

[_RT_]

Name Games Age Height Weight

B: Nick Vlastuin 80 22 187 86 David Astbury 60 25 195 93 Dylan Grimes 79 25 193 88

HB: Bachar Houli 149 28 180 83 Alex Rance 150 27 194 96 Kamdyn McIntosh 29 22 192 91

C: Brandon Ellis 110 23 181 81 Trent Cotchin 173 26 185 85 Connor Menadue 19 20 187 69

HF: Dustin Martin 153 25 187 88 Jack Riewoldt 202 27 195 91 Corey Ellis 17 20 184 75

F: Daniel Rioli 18 19 179 65 Ben Griffiths 61 25 200 101 Sam Lloyd 42 26 180 83

R: Shaun Hampson 98 28 201 106 Josh Caddy 95 24 186 84 Dion Prestia 95 24 175 82

Int: Toby Nankervis 12 22 199 106 Oleg Markov 8 20 188 73 Shane Edwards 187 27 182 80 Reece Conca 80 24 185 83

Averages:
Games - 87
Age - 24
Height - 188
Weight - 85.8

 

[TigerTank]

This "from the backline" stuff is so 1970s. Most country district league clubs use complicated rotations now that render a three-man follower division meaningless.
But who can resist? Certainly not me. I was born in the 70s.
So here's my marginally modernised version:

B: Houli Rance Grimes
HB: Vlaustin Astbury McIntosh
C: Grigg [mid rotation] Prestia
HF: Martin Griffiths Menadue
F: Lloyd Riewoldt Edwards

Int: B.Ellis Markov Rioli Nankervis

R1 - Hampson Cotchin Caddy Miles

then ...

R2 - Nankervis Cotchin Martin B. Ellis
R3 - Hampson Caddy Prestia Miles
R4 - Nankervis Martin Vlaustin Edwards
R5 - Griffiths Cotchin Caddy Prestia
etc.

emerg C. Ellis, Short, Conca,

 

[TigerImposter]

Still a huge weakness with Arseberry in the back half.

Chuckle chuckle

 

[TigerImposter]

Yep Caddy and Prestia are good pick
ups. Yarran very doubtful to play. It's going to be the fact we have too many C grade players still that will hold us back. I still count about 9

Yep and you're being generous

 

[bananatigz]

Yaz plays until the club indicates otherwise

B: Grimes, Astbury, Vlastuin
HB: Houli, Rance, McIntosh
C: B.Ellis, Cotchin, Yarran
HF: Martin, Griffiths, Rioli
F: Lloyd, Reiwoldt, Edwards
R: Hampson, Prestia, Caddy
I: Miles, Grigg, Nankervis, Markov

EMG from: Lennon, C.Ellis, Conca, Short, Menadue, Lambert, Drummond, Hunt

 

[fleabitten]

Best 22

FB: Vlastuin / Rance / Grimes
HB: Houli / Astbury / Yarran
C: B.Ellis / Martin / Grigg
HF: Edwards / Riewoldt / Caddy
FF: Rioli / Griffiths / Lloyd
Foll: Nankervis / Cotchin / Prestia
Int: Miles / Conca / McIntosh / Markov

A few guys there that still need to solidify themselves in the first team, but hopefully some others biting at their heels from the VFL

Reserve 22

FB: Morris / C.Moore / Batchelor
HB: Short / Chol / Hunt
C: Menadue / Townsend / C.Ellis
HF: Lennon / Elton / Castagna
FF: Butler / Maric / Soldo
Foll: Hampson / Lambert / Drummond
Int: A.Moore / Broad / DRAFT PICKS

Some exciting young players in there, plus some solid older players who can cover for injuries or poor form.

I'm assuming we promote and delist a few more guys to make list room for some rookie draftees.

 

[Snooza 100]

FB. Grimes/Astbury/Vlastuin
HB. Houli/Rance/Yarren
C. K,Mac/Prestia/BEllis
HF. Martin/Griff/Edwards
FF. Rioli/Reiwalt/Lloyd
Foll. Hampson,Cotch,Caddy
Int. Grigg,Miles,Markov,Menadue.

I put Caddy on ball cos i thought thats why he came to us.
That midfield looks great with Dusty switching through there.
I dont know much about Nankervis so i have Griff infront.
CEllis, Conca, Lennon, Morris and Lambet to push for games..

 

[Tango67]

Most realistic side I've seen so far.

weakest centre line in the afl....
Dusty runs one way
and double Ellis squibs on the wings

 

[TigerImposter]

weakest centre line in the afl....
Dusty runs one way
and double Ellis squibs on the wings

We can only put the available passengers to us on the Tiger bus.
Mate I'm not confident about next year, but we still have to look at what our options are.

 

[Bada Bing!]

B: Vlastuin - Astbury - Grimes
HB: McIntosh - Rance - Markov
C: B.Ellis - Martin - Menadue
HF: Caddy - Griffiths - Edwards
F: Rioli - Riewoldt - Nankervis
FOL: Hampson - Cotchin - Prestia
INT: Miles - Lloyd - Houli - Grigg

Pushing: Conca, Lennon, Broad, C.Ellis, Short, Drummond, Castagna, Pick 27, Pick 56, Pick 82, *Yarran (if he comes back),
Cloggers: Elton, Maric, Townsend, Hunt, Morris
DFA: Batchelor, A.Moore, Butler, Lambert
Rookies: Chol, Soldo, C.Moore (all re-rookie), Short (upgraded using Pick 100)

 

[exceptional design]

Just for fun I guess..

2016 shows only the 22 that played the most games for comparison.

2017 assumes that every player on the list is available.



If Yarran doesn't play, then I would bring in Short

I don't believe on gifting games. If the cubs are good enough, they will force their way into the side. I expect Short & Castagna will be the 1st ones to force their way in.
I have Griffiths and Nank changing on the bench. I prefer a mobile player on the ground than a ruckman resting in the forward line.

 

[SabreTooth]

You are all thinking outside the 4 walls

I am extremely confident Dimma is restructuring our best 22 as follows:

FB: Short
HB: Rance / Morris / Vlastuin / Houli / Astbury / Grimes / B.Ellis / Martin / Caddy / Prestia / Hunt
C: Cotchin
HF: Riewoldt
FF: Lloyd

Foll: Maric / Hampson / Grigg

Int: Conca / Griffiths / Rioli / Lambert

Emerg: Lennon / Batchelor / Nankervis / Vickery

 

[fleabitten]

Just for fun I guess..

2016 shows only the 22 that played the most games for comparison.

2017 assumes that every player on the list is available.

View attachment 303233

If Yarran doesn't play, then I would bring in Short

I don't believe on gifting games. If the cubs are good enough, they will force their way into the side. I expect Short & Castagna will be the 1st ones to force their way in.
I have Griffiths and Nank changing on the bench. I prefer a mobile player on the ground than a ruckman resting in the forward line.

You seem to share my love of spreadsheets (even when no number crunching is required). I have several google sheets that look a lot like the above.

 

[exceptional design]

You seem to share my love of spreadsheets (even when no number crunching is required). I have several google sheets that look a lot like the above.

I like to put things in snug fitting boxes

 

[Helen Wheels]

I like to put things in snug fitting boxes

Not mine, bucko.

 

[guruisatiger]

Guru's. Best Twenty Two
.
Bl.-Shorty -- Arseberry --.Rance

Hbl.-Houli -- Markov -- c.moore

Cln.- M.Tosh -- Caddy--- B.Ellis

Hfl. Lloyd. JR8. --- Edwards

Ff. Rioli --' Dusty.---- Cotchin

Ruck. - Nana K.- Vlaustin -- Prestia

Inter --Griff.-- Yazz - Cellis - Menadue

 

[living_in_syd]

Ashbury still in our best 22 is telling

Should have picked up a backman

 

[Helen Wheels]

Guru's. Best Twenty Two
.
Bl.-Shorty -- Arseberry --.Rance

Hbl.-Houli -- Markov -- c.moore

Cln.- M.Tosh -- Caddy--- B.Ellis

Hfl. Lloyd. JR8. --- Edwards

Ff. Rioli --' Dusty.---- Cotchin

Ruck. - Nana K.- Vlaustin -- Prestia

Inter --Griff.-- Yazz - Cellis - Menadue

Love your dangerous spirit of adventure. The forward six combination makes me tremble. I would name Rance at CHB and let the oppo guess, **** 'em.
He probably could dominate a game from BP. Wouldn't be surprised,

 

[richcogs]

To me that team does not look overally good. I dont understand what the jizzing type comments abouts. Line that team up against GWSs and you will have something then to be in awe of. Comparing their fringe players with our is where you can see the massive difference lies.

 

[Tiger_4_Life]

With Vickery finally out of the picture, I'm so excited for Griff. He's a much better player without that pea hearted jerk anywhere near the forward line, I reckon he'll thrive down forward with Jack.

 

[fleabitten]

Who cares how anyone compares to GWS. It's not a real team. It's Demetrenstein's monster. When they win their flags, the runner-up will be the real premier (unless it's GC).

 

[Goldust]

Depends how Griff and Astbury travel, if Griff finds consistency with Vickery gone and presumably not having to backup ruck, and Astbury can build on this year it doesn't look awful. I'm more worried about depth, Menadue, CEllis, Markov etc all need to start moving up a level, they're promising but we need people like BEllis pushed out of the team.

Getting Caddy would be nice

Griff is approaching year number eight and we are saying "if he finds cionsistency". I think we know the answer. Astbury a plodder - but we can't afford either to get hurt.

 

[Forensi Tiger]

Here is mine

B: 903RT Captain Cotch Tigerman22

HB: Grockadoc Wang Sunshine Tiger

C: Party Corolla Cogga Rules Bobby Sands

HF: Sassafras KakLaughing

 

[Forensi Tiger]

HF Sasafras JakLaughing Equuss

F: Goldust. Tiger Imposter Rodney Dangerfield

FOLL: Helen Wheels Mcuzzy Dr Mike