Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXVI - 'Loopy' Season in full swing

[agro]

Houston most likely to end up at Saints. Silvagnis (plural) are very much steering him away from Carlton. That includes Jack believe it or not.

Don’t think that’s Silvagni’s trade focus.

 

[Matty411]

Not sure how to feel about Matt Carroll being cut already but content with the others and wish them well.

Time for some fresh (and healthy) blood.

 

[YamandU]

The comment referred to not knowing why, but provided information.

Why is that a problem?

It’s just Surrey, just ignore it as I did .

 

[HarryFlashman]

I'd be loyal to the club that has paid me for 10 years and paid me handsomely.

Loyalty is given to friends and family well before your employer, regardless how well u are paid

 

[YamandU]

This crap being posted about Jack is rubbish, absolute lies.

And you know that how?

 

[macky99]

I love Jack, don’t think he’s going anywhere. Question was why would he say that & I have a reasonable & plausible answer.
Do I know that? Hell no, was just giving a possible answer

l don't believe there is any substance to what you are posting, this time of the year there are so many stories & rumours only a small % have substance.

 

[gab213]

Loyalty is given to friends and family well before your employer, regardless how well u are paid

And if this story was true it'd be the end of his AFL career, not just Carlton. No other club would want a player that engaged in something like that.

I think ensuring he maintained his well paid job would show loyalty to the responsibility he has to his own family. I'd like to see what friends are going to do fore him if he blows his career.

 

[HarryFlashman]

l don't believe there is any substance to what you are posting, this time of the year there are so many stories & rumours only a small % have substance.

There is was no substance at all - like I said, question was posed, I gave a plausible/reasonable answer.

 

[Blue Bloods]

100% u don’t believe everything.

Also 100% the players talk to each other & are critical about the clubs.
Would you be willing to bullshit a close mate to get him to come work for your company?

Obviously they can’t publishing that, neither could u if u wanted to keep your job but your a shit mate if u can’t be honest

My point was if he was talking down the club to a mate he wouldn’t talk so loud that a poster on BigFooty found out about it.

 

[HarryFlashman]

And if this story was true it'd be the end of his AFL career, not just Carlton. No other club would want a player that engaged in something like that.

I think ensuring he maintained his well paid job would show loyalty to the responsibility he has to his own family. I'd like to see what friends are going to do fore him if he blows his career.

Oh bullshit, players talk behind closed doors.
If it’s a close mate they are open and honest & the mate isn’t about to go running to the press.

 

[HarryFlashman]

My point was if he was talking down the club to a mate he wouldn’t talk so loud that a poster on BigFooty found out about it.

I agree

 

[macky99]

Houston most likely to end up at Saints. Silvagnis (plural) are very much steering him away from Carlton. That includes Jack believe it or not.

l don't believe that this is factual at all, you honestly believe Houston and his management would be taking that on board, seriously St Kilda will be going to the draft they have been burned recently going down the exact same path.
Most likely if he comes back to Melbourne it will be to one of the clubs in contention the next few years

 

[ESKIE]

Crikey loopy season alright

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

And you know that how?

Because I know what I know about Jack and the Silvagni family. Also if Houston comes to our club, Jack is one of the big reasons that I know for a fact.

SOS is a stubborn bloke but the lies about him and now Jack are rubbish.

SOS left the club years ago wonder why he hasn’t steered his own son away from the club too in the meantime.

 

[gab213]

Oh bullshit, players talk behind closed doors.
If it’s a close mate they are open and honest & the mate isn’t about to go running to the press.

If he was talking behind closed doors and it wound up in here id say he has problems including not having mates who are trustworthy. Its all just bs noise and you pick it up and run with it cause it suits the agenda you're pushing.

 

[BigFrizz36]

You’ve made my point Mason Cox beat those odds because of the better development coaching he received.

As John Lennon said "whatever gets you through the night".

Just bizarre that you are looking to argue about the development of Korcheck. You can have it without me from here on in

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Houston most likely to end up at Saints. Silvagnis (plural) are very much steering him away from Carlton. That includes Jack believe it or not.

that is very odd to read

 

[CrippaTheGoat9]

that is very odd to read

Because it’s made up

 

[SurreyBlue]

l don't believe that this is factual at all, you honestly believe Houston and his management would be taking that on board, seriously St Kilda will be going to the draft they have been burned recently going down the exact same path.
Most likely if he comes back to Melbourne it will be to one of the clubs in contention the next few years

It’s obvious he’s a StKilda supporter stirring trouble.

 

[Crippa#9]

Hopefully we rookie Marchbank

Why?

 

[HarryFlashman]

If he was talking behind closed doors and it wound up in here id say he has problems including not having mates who are trustworthy. Its all just bs noise and you pick it up and run with it cause it suits the agenda you're pushing.

I was not pushing the rumour at all. Gave a reason why.
Was pushing your “club/employer first” narrative & the ludicrous notion that u would put a club before a close mate & that the players all don’t talk about a whole heap of shit about stuff that would get anyone sacked.

 

[gab213]

I was not pushing the rumour at all. Gave a reason why.
Was pushing your “club/employer first” narrative & the ludicrous notion that u would put a club before a close mate & that the players all don’t talk about a whole heap of shit about stuff that would get anyone sacked.

Okay lmao, I'm pushing the 'ludicrous ' ideas? Silly me.

 

[SirSanchez]

Re the bluemour thread and the confirmed delistings.

Whilst I feel for the players being delisted, I’m also glad the club has made the call on those players and taken a more hard line approach. We cannot continue to carry that many injury prone players through another year.

 

[SurreyBlue]

Why?

it’s a position we have a need.
We’ll have a complete new team to work with him.
The guy has talent
We have rookie spots available and he’ll be worth it
Cost little and worth one more year as a rookie

 

[TheBlueCampaigner]

Crikey loopy season alright

Pull up a pew Eskie and enjoy the show