- Jun 3, 2015
- 515
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I think there was a bit of protection over the recruits he brought in, particular Setterfield.
Hewett is 100% there to replace Ed.
-
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Bluemour Melting Pot XXXII - Reaching fever pitch! š„ š„ š„
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I think there was a bit of protection over the recruits he brought in, particular Setterfield.
Hewett is 100% there to replace Ed.
How good would it be if someday, in the not too distant future, the Carlton Respects initiative could lead to a female member on our coaching panel.
Own The Future
Club Legend
- Nov 8, 2019
- 1,527
- 4,953
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Absolutely Ed can run all day, but Iām not sure he is the one Iād want delivering the ball inside 50. Seeing LOB repeatedly spear the ball onto the forwardās chest in the last few rounds showed what we have been missing. Helicopter punts from Ed are not what we need.
All that said I think Ed has a place in the team. The new pressure forward role sounds perfect for him.
So essentially SOS is advocating scenario B, for some unknown reason.
A) Ed Curnow and George Hewett in 2022, plus George Hewett for 2023-6.
B) Just Ed Curnow in 2022.
BringFevBack2021
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 9, 2021
- 7,567
- 16,496
- AFL Club
- Carlton
SOS can yak all he wants - just like Daisy Thomas, nothing positive to say about the club.
SOS brought Gorringe and Wright to the club in 2015. He also delisted Nick Holman in that same year.
Not sure what Gorringe and Wright were ever gonna do for the club, SOS.
FWIW Iād love him back at Carlton, I just think he has a vendetta on the club when realistically, it should be against the individuals. Heās the best player weāve ever had, one of the all time greats and a father to Jack, one of my favourite players.
Just please, stop the negativity SOS.
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #6,707
ex-player/administrator disagrees with some of ex-club's decisions..................prime minister calls emergency meeting of everyone ever.............
- Oct 10, 2016
- 3,084
- 7,339
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Im going to absolutely spit it if we lose 3 top ten draft picks sps, Dow and obrien that have been let down by the clubs poor culture and choice of coaches to other club for basically nothing
Bfevola
Senior List
- Oct 5, 2004
- 195
- 622
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
According to SOS we dont need any midfielders. And we dont need Hewitt cause we have Ed. Omg. No wonder our list is not balanced enough. He just wanted nice boys to be around his boys. Not bad influences, no rebels. No Extroverts. The list goes on.
And yes SOS was one of my favourite players, but I dont think he is the best list manager around.
And yes SOS was one of my favourite players, but I dont think he is the best list manager around.
Scenario C...as he stated...develop this relatively limited role player from within, if it is in fact required.
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #6,711
āIt was just a feeling of panicā: The long terrifying moments an earthquake shook Victoria
Deep in the High Country, 12 gold miners were hundreds of metres below ground when a 5.9-magnitude quake shook the earth around them. At first there was confusion and then a feeling of dread.
Mentioning Ed Curnow as a reason not to get Hewett is ridiculous imo. And it's not like we're sacrificing any trade collateral to get Hewett in, he's free.
Also Hewett may be a "relatively limited role player" but it is the lack of exactly these kinds of players that see us unable to arrest momentum/defend time and time again.
Hewett on moderate coin is an absolute no-brainer.
Do not agree about Wright, and thought he was ok for the club. For the brief time he was with us he served a small forward role quite well I believe. Agree about SOS and his being bitter towards the club, so hopefully he will move on under the new regime, especially with Liddle gone!!!
Last edited:
I think SOS is excellent at drafting talls, but no so much midfielders. Can't complain about our tall players he has drafted, Weiters, Charlie, Harry and TDK.
His son is becoming an integral part, and I actually think Cuningham is a very good player. Each time he finds form he gets injured. A matter of fact, injuries to a lot of these players have cost us growth.
- Oct 16, 2016
- 9,113
- 18,161
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Wright was a solid little player who did a great job at Carlton. Nothing but respect for him.
- Nov 14, 2012
- 12,354
- 20,250
- AFL Club
- Carlton
was just about to post thisā¦
Ed predominantly playing forward on the opposition main d50 exit.
spells in the twos teaching.
break glass cba option and sometime run with.
great club man
can absolutely coexist with Hewett
Whereās Dow going ?
Of course its not ridiculous. Like for like player...Ed is fit and durable, and could likely fulfill the defensive mid role to a good standard for another 2, perhaps 3 years. Can you play them both? Ed certainly doesn't have another position.
There are no free players.
It's a combination of poor coaching and team defense that creates the momentum swings...adding a 'defensive' mid is wallpapering over cracks.
JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
I thought JSOS was earmarked to replace Ed.
- Nov 14, 2012
- 12,354
- 20,250
- AFL Club
- Carlton
rumour is Tigers with his brother.
be pretty pissed if that eventuates.
particularly as hell have to work with Teague.
That first final where the Giants beat Sydney by a point, I thought Hewett was Swans` best player as he played consistently all game and never stopped competing, so he will be a good get because he just does his job well.
He is much more effective as a defensive winger than a pressure forward. LOB can attack from the other wing if he can nail that spot
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
why would dow go to the tigers
Heās contracted still ?
- Status
