Brodie Holland in "every teams" starting 18? ( 1 2)

[White Czar]

Originally Posted by Alkaline
Holland would make almost every teams start 22 if not 18.

I propose not.

I doubt Holland would get a gig for:

- Sydney
- WCE
- Adelaide
- St Kilda
- Geelong

And doubtful for

- Roos
- Melbourne
- Port
- Western Bulldogs

If not over clubs.

 

[Rozza44]

Id say only St.Kilda and West Coast he wouldnt get a start in the midfeild.
People dont take this kid seriously coz of his modelling and Dancing with the Stars but he is a really handy player and can shutdown important players.

 

[F/D]

He is also attacking.

Can kick goals.

Would make anyside.

 

[~GURU~]

No chance, he would struggle to make the Weagles for sure

 

[Alkaline]

No chance, he would struggle to make the Weagles for sure

Your not getting my point Bentleigh. I said "almost every side" not "Every single side"

 

[Alkaline]

No chance, he would struggle to make the Weagles for sure

weather he plays in the mid-feild or back or forward there will be room for him. There always an easy swap. Staker out, Holland in.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

He'd get games for melbourne. Maybe not every game but he'd play.

 

[White Czar]

I'm quite sure I could name 18 better players at

- Sydney
- WCE
- Adelaide
- St Kilda
- Geelong

Than our friend Brodie. Almost half the league. Thus I dont understand how "almost every team" has much chop about it.

 

[Alkaline]

I'm quite sure I could name 18 better players at

- Sydney
- WCE
- Adelaide
- St Kilda
- Geelong

Than our friend Brodie. Almost half the league. Thus I dont understand how "almost every team" has much chop about it.

So 5 teams out of 16. Thats majority of the league mate.

 

[F/D]

Holland > Skipworth
Holland > Lynch
Holland > McVeigh
Holland > Tenace/Byrnes
Holland > Blake

 

[Bloodz]

No chance, he would struggle to make the Weagles for sure

You mean the Eagles that play Adkins off the bench all the time???

 

[Crow-mosone]

lol is this the same brodie holland we've watched hack it up for years?

 

[bresker]

People would take him more seriously if he wasn't a C-grade celebrity.

The Tamsyn Lewis syndrome:

http://www.heraldsun.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5478,17217568%5E14822,00.html

You could say that many people would be forgiving about Fevola if he didn't arse around on the Footy Show & on stage at nightclubs.

 

[Milkman]

You mean the Eagles that play Adkins off the bench all the time???

Just a slight exaggeration.

He played a grand total of 7 games this year.

 

[Bloodz]

Just a slight exaggeration.

He played a grand total of 7 games this year.

If he is getting 7 games then saying Holland wouldn't crack that side is ridiculous

 

[lenny&carl]

lol is this the same brodie holland we've watched hack it up for years?

No not really, because he has improved a lot lately. Still not a worldbeater, but he actually would get a game for most teams for whatever that's worth.

 

[hotpie]

weather he plays in the mid-feild or back or forward there will be room for him. There always an easy swap. Staker out, Holland in.

Or Casey Green out, Holland in
Or Matera out, Holland in
Or Nikoski out, Holland in
Or Sampi out, Holland in

 

[carn_the_cattas]

Holland > Tenace/Byrnes

They would'nt be in our best 18.

Geelong's midfield would have players like King, Bartel, Ling, Ablett, Kelly, Enright, Wojcinski, Chapman, Corey, Milburn etc

 

[skywalk750]

I would take him. But best 22 is more accurate than best 18

 

[Pie 4 Life]

He would make the best 18 in every team, whether in the midfield or in the forward line.

 

[thommoone]

Brodie Holland better than Jarod McVeigh, atm yes.
But Holland in the Swans 22 no, because Mcveigh is not atm either, he might wellbe by years end though improvement is needed. If u notice the last game the swans played (2005 AFL grand final) then u would notice while McVeigh was fit he was still not selectedin the 22, or even the 25 for that matter

 

[F/D]

They would'nt be in our best 18.

Geelong's midfield would have players like King, Bartel, Ling, Ablett, Kelly, Enright, Wojcinski, Chapman, Corey, Milburn etc

Holland > Monica

 

[F/D]

Brodie Holland better than Jarod McVeigh, atm yes.
But Holland in the Swans 22 no, because Mcveigh is not atm either, he might wellbe by years end though improvement is needed. If u notice the last game the swans played (2005 AFL grand final) then u would notice while McVeigh was fit he was still not selectedin the 22, or even the 25 for that matter

Holland > Dempster

 

[carn_the_cattas]

Holland > Monica

Wojcinski only played 2 games in '05. You can't judge him on that, he was in pretty good form though.

Brodie Holland is a good player but the Pies can keep him. If he came to Geelong he might be in the best 22 but I don't think he'd be in the starting 18.

 

[Milkman]

If he is getting 7 games then saying Holland wouldn't crack that side is ridiculous

Didn't say he wouldn't crack the side. If we copped a few injuries and he's tearing it up in the WAFL like Adkins was, then he'd probably get a gig.